[0001] This invention relates to milling machines and in particular to milling machines
which are used to mill at least one of a pair of opposite faces of an elongate metal
workpiece such as a slab.
[0002] Particularly in the manufacture of copper workpieces, it is necessary to mill a pair
of opposed faces thereof in order to remove scale and the like from the faces prior
to the workpiece being rolled in a rolling mill. If this impurity is not removed,
it will be rolled into the workpiece during the subsequent rolling operations and
this is detrimental to the quality of the workpiece.
[0003] In such machines.it is usual for the workpiece to be fed between a cutter and an
associated support member which may be a so-called back-up roller or a flat slide
plate. The cutter acts on one face of the workpiece and the cutter gap, i.e. the gap
between the cutter and its associated support member, determines the thickness of
the workpiece after it has been acted upon by the cutter. It is necessary to machine
the pair of opposed faces of the workpiece and, after the workpiece has been machined
on one face, it is either fed to a second similar machine for treatment of the second
face or it is inverted and fed through the same machine again after the cutter has
been adjusted to

two required amount of material from the second face.
[0004] The milling machine may have a pair of cutters offset in the direction of movement
of the workpiece through the machine with each cutter having its associated support
member and in this way both of the opposite faces of the workpiece are milled during
one pass of the workpiece through the machine.
[0005] The cutters may be of cylindrical form.with the cutting edges on their periphery,
or they may be so-called face-milling cutters which operate with their axes at right
angles to the face of the workpiece which is being milled. Alternatively they may
be in the.form of planar blades caused to move across the face of the workpiece.
[0006] When the cutters are of cylindrical form, a pair of them may be arranged in opposed
relation and in this way each cutter also acts as the support member for the other
cutter so that back-up rollers or the like are not required.. The gap between the
two cutters determines the thickness of the workpiece.
[0007] It has been common practice with these milling machines to set the gap between the
cutters or between each cutter and its co-operating support member to ensure that
both faces of the workpiece are machined to produce a workpiece of a substantially
constant thickness. Such operation of the machine is satisfactory so long as the thickness-'of
the workpiece entering the milling machine does not vary. If the thickness does vary,
and, for example, the thickness increases, then the amount of material actually removed
from the face also increases to produce a workpiece of constant thickness. With such
an arrangement, the amount which is removed from the face of the workpiece is far
more than is necessary and is wasteful of material. If, however, the thickness of
the workpiece decreases, then it sometimes occurs that all of the scale.is not removed
from the faces of the workpiece and this results in an unsatisfactory product after
rolling.
[0008] Furthermore, variations in depth of cut cause more rapid wear on the cutter teeth
than will be the case if the depth of cut was maintained at a constant value.
[0009] It is an object of the present invention to provide a milling machine having control"means
by which these difficulties are substantially overcome.
[0010] According to a first aspect of the present invention, a milling machine comprises
means for guiding an elongate metal workpiece in the direction of its length along
a path, a cutter positioned on one side of the path and a co-operating support member
positioned on the other side of the path, the cutter being arranged to act on a face
of an elongate workpiece guided along the path, the cutter and the support member
together defining a cutter gap and means for adjusting said cutter gap, characterised
in that means are provided for producing an electrical signal representative of the
thickness of the workpiece upstream of the cutter gap, and control means responsive
to said electrical signal sarwe o bring about adjustment of the cutter gap to produce
a required depth of cut on the said face of the workpiece irrespective of variations
in the thickness of the workpiece upstream of the cutter gap.
[0011] 
[0012] workpiece in the direction of its length along a path, a pair of outters positioned
on opposite sides of the path and ar- ranged to act on respective opposed faces of
an elongate workpiece guided along the path, characterised in that each has means
associated therewith for producing an elec- Meal signal representative cf the thickness
of the work- piece after it has been acted upon by the cutter, means are provided
for producing an electrical signal representative of the thickness of the workpiece
upstream of the cutters and control means which are responsive to said electrical
signals and serve to bring about relative positional movement between the cutters
and said faces to produce a re-
quired depth of cut on each face irrespective.of variations in the thickness of the
workpiece.
[0013] In a milling machine having a pair of cutters, the operator sets into the machine
information concerning the depth of cut required on each of the opposed-faces and
the control means automatically sets the cutters so as to produce said depth of cut
on the opposed faces. If the thickness of the workpiece entering the milling machine
varies, then the control means adjusts the relative position between the cutters and
the faces to bring about the required depth of cut irrespective of the variations
in the thickness of the workpiece entering the milling machine.
[0014] In view of the fact that variations in the.thick-

entering the milling machine usually

necessary to have contin-

trical signal representative of the thickness of the workpiece is retained until the
next measurement is taken.
[0015] In order that the invention may be more readily unaerstood it will now be described,
by way of example only, with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:-
Figure 1 is a diagrammatic side elevation of a milling machine;
Figure 2 is a sectional elevation of a workpiece thickness measuring device shown
in Figure 1; and
Figure 3 is a circuit diagram of control means for the milling machine.
[0016] - Referring to Figure 1, a milling machine for milling elongate metal workpieces in
the form of slabs has a conventional roller flattening machine 1 provided at its.
entry end. A pair of rotary cutters 2, 4 are located on opposite sides of a path extending
through the milling machine. Pairs of driven pinch rolls 6, 8, 10 and 12 are positioned
along said path to guide a workpiece entering the mill from the flattener 1 along
the path so that its upper and lower faces can be acted upon by the respective rotary
cutters. The cutter 2 has a back-up roller 14 positioned above the path and the cutter
4 has a back-up roller 16 positioned below the path.
[0017] The cutter 2 and its back-up roller 14 form part of a first milling assembly 18 which
includes means for ras- ing and lowering the roller 14 with respect to the cutter
which is fixed relative to the path. The vertical posi- on of the roller 14 with respect
to the path is adjusted by means of a positioning device 20 acting on the bearing
chocks of the roller 14. A transducer (not shown) is located le- tween the bearing
chocks of the cutter 2 and the roller to provide an electrical signal representative
of the ga between the cutter and the roller and which is representative of the thickness
of the workpiece after it has been act upon by the cutter 2.
[0018] The cutter 4 is displaceable towards and a from the path while the back-up roller
16 is fixed relativ to the path. The vertical position of the cutter 4 is adj table
by means of a positioning device 22 which

bear-


gap between the cutter and the roller and representative the thickness of the workpiece
after it has been acted upon by the cutter 4.
[0019] Between the flattener and the cutter 2 there is a device 24 for measuring the thickness
of the workpiece before it is acted upon by the cutters. The device consists of a
pair of rolls 26, 28 on opposite faces of the workpiece and a transducer which indicates
the separation of the rolls. The device is shown in more detail in Figure 2.
[0020] A metal detector 30 is located below the path between the flattener 1 and the thickness
measuring device 24. A further metal detector 32 is located between the thickness
measuring device 24 and the first pair of pinch rolls 6. Each of the metal detectors
provides an electrical signal when a metal workpiece is present on the path immediately
above it.
[0021] Initially the metal workpiece is brought into position between the measuring rolls
of the device 24 so that the rolls engage opposed faces of the workpiece and the transducer
associated with the device produces an electrical signal representative of the thickness
of the workpiece between the rollers. The desired depth of cut on each of the opposed
faces of the workpiece is determined by the operator and the control means causes
the gaps between the two cutters and their respective back-up rollers to be adjusted
in order to give a required depth of cut on each of the faces. The pairs of pinch
rolls 6, 8, 10 and 13 feed the workpiece 34 through the milling machine and the required
cuts are made on the opposed faces.
[0022] Referring now to Figure 2, the thickness measuring device 24 is shown in more detail.
The device comprises a light-weight frame 36 which is guided at a pair of opposite
sides by means of rollers 38 acting in vertical channel members 40. The frame is thus
free to move vertically with respect to the channel members. The frame 36 has an opening
42 extending through it which is dimensioned such as to permit the workpiece 34 to
pass through it. The underside )f the workpiece is contacted by the roller 28 which
is mounted on the frame while the upperside of the workpiece can be contacted by the
roller 26 which is mounted in a housing 44 secured to the lower end of a connecting
rod 46, the upper end of which is connected to a piston of a fluid cylinder 48. The
fluid cylinder serves to bias the roller 26 into engagement with the upper surface
of the workpiece 34 but the roller can be displaced upwardly if the thickness of the
workpiece increases.
[0023] The frame 44 has an outwardly extending arm 50 to which one end of a position transducer
52 is connected. The transducer is mounted on the frame 36. As the roller 26 moves
vertically, due to the variation in the thickness of the workpiece, the transducer
52 is actuated and it produces an electrical signal which is representative of the
thick- ness of the workpiece between the rollers 26 and 28..
[0024] Referring now to Figure 3, the transducer 52 associated with the thickness measuring
device for the incoming workpiece is shown

potentiometer is taken through a buffer amplifier 56 and to a sample and hold amplifier
58. Amplifier 58 receives regular signals from a timer control 60.which in turn res-
eives a signal dependent on the speed of the workpiece as it passes through the machine.
This signal is received on line 62 from a buffer amplifier 64 which receives a signal
from a device (not shown) and which is responsive to the speed of the movement of
the workpiece along the path. When the sample and hold amplifier receives a signal
from the timer 60, it measures the output from the buffer amplifier 56 and retains
that measurement until the next signal is received from the timer 60, at which time
it receives a further signal from the buffer 56.
[0025] On the control desk for the machine, there is a potentiometer 66 on which the operator
sets the required depth of cut for the first cutter. A typical depth-of cut may be
up to .030 inches. The output from the potentiometer is applied through a buffer amplifier
68 to a resistor 70. The cutter 2 has a transducer associated with it which indicates
the separation between the cutter 2 and its back-up roller 14, Figure 1. This transducer
is indicated by reference numeral 72. The output from this transducer is applied to
a potentiometer 74 and the output from the potentiometer is connected through a buffer
amplifier 76 and applied across a resistor 78.
[0026] When the cutter 2 has been in use for some time, it is necessary to regrind it and
this brings about a slight reduction in the diameter of the cutter. To allow for this,
a potentiometer 80 allows a signal representative of the reduction in the size of
the cutter to be applied through a Duffer amplifier 82 and across a resistor 84. The
signals applied across the resistors 84, 78 and 70 are added together and are applied
as an input to a summing amplifier 86 which also receives a signal of the opposite
polarity from the sample and hold amplifier 58. The addition signal from the resistors
70, 78 and 84 is compared in the.amplifier 86 with the signal from the sample and
hold amplifier and a difference or error signal is provided on line 88. The error
signal on line 88 passes to a dual comparator comprising a buffer amplifier.90 and
two oppositely poled zener diodes 92, 94. Diode 92 is connected in series with a reed
relay 96 and diode 94 is connected in series with reed relay 98. The contact of relay
96 is connected in series with the coil of a further relay 100 and the contact of
this relay is connected in a drive circuit for the back-up roller of the first cutter
such as, when energised, to open up the gap between the back-up roller and its cutter.
The contact of relay 98 is connected in series with a further relay 102 and the contact
of this relay is connected in series with the drive circuit for the back-up roller
of the first cutter such that, when the contact is closed, the back-up roller is moved
towards the cutter to reduce the distance between them. The drive for the back-up
roller-is supplied with a drive signal on line 104. If the error signal from the amplifier
86 is such as to indicate that the gap between the cutter and its back-up roller is
too great, by an amount which causes zener diode 94 to break down, then relay 102
is actuated and the back-up roller is

error signal is reduced to zero. Similarly, if the por- arity of the signal from the
amplifier 86 is such as to that the gap between the cutter and its back-up roller
is too small, by an amount which causes the zener diode 92 to break down, then relay
100 is actuated causing the back-up roller to move towards the cutter until the error
signal is zero.
[0027] On the operator's control desk there is also a rheostat 106 on which the operator
can set a required depth of cut for cutter 4 typically up to .030 inches. The signal
from this rheostat is applied through a buffer amplifier 108 to be applied across
a resistor 110. There is also a rheostat 112 on which any variation in the cutter
diameter can be set and this signal is applied through a buffer amplifier 114 across
a resistor 116. The transducer associated with the cutter 4 is indicated by reference
numeral 118 and the output from the transducer is connected through a buffer 120 and
dropped across a resistor 122. The signals across the resistors 110, 116 and 122 are
added together to form an addition signal and in a summing amplifier 124 they are
compared with a signal from a sample and hold amplifier 126 which receives an output
from the buffer amplifier 76 on a line 128. The sample and hold amplifier is operated
intermittently by way of a timer 130 which receives an electrical signal on the line
62. The output from the sample and hold amplifier 126 is compared with the addition
signal to form an error signal as an output from the summing amplifier 124. The timer
130
.provides regular signals to the sample and hold amplifier so that the amplifier receives
a signal. from the line 128 and holds that signal until the next signal is received
from the timer whereupon the amplifier receives the signal on the line 128 and holds
this until the next signal from the timer 130 is received.
[0028] The output from summing amplifier 124 is applied to a dual comparator consisting
of a buffer amplifier 126 and two zener diodes 128, 130 arranged in opposed relation.
The output from the diode 128 is applied to a reed relay 132, the contact of which
is connected in series with a further relay 134. The output from the diode 130 is
connected to a relay 136 having a contact in series with a further relay 138. If the
output from the buffer 126 is sufficiently large to cause breakdown of one or other
of the diodes, the appropriate relay is operated in order to cause the cutter 4 to
be moved up or down depending upon the polarity of the error signal. If the error
signal indicates that the separation of the cutter and its back-up roller is too low,
then the cutter 4 is caused to be raised until the error signal is reduced to zero.
Similarly, if the polarity of the error signal is such as to indicate that the cutter
and its back-up roller are separated by too great an amount, then the appropriate
relay is operated to cause the actuating device to drive the cutter towards its back-up
roller until the error signal is zero.
[0029] The signal on line-104, which brings about the adjustment of the cutters or their
back-up rollers, is supplied . from a source through contacts associated with the
metal detectors 30, 32 respectively. In this way the cutters and their back-up rollers
cannot be actuated until metal-is pass ing through the metal detectors.
[0030] As a further precaution, a comparator 140 receives two signals from lines 142 and
144 respectively which are the outputs from the buffers 76 and 56 respectively. If
these signals indicate that the first cutter 2 has to make a depth of cut of greater
than .030 inches, then the comparator operates a relay which de-energises the roller
flattening machine and the pinch rolls 6, 8, 10 and 12 to render the machine inoperative.
Similarly, a comparator 146 receives signals on line 142 and 148, the latter being
received from the buffer 120, and again if the comparator 146 indicates that the cutter
4 has to make a depth of cut greater than .030 inches, then a relay is operated to
render the pinch rolls 6, 8, 10 and 12 inoperative along with the roller flattening
machine.
[0031] The first transducer 52 has a digital display device 152 associated with it to indicate
the in-going thickness of the workpiece and the transducers 72 and 118 have digital
displays 154 and 156 respectively which indicate the thickness of the material as
it passes between the first and second cutters respectively. The actual diameters
of the cutters 2 and 4 are indicated on digital displays l58 and l60 respectively.
[0032] The control circuit of the invention enables the depth of cut on each of the cutters
to be selected by the operator and for this depth of cut to be made on the appropriate
face of the workpiece. If the in-going thickness of the workpiece changes, then the
depth of cut remains the same and this results in a product having the required depth
of cut on each of iits opposite faces regardless of variation in in-going thickness
The sample and hold amplifiers 58 and 126 operate intermittently and changes in the
separation of the cutters and their associated back-up rollers are made intermittently
but this is satisfactory since changes in the thickness of the workpiece occur at
long term intervals. If the incoming material has large gauge variations at irregular
intervals, the sample and hold circuits would be'replaced by analogue delay circuits.
This system would allow gauge signals to be delayed according to the line speed, so
that the cutter gap variation between 2 and 14 would follow the gauge variations measured
at 24 but delayed by a precise period. A similar delay would operate at the second
cutter and back-up rollers 4 and 16 but would take its gauge reference from the transducer
at the first cutter position. It is not necessary for the same depth of cut to be
made on each face of the workpiece, the operator has the choice of setting differen
depths of cut for the opposite faces, if he so wishes.
1. A milling machine comprising means for guiding an elongate metal workpiece in the
direction of its length along a path, a cutter positioned on one side of the path
and a co-operating support member positioned on the other side of the path, the cutter
being arranged to act on a face of an elongate workpiece guided along the path, the
cutter and.the support member together defining a cutter gap and means for adjusting
said cutter gap, characterised in that means are provided for producing an electrical
signal representative of the thickness of the workpiece upstream of the cutter gap,
and control means responsive to said electrical signal serve to bring about adjustment
of the cutter gap to produce a required depth of cut on the said face of the workpiece
irrespective of variations in the thickness of the workpiece upstream of the cutter
gap.
2. A milling machine as claimed in claim 1, characterised in that the cutter and its
support member have means associated therewith for producing an electrical signal
representative of the cutter gap and said control means serves to add an electrical
signal representative of the desired depth of cut to the signal representative of
the cutter gap to form an addition signal and this addition signal is compared with
the signal representative of the thickness of the workpiece to form an error signal
and said error signal is used to bring about adjustment of said cutter gap in the
sense to reduce the error signal to zero.
3. A milling comprising means for-guiding an elongate metal workpiece in the direction
of its length along a path, a pair of cutters positioned on opposite sides of the
path and arranged to act on respective opposed faces of an elongate workpiece guided
along the path, characterised in that each cutter has means associated therewith for
producing an electrical signal representative of the thickness of the workpiece after
it has been acted upon by the cutter, means are provided for producing an electrical
signal representative of the thickness of the workpiece upstream of the cutters and
control means which are responsive to said electrical signals and serve to bring about
relative positional movement between the cutters and said faces to produce a required
depth of cut on each face irrespective of variations in the thickness of the workpiece.
4. A milling machine as claimed in claim 3, characterised in that in the control means
the signal representative of the thickness of the workpiece after it has been acted
upon by the first cutter which it encounters when it travels along said path is added
to a signal representative of the required depth of cut for said cutter to form an
addition signal is compared with the signal representative of the thickness of the
workpiece to form an error signal and said error signal is used to actuate means for
causing relative positional movement between the cutter and the workpiece in the sense
to reduce the error signal to zero
A milling machine as claimed in claim 2 or 4, characterised in that the signal representative
of the thickness of the workpiece upstream of the cutter is delayed by a period of
time determined by the speed of movement of the workpiece along the path before being
compared with said addition signal.
6. A milling machine as claimed in claim 2, 4 or 5, characterised in that the addition
signal or the error signal is modified by a further signal representative of a change
in diameter of the cutter from a predetermined value.
7. A milling machine as claimed in any preceding claim, characterised in that the
signal representative of the thickness of the workpiece upstream of the cutters is
sampled by the control means at regular intervals and is held at sampled value until
the next sample is taken.
8. A milling machine as claimed in claim 4, characterised in that in the control means
the signal representative of the thickness of the workpiece after it has been acted
upon by the second cutter is added to a preset signal representative of the required
depth of cut for the cutter to form an additional signal and this addition signal
is compared with the signal representative of the thickness of the workpiece after
it has been acted upon by the first cutter to form an error signal and this error
signal is used to actuate means causing relative positional movement between the second
cutter and the workpiece in the sense to reduce the error signal to zero.
9. A milling machine as claimed in claim 8, characterised in that the signal representative
of the thickness of the workpiece after it has been acted upon by the first cutter
is delayed for a period of time determined by the speed of movement of the workpiece
along the path before being compared with said addition signal.
10. A milling machine as claimed in claim 8 or 9, characterised in that the addition
signal is modified by a further signal representative of a change in diameter of the
second cutter from a predetermined value.
11. A milling machine as claimed in claim 8, 9 or 10, characterised in that the signal
representative of the thickness of the workpiece after it has been acted upon by the
first cutter is sampled by the control means at regular intervals and is held at the
sampled value until the next sample is taken.
12. A milling machine as claimed in any preceding claim and in which each cutter has
a co-operating support member in the form of a back-up roller associated therewith,
the.roller being positioned on the opposite side of the path. to the cutter, characterised
in that the relative positional movement is brought about by keeping'the roller fixed
and moving its associated cutter.