CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS
TECHNICAL FIELD
[0002] The present invention relates to a protective coating for components exposed to high
temperatures, such as components of a gas-turbine engine.
BACKGROUND ART
[0003] As is known, the operating environment inside a gas-turbine engine is both thermally
and chemically hostile to the materials that are exposed to it.
[0004] A long-established solution has been to protect the materials with a thermal barrier
coating (TBC) system. The latter generally includes a thermal insulating ceramic layer
applied to the substrate by means of a bonding layer. Hereinafter, in the present
document, the bonding layer will be referred to by the term "bond coat", which is
commonly adopted in the industry.
[0005] Metal oxides, such as for example zirconium oxide (ZrO2), which is partially or completely
stabilized by yttrium oxide (Y2O3), were employed for the thermal insulating ceramic
layer. In recent years, more complex oxides, such as for example lanthanum, cerium,
neodymium, or ytterbium and gadolinium zirconates, have also been used instead of
yttrium oxide, although in limited applications. The ceramic layer can be deposited
by means of different deposition techniques, such as air plasma spray (APS), physical
vapor deposition (PVD), electron beam physical vapor deposition (EBPVD), suspension
plasma spray (SPS). APS is often preferred over other deposition techniques due to
the low cost of equipment and the ease of application and masking. In particular,
the adhesion mechanism for plasma-sprayed ceramic layers takes place via mechanical
interlocking with a bond coat having a relatively rough surface, in particular with
a Ra between about 9 and about 19 µm.
[0006] Bond coats are typically formed from an oxidation-resistant alloy such as MCrAlY+N,
or from a diffusion aluminide or platinum aluminide forming an oxidation-resistant
intermetallic, or a combination of both.
[0007] In the MCrAlY+N alloy, M is iron, cobalt, and/or nickel, while N denotes one or more
possible, but not necessary, elements selected from the group composed of silicon,
rhenium, tantalum, iridium, and/or others, with specific functions, such as for example
the reduction of the aluminum diffusion coefficient within the coating.
[0008] Bond coats made with such compositions protect the substrate by forming an oxidation
barrier for the substrate itself. In particular, the aluminum content of these bond
coats allow the slow growth of a dense layer of adhesive aluminum oxide (alumina scale)
at high temperatures. This oxide scale protects the bond coat from further oxidation
and improves the bond between the ceramic layer and the bond coat itself.
[0009] The oxidation of the bond coat cannot be avoided because the thermal insulating ceramic
layer is unable to avoid the diffusion of oxygen in the solid state or its permeation
through porosity and microcracks, which must be present to reduce the thermal conductivity
and brittleness of the ceramic coating.
[0010] The chemical composition of the bond coat results from a compromise between different
needs, in terms of relative quantities of the several elements. In fact, a bond coat
must have many properties that are not perfectly compatible with each other. These
properties refer to (a) the chemical compatibility with the base material; (b) the
thermal expansion coefficient similar to that of the base material; (c) the lowest
possible transition temperature from ductile to brittle; (d) the high resistance to
crack formation, low crack propagation velocity, and high resistance to thermal fatigue;
(e) the high resistance to hot corrosion (this property is not crucial in many modern
very high-efficiency turbines); (f) the high resistance to oxidation (which becomes
even more important if the overlying thermal insulating ceramic layer detaches, because
the anchor temperature rises to much higher values, even 200 °C higher); (g) the formation
of a dense and highly adhesive oxide scale, adapted to tightly maintain the adhesion
of the overlying thermal insulating ceramic layer; (h) the resistance to damage and
contamination due to post-coat deposition machining processes (general thermal treatments
and, in particular, brazing and cooling hole machining).
[0011] While properties (a)-(d) require a limited aluminum content (about <5% by weight)
and ensure excellent compatibility with the base material, properties (f)-(h) require
a high aluminum content (>8% by weight) and are aimed at achieving an excellent bond
coat surface behavior. Finally, property (e) requires a high chromium content (>28%
by weight), which is not, however, compatible with properties (f)-(h).
[0012] For example, a bond coat with an aluminum quantity >12% showed excellent resistance
to oxidation and excellent adhesion of the thermal insulating ceramic layer but, at
the same time, showed poor fatigue resistance, with the formation of cracks which
propagated to the base material. In contrast, a bond coat with an aluminum content
<4% showed strong reactivity with the carbon present in the atmosphere of a thermal
treatment furnace, with the formation of a reaction layer on its surface, which was
poorly adapted for the adhesion of the thermal insulating ceramic layer.
[0013] One of the problems that research had to address in this field related to the premature
detachment of significant parts of the thermal insulating ceramic layer after a number
of operation hours lower than expected. This detachment necessarily involves an overheating
of the areas that are no longer protected, in some cases leading to the formation
and propagation of cracks in the base material.
[0014] Generally, since hot corrosion was a phenomenon as feared as oxidation, bond coats
have always had a composition which was relatively poor in aluminum (<7%) and very
rich in chromium (about 30% or slightly lower) . Furthermore, in order to ensure good
performance in terms of anchoring of the thermal insulating ceramic layer to the bond
coat, a thin (between 0.05 and 0.1 mm) but rougher layer of the same composition was
deposited onto the bond coat.
[0015] For a more complete understanding of the problem that the present invention aims
to solve, the evolution in the bond coat deposition technique must be taken into consideration.
For productivity reasons, very often the vacuum plasma spray technique, used for both
the main layer in contact with the material to be protected and the rough surface
layer, has been replaced by the HVOF (High Velocity Oxygen Fuel) technique for the
main dense part and by the air plasma spray technique for the rough surface layer
(which is called APS flash; flash because it is thin). Such replacement is still ongoing,
and the number of parts coated with vacuum plasma spray is still decreasing.
[0016] Despite representing a benefit from a production viewpoint, the use of HVOF and air
plasma spray techniques has nevertheless resulted in problems relating to premature
detachment of the thermal insulating ceramic layer. In fact, the rough surface layer,
when deposited with HVOF employing a coarse powder, does not often achieve optimal
roughness, while when deposited with the APS flash technique, it tends to form mixed
oxides, which have poor adhesion when its composition is low in aluminum. Furthermore,
instead of a dense aluminum oxide scale, such poorly adhesive mixed oxides also form,
and often especially, at relatively low temperatures, even as low as 750 °C.
[0017] There was a need for a technical solution that could ensure the adhesion of the thermal
barrier to the base material for periods longer than those of the prior art, regardless
of the techniques with which the bond coat thereof is deposited.
DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0018] In order to meet the above-mentioned need, the inventors of the present invention
made a bond coat composed of two distinct layers consisting of two different chemical
compositions. In this way, the functions of the bond coat have been separated into
the two layers composing it.
[0019] An object of the present invention is a thermal barrier fixed to a surface of a material
exposed to high temperatures; said thermal barrier comprising a bond coat layer fixed
to the surface of the material to be protected and a thermal insulating ceramic layer
fixed to the bond coat layer; said thermal barrier being characterized in that said
bond coat comprises a first and a second layer distinct from each other and both composed
of a MCrAlY + N alloy; wherein M is selected from Ni and Co, and N is selected from
the group composed of Re, Ir, Si, Ta and Pt; said first and second layers having a
different % by weight of the elements;
- said first layer being in contact with said surface of the material to be protected
and composed of 2 to 7% by weight of Al, 0.5 to 2% by weight of Y, 10 to 35% by weight
of Cr, 0 to 5% by weight of N and a % by weight of M to complete 100;
- said second layer being fixed to said first layer and composed of 8 to 14% by weight
of Al, 0.5 to 2% by weight of Y, 10 to 20% by weight of Cr, 0 to 5% by weight of N
and a % by weight of M to complete 100;
- said first layer having a thickness between 100 and 500 µm, preferably between 180
and 300 µm, and said second layer having a thickness less than or equal to 150 µm,
preferably between 10 and 70 µm.
[0020] Preferably, said second layer has a surface with a roughness Ra between 8 and 23
µm, more preferably between 12 and 20 µm.
[0021] Preferably, said first layer is composed of 4 to 6% by weight of Al, 0.5 to 1% by
weight of Y, 20 to 28% by weight of Cr, 0 to 2.5% by weight of N and a % by weight
of M to complete 100.
[0022] Preferably, said second layer is composed of 10 to 12% by weight of Al, 0.5 to 1%
by weight of Y, 13 to 17% by weight of Cr, 0 to 2.5% by weight of N and a % by weight
of M to complete 100.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0023] Hereafter embodiments of the present invention will be described for illustrative
and non-limiting purposes together with the accompanying figures, in which:
- Figure 1 is a schematic view of the thermal barrier according to the invention; and
- Figure 2 is a chart where the experimental results of the cyclic oxidation tests are
reported.
PREFERRED EMBODIMENT OF THE INVENTION
[0024] In the figure, reference numeral 1 denotes, as a whole, a thermal barrier fixed by
deposition to the surface 2 of a material 3 to be protected against high temperatures.
[0025] The thermal barrier 1 comprises a thermal insulating ceramic layer 4 and a bond coat
layer 5, which is composed of a first layer 6 fixed to the surface 2 of the material
3 to be protected, and a second layer 7 fixed to a surface 8 of the first layer 6
on the opposite side to the material to be protected.
[0026] The first layer 6 and the second layer 7 are made with a MCrAlY + N alloy; wherein
M is selected from Ni and Co, and N is selected from the group composed of Re, Ir,
Si, Ta and Pt.
[0027] The first 6 and second 7 layers can be discerned from each other by the different
% by weight of the elements in the alloy.
[0028] The first layer 6 has a composition made up of 2 to 7% by weight of Al, 0.5 to 2%
by weight of Y, 10 to 35% by weight of Cr, 0 to 5% by weight of N and a % by weight
of M to complete 100.
[0029] Materials corresponding to the above-described composition relating to the first
layer 6 are commercially available under the trade names Amperit 418, NI535, Amdry
2231, CO 301, Amperit 422, Amdry 995, Amperit 415, and CO 210.
[0030] The second layer 7 has a composition made up of 8 to 14% by weight of Al, 0.5 to
2% by weight of Y, 10 to 20% by weight of Cr, 0 to 5% by weight of N and a % by weight
of M to complete 100.
[0031] Materials corresponding to the above-described composition relating to the second
layer 7 are commercially available under the trade names NI 832, Amperit 436, Amdry
2464, Amperit 429, NI 944, Amperit 428, NI 937, and Amperit 416.
[0032] The inventors made a series of specimens reproducing the thermal barrier according
to the invention and tested their effectiveness compared to specimens reproducing
the thermal barriers according to the prior art.
[0033] For a more complete evaluation of the advantages of the invention, the bond coat
of the specimens was produced with different deposition techniques.
[0034] The deposition techniques used in the examples were low pressure plasma spray (LPPS)
for both layers, or high velocity oxygen fuel (HVOF) for the first layer and air plasma
spray (APS) for the second layer.
[0035] Table I below reports the compositions of the bond coats of the specimens made together
with an indication of the technique used.
Table I
| Specimen |
First layer |
Second layer |
| Bond coat according to the invention |
| 1 |
Amperit 418.117 (LPPS) |
Amperit 436 (LPPS) |
| 2 |
Amperit 418.117 |
Amperit 429 (LPPS) |
| |
(LPPS) |
|
| 3 |
Amperit 418.724 (HVOF) |
Amperit 436 (APS) |
| 4 |
Amperit 418.724 (HVOF) |
Amperit 429 (APS) |
| 5 |
Amperit 422 (HVOF) |
Amperit 429 (APS) |
| Comparison bond coat |
| 6 |
Amperit 418.11720 (LPPS) |
Amperit 418.715 (LPPS) |
[0036] The thickness of the first layer was equal to 180 µm and the thickness of the second
layer was equal to 75 µm.
[0037] The base material used for the specimens 1-6, and on which the respective bond coats
were deposited, was the nickel-based superalloy MarM247.
[0038] Furthermore, the same thermal insulating ceramic layer consisting of zirconia partially
stabilized with 7% by weight of yttria was deposited onto each specimen with the air
plasma spray (APS) technique. The presence of yttria leads to the formation of a "non-transformable"
tetragonal phase, which avoids the phase transformation between tetragonal and monoclinic
phase typical of pure zirconia; such transformation is undesirable because it is accompanied
by a volume change, which produces stresses in the coating and potential detachment
from the bond coat. Different compositions, with a greater percentage of stabilizer,
can be used, as well as several other compositions, normally applied as a second ceramic
insulating layer on top of the usual one.
[0039] The thermal insulating ceramic layer used in the specimens has a thickness equal
to 0.5 mm and a porosity equal to 16%.
[0040] The thickness values reported above were obtained in the metallographic section at
a temperature of 20 °C by an optical microscope with a graduated scale in the eyepiece.
[0041] The specimens described above underwent cyclic oxidation tests in a furnace and (simulated)
brazing heat treatment tests.
[0042] The cyclic oxidation tests were carried out according to a procedure whose characteristics
are reported below:
- A tubular furnace was used, operated manually for the introduction and removal of
the specimens, set to 1100 °C.
- Daily cycles were performed, leaving the specimens in the furnace for 23 hours and
out of the furnace for 1 hour each day, with visual inspection. In this way, 4 cycles
per week were performed.
- Over the weekend and Monday, the specimens remained in the furnace for 71 hours and
on Monday out of the furnace for 1 hour.
- Each week, the specimens remained at a high temperature for 163 hours and underwent
5 cooling cycles to room temperature.
- The test ended with the detachment of the thermal insulating ceramic layer. The exposure
time at high temperature that caused such detachment constituted the result, referred
to as "FCT life" (these tests are normally denoted by the acronym FCT, namely Furnace
Cyclic Test).
[0043] The simulated brazing test was performed by placing the specimens in an industrial
furnace together with a filler of actual components undergoing brazing treatment (typically
between 1150 and 1190 °C). The specimens were not in contact with the brazing alloy,
but were at the same temperature and in the same atmosphere as the actual components,
thus undergoing the same contamination risk.
TEST RESULTS
[0044] Table II reports the results of the FCT test on the 6 specimens in Table I. For a
proper evaluation of the results in Table II, the related deposition technique used
must be taken into account. In fact, the low pressure plasma spray (LPPS) technique
is more efficient but also more expensive and available from only a few suppliers,
as well as less suitable for coating components that already have cooling holes (for
example, used and repaired components that need to be re-coated before a second operational
life); while the HVOF + APS flash technique is less expensive and readily available
from all coating manufacturers for gas-turbine components.
Table II
| Specimen |
FCT life (h) |
Average |
| 1 |
3588 |
4008 |
4148 |
3915 |
| 2 |
3507 |
3565 |
3588 |
3553 |
| 3 |
3387 |
3527 |
3550 |
3488 |
| 4 |
3573 |
3876 |
3993 |
3814 |
| 5 |
3527 |
3667 |
3667 |
3620 |
| 6 |
3461 |
3461 |
3565 |
3496 |
[0045] For a more immediate display of the results, the values in Table II are also reported
in the chart in Figure 2.
COMMENTARY ON THE RESULTS
[0046] With regard to the bond coats deposited with the more expensive LPPS technique, the
specimens 1 and 2 of the present invention, whose results are represented by the first
two columns of the chart in Figure 2, are improved in terms of cyclic oxidation resistance
(FCT test) compared to the reference with uniform composition (column 6).
[0047] With regard to the bond coats deposited with the HVOF + APS flash technique (columns
3, 4, and 5 of the chart in Figure 2), which is less expensive, more readily available,
and more suitable for repairing and restoring components that have already been used,
it can be seen that the results obtained were either comparable or higher to reference
6. In this regard, it should be considered that the HVOF + APS flash technique produces
surface layers that are already partially oxidized, and thus perform inherently less
with the same powder composition than those produced with LPPS.
[0048] The simulated brazing test compared the bond coat 6 (Amperit 418.117/Amperit 418.715,
all LPPS) with bond coat 1 (Amperit 418.117/Amperit 436, all LPPS) and showed that,
by using an aluminum-rich composition for the second layer, the formation of a reaction
layer mainly made up of chromium carbide, which is brittle and poorly adapted to maintain
the adhesion of the overlying ceramic insulating layer, is avoided.
[0049] In the case of comparison bond coat 6, an uneven layer of Cr23C6 particles was visible,
and immediately below it, a blackish aluminum oxide layer mixed with other oxides.
Further below, a thicker area being lower in chromium is visible, as such element
is spread onto the surface to form the unwanted reaction layer.
[0050] In contrast, in the case of the bond coat 1 of the invention, no microstructure formed
by chromium carbide was visible under the optical microscope, while under the electron
microscope a very thin layer (about 0.5 µm) of dense aluminum oxide was visible on
the surface.
1. A thermal barrier fixed to a surface of a material exposed to high temperatures; said
thermal barrier comprising a bond coat layer fixed to the surface of the material
to be protected and a thermal insulating ceramic layer fixed to the bond coat layer;
said thermal barrier being
characterized in that said bond coat comprises a first and a second layer distinct from each other and
both composed of a MCrAlY+N alloy; wherein M is selected from Ni and Co, and N is
selected from the group composed of Re, Ir, Si, Ta and Pt;
- said first and second layers having a different % by weight of the elements;
- said first layer being in contact with said surface of the material to be protected
and composed of 2 to 7% by weight of Al, 0.5 to 2% by weight of Y, 10 to 35% by weight
of Cr, 0 to 5% by weight of N and a % by weight of M to complete 100;
- said second layer being fixed to said first layer and composed of 8 to 14% by weight
of Al, 0.5 to 2% by weight of Y, 10 to 20% by weight of Cr, 0 to 5% by weight of N
and a % by weight of M to complete 100;
- said first layer having a thickness between 100 and 500 µm and said second layer
having a thickness less than or equal to 150 µm.
2. The thermal barrier according to claim 1, characterized in that said first layer has a thickness between 180 and 300 µm.
3. The thermal barrier according to claim 1 or 2, characterized in that said second layer has a thickness between 10 and 70 µm.
4. The thermal barrier according to one of the preceding claims, characterized in that said second layer has a surface with a roughness Ra between 8 and 23 µm.
5. The thermal barrier according to one of the preceding claims, characterized in that said second layer has a surface with a roughness Ra between 12 and 20 µm.
6. The thermal barrier according to one of the preceding claims, characterized in that said first layer is composed of 4 to 6% by weight of Al, 0.5 to 1% by weight of Y,
20 to 28% by weight of Cr, 0 to 2.5% by weight of N and a % by weight of M to complete
100.
7. The thermal barrier according to one of the preceding claims, characterized in that said second layer is composed of 10 to 12% by weight of Al, 0.5 to 1% by weight of
Y, 13 to 17% by weight of Cr, 0 to 2.5% by weight of N and a % by weight of M to complete
100.