Technical field of the invention
[0001] The present invention relates to a multi-level organic Rankine cycle system (ORC
system) equipped with a single regenerator.
[0002] The adopted solution is particularly suitable for organic Rankine cycle systems built
on multiple levels, in which there is a notable difference between the evaporation
temperature and the condensation temperature of the organic working fluid.
Background art
[0003] As is known, a thermodynamic cycle is defined as a finite succession of thermodynamic
transformations (for example isothermal, isochore, isobaric or adiabatic) at the end
of which the system returns to its initial state.
[0004] Such cycle can be direct, for example an ORC cycle (Organic Rankine Cycle), in which
a thermal source is used to produce mechanical/electrical energy and heat at a lower
temperature than that of the thermal source, or it can be inverse, for example a heat
pump in which electrical energy is used to transfer heat from a source at a lower
temperature to one at a higher temperature.
[0005] In particular, an ideal Rankine cycle is a thermodynamic cycle composed of two adiabatic
and two isobaric transformations. In the case of a direct cycle, its purpose is to
transform heat into work. This cycle is generally adopted especially in thermo-electrical
power systems for the production of electrical energy and uses water as a driving
fluid, both in liquid form and in form of steam, with the so-called steam turbine.
[0006] More specifically, organic Rankine cycles (ORC) have been hypothesized and implemented
that use high molecular mass organic fluids for the most diverse applications, in
particular also for the exploitation of low-medium enthalpy thermal sources. As in
other steam cycles, the system for an ORC cycle includes one or more feed pumps for
moving the organic working fluid in the liquid state from the low pressure zone to
the high pressure zone, at least one heat exchanger (also called pre-heater or evaporator,
depending on the function performed) to perform the preheating, vaporization and possible
superheating or heating phases in supercritical conditions of the same working fluid,
at least one turbine for the expansion of the fluid, mechanically connected to an
electrical generator, a condenser that returns the organic working fluid to the liquid
state.
[0007] It is also known that in ORC cycles the use of high molecular mass organic fluids
very often involves the need to introduce, downstream of the turbine and upstream
of the condenser, a further heat exchanger called a 'regenerator' or 'recuperator'
which recovers a good portion of the sensible heat of the low pressure organic fluid
vapor, which heat is used to preheat the organic working fluid in the liquid phase
downstream of the cycle feed pump and upstream of the pre-heater.
[0008] In many applications the type of regenerator used is the 'finned coil' type (Tube
Fin Heat Exchangers, also called 'finned coil heat exchangers'), commonly used also
in the civil sector, for air heat pumps, for coolers or condensers in general, to
release or absorb heat from the ambient air.
[0009] In traditional multi-pressure level ORC cycles, typically one turbine is used for
each level, which converts the enthalpy change of each level into mechanical energy.
[0010] The turbine exhaust is a very important section at a thermodynamic level as a load
loss in this area greatly affects the generation of electrical energy, since this
load loss constitutes a back pressure that adds to the condensation pressure, reducing
the expansion ratio that the turbine can exploit. It is therefore essential to take
the best care of this exhaust area, by minimizing load losses. Each turbine, in known
configurations, has its own exhaust that leads to a regenerator, which is made of:
- tube side: a working fluid in liquid state coming from the pump, at the pressure of
the level that is appropriate for that turbine, and
- shell side: a steam exhausted from the turbine.
[0011] In ORC cycles according to the state of the technique it is usual to have a regenerator
for each pressure level; each regenerator has the function of recovering the enthalpy
of the steam, which typically is very superheated, bringing it closer to saturation,
to the benefit of the liquid phase which, under pressure, is far from its saturated
state and due to the heat exchange in the regenerator, approaches the saturation condition,
relieving the incoming heat source from this task, so as to increase cycle efficiency.
Fig. 1 represents the scheme of an ORC cycle system 100, at two pressure levels, made
according to known technique with two turbines and two separate regenerators. The
solid lines represent the path of the organic working fluid, the dashed lines the
path of the heat source. The high pressure cycle 110 comprises an evaporator 120,
a turbine 130, mechanically connected to an electrical generator 140, a regenerator
150, a condenser 160 and a feed pump 170. The cited components perform the functions
described above. Similarly, the low pressure cycle 110' comprises an evaporator 120',
a turbine 130', mechanically connected to the same electrical generator 140, a regenerator
150', a condenser 160' and a feed pump 170'.
[0012] Each regenerator 150, 150', in ORC cycles according to the state of the technique,
therefore exchanges heat between the vapor phase and the liquid phase of the same
process fluid, in particular, between the exhaust vapor phase of a respective turbine
120, 120' and the liquid phase delivered by the respective feed pump 170, 170'.
[0013] With reference to figures 2a and 2b, in other cases it is convenient to use, always
according to the known technique, a two-pressure level cycle having a single turbine,
comprising axial or radial and axial stages. An example of this second solution is
described in the Applicant's patent
EP 2805034 B1. In this case, therefore, the turbine discharge is single and the traditional scheme
involves the use of two separate regenerators, which can be arranged, with reference
to the vapor side, in parallel (as in Fig. 2a) or in series (as in Fig. 2b) . In particular,
figure 2a represents the scheme of an ORC cycle system 200 (always with two pressure
levels), in which the high pressure cycle 210 comprises an evaporator 220, a turbine
230, mechanically connected to an electrical generator 240, a regenerator 250, a condenser
260 and a feed pump 270. The low pressure cycle 210' includes an evaporator 220',
the same turbine 230 as the high pressure cycle, the electrical generator 240, a regenerator
250', a condenser 260' and a feed pump 270' .
[0014] In this system the exhaust steam flow 235 from the turbine 230 is divided into a
first flow 245 which feeds the regenerator 250 of the high pressure cycle 210, and
a second flow 245' which feeds the regenerator 250' of the low pressure cycle.
[0015] Figure 2b represents the scheme of an ORC cycle system 300 (always with two pressure
levels), in which the high pressure cycle 310 comprises an evaporator 320, a turbine
330, mechanically connected to an electrical generator 340, a regenerator 350, a condenser
360 and a feed pump 370. The low pressure cycle 310' comprises an evaporator 320',
the same turbine 330 of the high pressure cycle, the electrical generator 340, a regenerator
350', the same condenser 360 of the high pressure cycle and a feed pump 370'.
[0016] According to the diagram in figure 2b, the exhaust steam flow 335 from the turbine
330 is first conducted into a first regenerator 350, at high pressure, and then into
a second regenerator 350', at low pressure.
[0017] In summary, the scheme in figure 1 presents the variant with two single turbines
in parallel, each operating on its own reference pressure levels (high pressure cycle
and low-pressure cycle), whereas the schemes in figures 2a and 2b present the configuration
with a single turbine for the two pressure levels.
[0018] In any case, whatever the scheme adopted, the two regenerators (high and low pressure)
are two separate components, each with its own casing. This implies an increase in
construction and system complications and, consequently, in ORC system costs. Furthermore,
in some applications, these system schemes according to the state of the art for cycles
with multiple pressure levels introduce a loss that reduces the overall performance
of the system due to the back pressures created by the circuit complication downstream
of the two steam flows, exhausted from the single turbine or from the two separate
turbines.
Summary of the invention
[0019] The solution to the technical problems referred to in the previous paragraph is obtained,
according to the present invention, with a single regenerator for ORC systems with
two or more pressure levels. Such a regenerator comprises at least two finned batteries
and a single containment casing. According to one aspect of the present invention,
therefore, a multi-pressure level organic Rankine cycle system is described, the regenerator
of which is provided with a single casing containing more than one battery and having
the characteristics set forth in the independent product claim annexed to the present
description.
[0020] Further preferred and/or particularly advantageous ways of implementing the aforementioned
system are described according to the characteristics set out in the attached dependent
claims.
Brief description of the drawings
[0021] The invention will now be described with reference to the attached drawings, which
illustrate some non-limiting embodiments of a regenerator for multi-level ORC systems,
wherein:
- figure 1 schematically illustrates a scheme of a two-pressure level ORC system, equipped
with two turbines and two separate regenerators, each capable of receiving the steam
at the turbine outlet and the liquid at the pump outlet of the reference cycle, according
to known technique,
- figure 2a schematically illustrates a scheme of a two-pressure level ORC system, equipped
with a single turbine that processes, in different stages, the steam coming from the
two cycles, one of high pressure and one of low pressure, with parallel regenerators,
according to known techniques,
- figure 2b schematically illustrates a scheme of a two-pressure level ORC system, equipped
with a single turbine that processes, in different stages, the steam coming from the
two cycles, one of high pressure and one of low pressure, with regenerators in series,
according to the known technique,
- figure 3 illustrates a single regenerator for a two-pressure level ORC system, according
to a preferred embodiment of the present invention, and
- figure 4 schematically illustrates a scheme of a two-pressure level ORC system, equipped
with a single turbine that processes, in different stages, the steam coming from the
two cycles, one of high pressure and one of low pressure, with the single regenerator
of figure 3 and with a parallel power supply of the regeneration batteries contained
within it.
Detailed description
[0022] The single regenerator, according to the present invention and the relative ORC system
with multiple pressure levels that comprises it, will be described below with reference
to figures 3 and 4 in which a single regenerator for an ORC system with two pressure
levels and the relative ORC system are illustrated in an exemplary and non-limiting
manner. The invention, by means of considerations known to a person skilled in the
art, is equally relevant to ORC system with more than two pressure levels.
[0023] In the following description and considering, for example, two pressure levels, such
pressure levels of the ORC system will be defined for simplicity as "high pressure"
and "low pressure" and are to be understood as the pressures delivered by the respective
feed pumps to the organic working fluid. The pressure levels are conveniently chosen
based on the fluid and the properties of the thermal source, in such a way as to have
the ratio between the maximum pressure of the high-pressure cycle and the maximum
pressure of the low-pressure cycle comprised between 1.5 and 2.7. The maximum pressure
of the high-pressure cycle does not exceed 34 bar absolute and that of the low-pressure
cycle does not fall below 10 bar absolute, and in any case the ratio between the maximum
pressure of the high-pressure cycle and the maximum pressure of the low-pressure cycle
falls within the range indicated above. The upper limit for the high-pressure cycle
of 34 bar absolute is a physical limit imposed by the type of fluid used: it is generally
preferable not to exceed 80% of the critical pressure of the fluid, so as not to suffer
the effects of instability due to proximity to the critical point.
[0024] The lower limit of 10 bar for the low-pressure cycle is instead an indication of
a technical-economic nature: if for example the low pressure cycle were to be established
at a pressure level below the value of 1.5 - 2.7, compared to the high-pressure cycle,
its presence would be difficult to justify in terms of economic convenience compared
to a single-level cycle. We can therefore say that these pressure levels are mutually
correlated both by physical aspects and by cycle optimization aspects, in the case
of two-level cycles.
[0025] A single regenerator 50 for a multi-pressure level ORC system according to the present
invention, comprises a casing 55 containing within it at least one finned battery
for each pressure level of the ORC system. In the illustrated example, the casing
55 comprises three high-pressure finned batteries 60 and a further two low-pressure
finned batteries 65 and a parallel power supply of the regeneration batteries contained
therein is achieved. It should be noted that, regardless of the number of finned batteries,
what is most relevant is that the pressure ratio cited above (comprised between 1.5
and 2.7) also influences the ratio between the exchange surfaces of the at least one
high-pressure battery with respect to the at least one low-pressure battery: such
ratio is conveniently chosen in a similar way to the pressure ratio and this is conveniently
comprised between 1 and 3.
[0026] The steam flow 12 that hits the regenerator 50 is that coming from the turbine exhaust,
whereas within the finned batteries there is a flow of liquid phase 10, 15 corresponding
to a pressure level of the cycle (Fig. 4): if a cycle has two pressure levels, within
the casing 55 of the regenerator 50 there will be at least two finned batteries 60,
65, each of which regenerates a pressure level.
[0027] Typically, such solution is suitable for geothermal systems in which the characteristics
of the thermal source tend to increase the size of the system components and to conveniently
use a multi-level pressure cycle. In the case studied the thermal source cannot be
cooled below a limit temperature (for example, to avoid a precipitation of the salts
contained within it) and regeneration is therefore advantageous to respect this constraint,
as preheating the organic liquid reduces its capacity to cool the geothermal source;
furthermore, the multi-level cycle allows to optimize the thermodynamic efficiency
despite the limitation on the re-injection temperature of the thermal source.
[0028] According to the present innovation, therefore, the single steam flow 12 exiting
the turbine enters the single casing of the regenerator, is divided into 2 parallel
steam flows and hits the high-pressure and low-pressure batteries.
[0029] The liquid phase organic working fluid from the working fluid feed pumps circulates
in the finned batteries 60, 65 of the regenerator 50, which are divided into a high-pressure
side and a low-pressure side within a single casing 55. The turbine exhaust steam
flow 12 flows as a single flow in the casing and heats both the high-pressure and
low-pressure finned batteries.
[0030] Within the regenerator casing 55, it may be preferable to insert baffles to convey
the steam towards the regenerator batteries in a more orderly and homogeneous manner.
[0031] According to an alternative solution, as illustrated in figure 3, instead of the
baffles there can be a plurality of perforated plates 57, 58, with a variable number
of holes so as to have the same steam flow passing through all the finned batteries
60, 65.
[0032] Although not described, the present invention can also be effectively used to create
a series power supply of the batteries, by installing suitable stem divisions and
baffles within the casing.
[0033] With reference to figure 4, an example of an organic Rankine cycle system 100 with
a thermodynamic cycle at two or more pressure levels (two in the described configuration)
and using the single regenerator solution, is described below.
[0034] The system 400 includes:
- a first high pressure evaporator 20 and a second low pressure evaporator 25, to heat
and vaporize (possibly also to superheat) respective flows of organic working fluid
(hereinafter, more simply, a working fluid),
- a turbine 30 for expanding working fluid vapor flows, downstream of evaporators 20,
25. The turbine, conveniently, may be a single turbine, comprising only axial stages
or radial and axial stages and having two inlets for respective working fluid flows
and a single outlet for an expanded vapor flow. The system, however, may alternatively
comprise two separate turbines, one for high pressure and one for low pressure,
- an electrical generator 40 mechanically connected to the turbine 30 for the production
of electrical energy,
- a single regenerator 50, downstream of the turbine 30, provided with a single casing
55 and containing at least a first high pressure battery 60 and at least a second
low pressure battery 65. The regenerator 50 operates by transferring heat from the
exhaust steam flow from the turbine 30 to respective flows of working fluid in liquid
phase,
- a condenser 70, downstream of the regenerator 50, to condense the expanded vapor flow,
and
- a first feed pump 80 and a second downstream feed pump 85 for compressing, at high
pressure and low pressure, respective flows of working fluid in liquid phase.
[0035] The system can also be equipped with appropriate control valves 90, 95, to regulate
the working fluid flows.
[0036] The flow (indicated by dotted lines) of the thermal source 5 used, for example a
geothermal source, from a withdrawal point 5' (THERMAL SOURCE IN) passes through the
first high pressure evaporator 20 and the second low pressure evaporator 25 sequentially,
releasing heat to the respective working fluid flows, to reach then a reinjection
point 5" (THERMAL SOURCE OUT). Different and more efficient schemes than those schematically
reported here can be adopted to create a cycle with 2 or more pressure levels such
as the one reported in
GB 2 162 583 A (in this scheme, however, the regenerators are not present.
[0037] The organic working fluid (whose paths are represented by solid lines) is a single
flow in the vapor phase, from the exhaust of the turbine 30 to downstream of the condenser
70, whereas it is divided into two flows at high pressure and low pressure, concerning
the rest of the path. More precisely, a single flow 12 of working fluid in the vapor
phase departs from the exhaust point 12' of the turbine 30, downstream of all the
expansion stages of the turbine itself, and passes through the regenerator 50 and
the condenser 70. At the outlet of the condenser, evidently, there will be a single
flow 12 of working fluid, but in the liquid phase. Once a branch 12" is reached, the
working fluid is divided into two flows: a first flow 10 is sucked by the first feed
pump 80 and compressed at high pressure, whereas a second flow 15 is sucked by the
second feed pump 85 and compressed at low pressure. Alternatively, instead of two
separate pumps in parallel, it may be convenient to have a single line on which a
first low pressure pump is installed which processes the sum of the two required flow
rates and a second pump in series which, starting from the main flow rate, detaches
and pressurizes the fraction needed to feed the high-pressure cycle.
[0038] The first flow 10 of working fluid, in liquid phase and at high pressure, passes
through the regenerator 50 and, more precisely, the high pressure battery 60, to absorb
heat from the expanded vapor flow 12. It then reaches the first high pressure evaporator
20, to heat up further and vaporize and finally, through a first inlet 10', it reaches
the turbine 30, upstream of all the expansion stages of the turbine itself.
[0039] The second flow 15 of working fluid, in liquid phase and at low pressure, passes
through the regenerator 50 and, more precisely, through the low pressure battery 65,
to absorb heat from the expanded vapor flow 12. It then reaches the second low pressure
evaporator 25, to heat up further and vaporize and finally, through a second inlet
15', it reaches the turbine 30 in an intermediate expansion stage of the turbine itself.
[0040] The solution according to the present invention, in which a single regenerator is
used for two or more levels of an ORC system, has several advantages.
[0041] The main advantage lies in the fact that the regenerator requires a single casing,
therefore the construction simplification of the component is notable.
[0042] As a result, the cost of the component and the costs associated with its maintenance
are also significantly reduced.
[0043] Furthermore, such solution does not require that the steam flow exhausted from the
turbine be separated, or divided into two different flows to reach the two separate
regenerators, as is currently the case: this is a further advantage as the back pressure
that would be created in the division of the two flows would in fact be added to the
condensation back pressure, reducing the enthalpy jump in the turbine and, depending
on the application, risking to penalize the cycle efficiency.
[0044] Another advantageous feature of this unique regenerator is that it powers the two
high pressure and low pressure batteries, in parallel, with the same temperature difference.
In fact, if the finned batteries were put in series, the second battery downstream
of the first could receive heat at too low a temperature, with consequent problems
of condensation of the exhaust steam from the turbine and/or problems of insufficient
heat exchange.
[0045] If it is true that such feature can also be obtained with two separate regenerators
in parallel as per the state of the art (scheme in Fig. 2a), the present invention
does not imply problems of balancing the steam flow rates in the two different channels,
ensuring better regeneration efficiency.
[0046] In addition to the ways of implementing the invention, as described above, it is
to be understood that there are numerous further variations. It is also to be understood
that said ways of implementing are only exemplifying and do not limit either the object
of the invention, or its applications, or its possible configurations. On the contrary,
although the above description makes it possible for a skilled person to implement
the present invention at least according to an exemplifying configuration thereof,
it is to be understood that numerous variations of the described components are conceivable,
without thereby departing from the object of the invention, as defined in the attached
claims.
1. Organic Rankine cycle system (400) with two or more pressure levels, operated by a
flow (5) of thermal source and by flows (10, 12, 15) of working fluid, the system
(400) being
characterized by the fact that, in combination:
- the system (400) includes a single recuperator (50) provided with a casing (55)
which contains within it at least one finned battery (60, 65) for each pressure level
of the system (400), and
- the recuperator (50) is configured to carry out a heat exchange between a single
flow (12) of working fluid in the vapor phase and two or more flows (10, 15) of working
fluid in the liquid phase, in which each flow (10, 15) of working fluid in the liquid
phase is at a different pressure level and flows into at least one respective finned
battery (60, 65).
2. System according to claim 1, wherein the organic Rankine cycle is at two pressure
levels and the ratio between the maximum pressure of the higher pressure level and
the maximum pressure of the lower pressure level is between 1.5 and 2.7.
3. System (400) according to claim 1 or 2, wherein inside the casing (55) the ratio between
the exchange surface between the at least one high pressure battery (60) and the at
least one low pressure battery (65) is between 1 and 3.
4. System (400) according to any of the previous claims, wherein within the casing (55)
of the recuperator (50) there is at least one baffle to convey the steam towards the
finned coils (60, 65) of the regenerator (50).
5. System (400) according to any of claims 1 to 3, in which within the casing (55) of
the recuperator(50) there is a plurality of perforated plates (57, 58) with a variable
number of holes in order to have the same steam flow rate that passes through all
the finned coils (60, 65).
6. System (100) according to any of the previous claims, further comprising:
- a first high pressure evaporator (20) and a second low pressure evaporator (25),
to heat and vaporize respective flows (10, 15) of working fluid,
- an expansion turbine (30) downstream of the evaporators (20, 25).
- a condenser (70), downstream of the recuperator (50), to condense the single flow
(12) of working fluid in the vapor phase, and
- a first feed pump (80) and a second downstream feed pump (85) to compress, at high
pressure and at low pressure, respective flows (10, 15) of working fluid in the liquid
phase.
7. System (100) according to claim 6, in which the turbine (30) is a single turbine,
comprising only axial or radial and axial stages and having two inlets for respective
flows (10, 15) of working fluid and one outlet of the single flow (12) of working
fluid in vapor phase.
8. System (100) according to any of the previous claims, in which the heat source flow
(5) is configured to pass through, from a withdrawal point (5'), sequentially, the
first high pressure evaporator (20) and the second low pressure evaporator (25) and
then to reach a reinjection point (5").
9. System (100) according to claim 8, wherein the thermal source is a geothermal source.
10. System (100) according to any of claims 6 to 9, wherein the single flow (12) of working
fluid in vapor phase is configured to start from an exhaust point (12') of the turbine
(30) and to pass through the recuperator (50) and the condenser (70).
11. System (100) according to one of claims 6 to 10, wherein a first high-pressure flow
(10) of the two or more flows (10, 15) of working fluid in liquid phase is configured
for:
- being sucked in by the first feed pump (80) and compressed at high pressure,
- passing through the high-pressure battery (60) of the regenerator (50),
- passing through the first evaporator (20) at high pressure, and
- through a first inlet (10'), reaching the turbine (30) upstream of all the expansion
stages of the turbine itself.
12. System (100) according to one of claims 6 to 11, wherein a second low pressure flow
(15) of the two or more flows (10, 15) of working fluid in liquid phase is configured
for:
- being sucked in by the second feed pump (88) and compressed at low pressure,
- passing through the low pressure battery (65) of the regenerator (50),
- passing through the second evaporator (25) at low pressure, and
- through a second inlet (15'), reaching the turbine (30) in an intermediate expansion
stage of the turbine itself.