[0001] This invention relates to photovoltaic elements useful for converting light into
electrical energy.
[0002] Schottky barrier and P-N junction photocells rely upon the fact that a built-in-potential
exists at the metal/semiconductor interface as in the Schottky device or at the junction
between the P-type and N-type semiconductors as in the P-N junction device.
[0003] Inorganic semiconductors have been used in the past for solar cells because of their
fairly high conversion efficiencies which have been as high as 12 to 15 percent. However,
such cells have proven to be very expensive to construct because of the melt and other
processing techniques necessary to fabricate the semiconductor layer. As a result,
such cells have had extensive practical utility only in the field of space exploration,
and not in terrestrial applications.
[0004] In an effort to reduce the cost of solar cells, organic photoconductors and semiconductors
have been considered, because of the inexpensive formation of the photoconductive
layer by solvent coating and similar techniques.
[0005] Phthalocyanine has been used in organic solar cells in the past in contact with a
layer containing an electron acceptor such as oxidized tetramethyl 2-phenylenediamine,
S-carotene, dibrominated p-phenylenediamine and p-chlor- anil. Examples are illustrated
in U.S. Patent 3,057,947. However, such cells have extremely low conversion efficiencies,
less than 10
-7 percent, for several reasons. First, the acceptors are not dyes and therefore do
not absorb radiation in the visible spectrum as well as dyes do. Second, the layers
are formed by pressing techniques and have thicknesses which are high.
[0006] Multilayer photoelectric cells have been constructed from a layer comprising a phthalocyanine
dispersed in an organic polymeric binder with or without an overcoat of malachite
green, as reported, for example, in Topics in Current Chemistry, Springer-Verlag,
Volume 61, 1976, page 124, and U.S. Patent 3,789,216, issued January 29, 1974. However,
the conversion efficiency of such cells was very low -- less than 10
4 percent, as reported in Springer-Verlag.
[0007] A layer of porphyrin has been used to improve certain inorganic photovoltaic cells
e.g., selenium cells. Examples are disclosed in U.S. Patent 3,935,031. However, only
expensive inorganic semiconductors which themselves are self-sufficient cell materials
have been suggested for such use with porphyrin.
[0008] According to the present invention there is provided a photovoltaic element which
comprises
(1) a first layer comprising an organic electron donor compound, in contact with
(2) a second layer comprising an organic electron acceptor compound, said layers forming
a rectifying junction between them and at least one of said layers being capable of
absorbing radiation at wavelengths between 350 and 1000 nm, and
(3) an electrode in operative ohmic contact with each of said layers, at least one
of said electrodes being transparent to electromagnetic radiation to which the photo-
voltaic element is sensitive,
wherein the organic compound of each of layers (1) and (2) has a molecule having a
planar polycyclic nucleus and wherein the combined thickness of the electron donor
compound layer or layers and the electron acceptor compound layer or layers is no
greater than 0.5 micron.
[0009] In a preferred embodiment of the invention each of said organic compounds has a molecule
whose surface area is at least 40 square Angstroms and a width of at least 5 Angstroms.
[0010] In another preferred embodiment of the invention the electron acceptor has a molecule
containing a nucleus having at least 7 fused carbocyclic and/or heterocyclic rings
and the electron donor has a molecule containing a nucleus having at least 8 fused
carbocyclic and/or heterocyclic rings.
[0011] The surface area of the molecule is calculated by assuming the atoms are points connected
by a bond of appropriate length, i.e. 1.39 Angstroms in a benzene ring. Hence the
surface area of benzene is 5.0 square Angstroms. However, where the molecule is not
annulated, that is where the rings are joined together in a non- rigid manner, e.g.
by a single bond, the effective area is greater than the area as calculated above.
In such a case, it is the effective area which should be taken and this will normally
be some 30% greater than the calculated area.
[0012] In another embodiment of the invention the electron donor is a porphyrin or phthalocyanine
and the electron acceptor is a photoconductive organic dye capable of absorbing radiation
at wavelengths between 350 and 1000 nm.
[0013] As used in the present specification and claims photovoltaic element means a solid
state device which converts radiation absorbed by the element directly to electric
power.
[0014] Thus the elements of this invention are suitable as terrestrial rooftop generators
(solar cells) or as light-level measuring devices. -As a light-level measuring device,
the element may be used both at high and low light levels. The elements exhibit moderately
high open circuit voltages of from 300-500 mV.
[0015] Alternatively, the element may also be used in the current mode. The current generated
in a diffuse room-light condition is about 20µA/cm
2, a large enough current to be measured accurately. The current can thus become a
measure of the light intensity, and the cell can be used as an exposure meter.
[0016] The photovoltaic elements of the present invention are capable of working at conversion
efficiencies of at least 0.02% and, for example, as high as 1%.
[0017] The terms "electron donor" and "electron acceptor" used in the present specification
and claims are used to describe the respective electron affinity of the compounds
when layers comprising them are in contact with each other. Thus, an electron donor
has a relatively low electron affinity, and an electron acceptor has a relatively
high electron affinity. As such, an electron donor tends to act as a p-type semi-conductor
whereas an electron acceptor tends to act as an n-type semi- conductor.
[0018] As used in the present specification and claims the term "rectifying junction" means
a junction which provides a ratio of forward current to reverse current of at least
10 when a potential of at least 0.5 V is applied to the element.
[0019] "Polycyclic" is used in the present specification and claims to mean containing two
or more rings which may be fused or not.
[0020] By the term "planar" used in the present specification and claims we mean that the
atoms of the nucleus lie in the same plane or that any atom of the nucleus or a resonance
form thereof lies no more than 10° out of the plane.
[0021] The photovoltaic elements made from coatings of the above compounds will be generally
free from short circuits between the electrodes due to pinholes in the coatings. The
compounds, when coated, appear to deposit as flat, overlying molecules. Also, the
planarity of the compounds' nuclei provides minimum resistance to charge transport
through their layers and therefore provides a maximum short circuit current.
[0022] In one preferred embodiment of the invention, the planar polycyclic nuclei of the
compounds are highly conjugated, have pi-electrons and have a large surface area.
Generally, the larger the molecular surface area of such compounds, the more likely
it is that the compounds will provide an element with high conversion efficiencies.
It is believed that this greater area provides greater assurance of molecular overlap
hence less likelihood of pinhole shorts.
[0023] Examples of useful electron donor compounds with planar, fused polycyclic nuclei
are the porphyrin and phthalocyanine compounds. Any such compound is operative, with
or without a chelated metal atom. The chelated metal, if present, may be cobalt, magnesium,
zinc, palladium, nickel, copper, lead, or platinum. Some metal phthalocyanines are
preferred for this invention because of the greater conversion efficiencies which
they confer on the'element. Examples of preferred metal phthalocyanines include copper,
lead and platinum phthalocyanine. Lead phthalocyanine has been used to produce an
efficient cell with a spectral response extending to almost 1000 nm. It is preferred
that an electron donor layer containing a porphyrin be structureless or micro-crystalline,
because large crystals in such a layer tend to provide a shorting path which can decrease
the inefficiency of the element.
[0024] As used herein, the term "porphyrin or phthalocyanine compound" means any compound,
natural or synthetic, which contains the basic porphyrin or phthalocyanine structure.
Examples of such porphyrins are disclosed in the aforesaid U.S. Patent 3,935,031.
A preferred class of such compounds are those having the formula:
wherein L is CH or N,
M is a metal,
T and T are both S or bath CH, or one of T and T2 is N and the other CH,
X1 and X 2 are the same or different, and are each halogen or hydrogen; and
Z1 represent the atoms necessary to complete an unsaturated ring having.6 ring atoms.
[0025] One further option is to use compounds of Formula IV, but in a nonmetallic form,
wherein two of the four nitrogen atoms associated with M are hydrogenated.
[0026] If desired, two electron donor layers of the same or different electron donor compounds
may be used. Only one of these layers contacts the electron acceptor layer, while
the other is in ohmic contact with an electrode.
[0027] Other useful compounds for the electron donor layer are compounds which contain at
least 8 carbocyclic and/or heterocyclic fused rings. Examples include ovalene, diindeno
[1,2,3-cd-1'2'3'-lm]perylene, violanthrene, isoviolanthrene, and pyranthrene.
[0028] Perylene derivatives which are particularly useful as electron donor compounds have
the formula:
wherein R14 and R15 are each hydrogen or an alkyl of 1-5 carbon atoms which may be substituted, a phenyl,
substituted phenyl or quinolyl group, and
R16, R17, R18 and R19 are each oxygen or R14 and one of R16 and R17 and R15 and one of R18 and R19 together complete a one or two ringed heterocyclic group, in which case the other
of R16 and R17 and the other of R18 and R19 are oxygen.
[0029] Examples of compounds of formula II are:

and, preferably

[0030] The electron acceptor compound may comprise 7-14 fused carbocyclic and/or heterocyclic
rings which may be substituted with one or more electron withdrawing groups such as
keto; cyano; halogen, e.g. chlorine or bromine; sulphonyl; carboxy, nitro;
imino; alkyl or alkoxy containing from 1 to 5 carbon atoms, for example, methyl, ethyl,
propyl; hydroxyl; amino; aryl containing from 6 to 10 carbon ring atoms which may
be substituted e.g., phenyl, naphthyl or halo-, alkyl- or alkoxyphenyl; provided that
the compound contains at least one electron-withdrawing group.
[0031] Representative examples of fused polycyclic compounds of this type are anthraquinone-derived
vat dyes such as flavanthrone and derivatives of perylene, coronone-imide, ovalene
and compounds of the structure:

wherein E is 0 or S.
[0032] Other polycyclic compounds which may be used in electron acceptor layers include
those in which the polycyclic rings are not fused. Particularly useful examples are
photoconductive organic dyes such as pyrylium-type dye salts which include pyrylium,
thiapyrylium and selenapyrylium dye salts, and also salts of the aforementioned pyrylium-type
dye salts containing condensed ring systems such as salts of benzopyrylium and naphthopyrylium
dyes. Highly preferred examples have a molecule having a surface area of at least
40 square Angstroms and a width in the plane of the compound of at least 5 Angstroms.
[0033] Examples of pyrylium-type dyes, which may be used are those with the formula:

wherein J is CR
10 or nitrogen, Q and X are each oxygen, sulphur or selenium, R
8, R
9 and R
10 are each hydrogen, an alkyl of 1-3 carbon atoms, an aryl, substituted aryl, cyano
or nitro group, R , R
2, R
3 and R4 are each a phenyl or substituted phenyl group or an alkyl or alkoxy group
of 1-5 carbon atoms, at least two of R
1,
R21 R3 and R
4 being phenyl or substituted phenyl, m is 0 or 1 and is 0 if J is nitrogen, and Z
- is an anion.
[0034] Examples of anions Z are perchlorate and fluoroborate.
[0035] If R
1, R
2, R3 or R
4 are substituted phenyl, it is preferred that the substituents be located in the para
position and be selected from those which shift the blue absorption peak of the dye
salt to a longer wavelength. Examples of such substituents include alkyl having from
1 to 3 carbon atoms and halogens e.g. chlorine or fluorine.
[0036] Another class of useful polycyclic compounds of the unfused type includes 2,4,6-trisubstituted
pyrylium, thiapyrylium and selenapyrylium dye salts of the general structure:

in which R° and R' are the same or different and are each alkyl from 1 to 6 carbon
atoms, e.g., methyl, ethyl or isopropyl; phenyl, substituted phenyl or a 5 or 6 membered
heterocyclic ring, e.g., thienyl, furyl, pyridyl, pyrimidinyl, thiadiazolyl, thiazolyl
or pyrrolyl.
[0037] R6 represents an alkylamino- or dialkylamino- substituted 5 or 6 membered heterocyclic
ring having from 1 to 6 carbon atoms in the or each alkyl moiety including dialkylamino-substituted
and halogenated alkylamino-substituted phenyl, dialkylaminopyridyl, dialkylaminofuryl,
dialkylamino- thienyl, dialkylaminopyrimidinyl, dialkylaminothiadi- azolyl or dialkylaminothiazolyl;
X is oxygen, selenium or sulphur and Z
- is an anion, e.g., perchlorate or fluoroborate.
[0038] Examples of such compounds, particularly wherein at least one of R
5, R
6 and R
7 is heterocyclic, are described in Research Disclosure, Volume 157, May 1977, Publication
No. 15742, published by Industrial Opportunities, Ltd, Homewell, Havant, Hampshire,
P09 lEF, United Kingdom.
[0039] Examples of pyrylium-type dyes which may be employed as the electron acceptor include:
4-[(2,6-diphenyl-4H-thiapyran-4-ylidene)methyl]-2, 6-diphenylthiapyrylium perchlorate,
4-[(2,6-dimethoxy-4H-thiapyran-4-ylidene)methyl]-2, 6-diphenylthiapyrylium perchlorate,
4-[(2,6-diphenyl-4H-pyran-4-ylidene)methyl]-2,6-diphenylthiapyrylium perchlorate,
4-[(2,6-diphenyl-4H-pyran-4-ylidene)methyl]-2,6-diphenylpyrylium fluoroborate,
4-[(2,6-diphenyl-4H-thiapyran-4-ylidene)methyl]-2, 6-diphenylselenapyrylium perchlorate,
4-[(2,6-diphenyl-4H-selenin-4-ylidene)methyl]-2, 6-diphenylselenapyrylium perchlorate,
4-[(2,6-diphenyl-4H-pyran-4-ylidene)methyl]-2,6-diphenylselenapyrylium perchlorate,
4-[(2,6-diethyl-4H-thiapyran-4-ylidene)methyl]-2, 6-diphenylthiapyrylium perchlorate,
4-[(2,6-diphenyl-4H-thiapyran-4-ylidene)methyl]-2, 6-diethoxythiapyrylium perchlorate,
2,6-diphenyl-4-[(2,6-diphenyl-4H-pyranylidene) amino] pyrylium perchlorate,
2,6-diphenyl-4-(4-dimethylaminophenyl)thiapyrylium hexafluorophosphate,
2,6-diphenyl-4-(4-diphenylaminophenyl)thiapyrylium perchlorate,
2,6-diphenyl-4-(4-dipropylaminophenyl)thiapyrylium perchlorate,
4-{[2,6-di(p-methylphenyl)-4H-thiapyran-4-ylidene] methyl)-2,6-diphenylthiapyrylium
perchlorate,
4-{[2,6-di(p-fluorophenyl)-4H-thiapyran-4-ylidene] methyl)-2,6-diphenylthiapyrylium
perchlorate,
4-{[2,6-di(p-fluorophenyl)-4H-thiapyran-4-ylidene] methyl}-2,6-di(p-fluorophenyl)thiapyrylium
perchlorate,
4-{[2,6-di(p-methylphenyl)-4H-thiapyran-4-ylidene] methyl}-2,6-di(p-methylphenyl)thiapyrylium
perchlorate.
[0040] The electron acceptor layer may comprise a mixture of different dye salts of formula
(I), or one or more dye salts of formula (I) with one or more dye salts of formula
(V). In some instances synergism has been demonstrated, in that the conversion efficiency
of the mixture exceeds that obtainable from using either of the dye salts alone.
[0041] More than one electron acceptor layer may be employed. They may comprise different
compounds or the same compound as used in the first electron acceptor layer.
[0042] The thickness of the combined electron donor and acceptor layers is an important
aspect of the photovoltaic elements of the invention. It has been found,that efficiencies
begin to decrease drastically for a thickness in excess of. 0.5 micron. This decrease
in efficiency is believed to be caused by decreased penetration of light to the region
adjacent the rectifying junction, or by increased electrical resistance within the
layers. Minimum thickness for the individual layers appears to be dictated by coating
techniques and the minimum that can be used without shorting out. Useful devices of
good efficiency have been constructed with thicknesses for each of the two layers
as low as 100 Angstroms.
[0043] Preferred thicknesses for each of the two layers, for optimum photovoltaic element
results, are from 300 to 500 angstroms. If unequal thicknesses are to be used, it
is preferred that the thinner layer be adjacent the transparent electrode to permit
the best exposure of the rectifying junction to radiation.
[0044] In the present photovoltaic elements the electrodes are in operative ohmic contact,
one to the electron donor layer and the other to the electron acceptor layer. Although
the preferred construction is one in which the electrodes are in actual physical contact
with their respective donor or acceptor layers, this need not always be the case.
For example, the electron donor layer which contributes to the formation of the rectifying
junction can be spaced away from its electrode by a second electron donor layer, as
indicated above. In addition, an electrode which is operative is one which is connected
in a manner that does not short circuit the element.
[0045] The electrode adjacent to the electron donor layer preferably has a high work function,
while the one adjacent to the electron acceptor layer preferably has a low work function.
[0046] It has been found that a preferred electrode adjacent to the electron donor layer
is a glass or a transparent film such as poly(ethylene terephthalate) coated with
a transparent layer of indium tin oxide, tin oxide or nickel. This electrode not only
has a high work function, but is transparent. Examples of such electrodes having a
glass support are Nesa and Nesatron glass electrodes manufactured by PPG Industries
and having a surface resistivity of about 10 to 50 ohms/square and an optical transmittance
of about 80 percent, for visible light. Nesa and Nesatron are trademarks of PPG Industries.
[0047] The opposite electrode is preferably a metal with a low work function, such as indium,
silver, tin or aluninium and can be transparent or opaque. Silver is a preferred electrode
for minimum loss in conversion efficiency upon aging.
[0048] A photovoltaic element according to the present invention is shown in enlarged cross-section
in the accompanying drawing and comprises a laminar array 10 of a window electrode
12 comprising a transparent support 14 and a transparent electrically conductive layer
16; an electron donor layer 18, an electron acceptor layer 20 and an electrode 22
of a metal in ohmic contact with layer 20. It will be appreciated that the dimensions
of the element in the drawing have been exaggerated for clarity. Preferred thicknesses
for the layers comprise, for layer 16, 0.5 micron to 5 microns; for layer 18, 100
to 2500 angstroms; for layer 20, 100 to 2500 angstroms; and for electrode 22, 100
to 2000 Angstroms. As noted above, the combined thicknesses of layers 18 and 20 do
not exceed 0.5 micron.
[0049] Wires 24 represent leads contacting the electrodes to connect the element to a load
circuit.
[0050] A preferred technique for making the present photovoltaic elements involves forming
the electron donor layer and the electron accepting layer (forming the rectifying
junction) by coating them from two different solvents, one upon the other, the solvent
for one being a poor solvent for the other. In this manner, a well-defined interface
between the two layers will be maintained. An alternative and highly preferred method
is to vapor deposit a porphyrin or phthalocyanine electron donor layer on a clean,
i.e. polished, window electrode (using electron donor compounds which are reasonably
free of decomposable impurities) and thereafter solvent coat a dye salt electron acceptor
layer, for example, by spin coating it at between 1,000 and 10,000 rpm from the solvents
1,2-dichloroethane, dichloromethane or mixtures of the two. For pyrylium dye salts,
a particularly useful solvent mixture has been, 49 weight percent 1,2-dichloroethane,
49 weight percent dichloromethane, and 2 weight percent 1,1,1,3,3,3-hexafluoroisopropyl
alcohol. This solvent mixture is employed for spin-coating throughout the Examples
below. A currently preferred process for polishing the Nesatron glass (which can be
used as a window electrode) comprises rubbing the Nesatron glass surface with a cotton
flannel wetted with a suspension of an alumina or other abrasive. The polished Nesatron
glass is then cleaned in an ultrasonic cleaner containing 1:1 H
20/isopropyl alcohol for about a half an hour to remove the abrasive particles. It
can then be rinsed thoroughly with distilled water.
[0051] The electrode for the electron acceptor containing the dye salt layer is preferably
applied by conventional vapor deposition techniques.
[0052] The following Examples are included for a better understanding of the invention.
In each case, a slide projector, together with appropriate glass filters and a water
filter, was used to provide a simulated 75 mW/cm
2 sunlight, as defined in H.J.Hovel, in Semiconductors and Semimetals, Vol. 2, "Solar
Cells", 1975. The light incident on the element had an intensity of 75 mW/em
2, calibrated against a standard silicon solar cell having a short-circuit current
output of 21.5 mA/cm
2 at 75mW/cm
2. The current-voltage characteristics of each element were obtained by applying an
external voltage to the element in either polarity. The voltage across the element
and the current through it were measured by a multimeter and were simultaneously plotted
using an x-y recorder. Fill Factor (as defined by Hovel supra) is the fraction of
the product of the short circuit current and open circuit voltage Which is available
as power output.
Example 1
[0053] An element as shown in the accompanying drawing was fabricated in the following manner:
(a) A piece of Nesatron glass 100 microns thick and about 1 inch square was polished
and thoroughly cleaned and was used as the window'electrode 12.
(b) A 400 Angstrom thick copper-phthalocyanine film was deposited on the Nesatron
glass by vapor deposition in a 1 x 10-5 torr vacuum to provide the electron donor layer 18.
(c) A 400 Angstrom thick layer of a photoconductive dye salt, 4-[(2,6-diphenyl-4H-thiapyran-4-ylidene)methyl]-2,6-diphenylthiapyrylium
perchlorate, was spin-coated on top of the copper phthalocyanine layer to form the
electron acceptor layer 20. This layer 20 appeared to be homogeneous and very uniform.
(d) The top electrode 22, indium, was vapor deposited on top of the two organic layers
16 and 18 to complete the element.
[0054] Under the simulated sunlight illumination described above (75 mW/cm
2), the element developed an open-circuit voltage of 0.36 volt, a short-circuit current
of 2 mA/cm
2, and a fill factor of 0.47. The power conversion efficiency was 0.45 percent.
Examples 2 to 7
[0055] Layers of dye salts having the formula:

(wherein Ø is phenyl, and X and Q are as defined 111 Table I below were tested as
electron acceptor layers in elements prepared as described in Example 1. The copper
phthalocyanine electron donor layer deposited by vapor deposition was about 400 Angstroms
thick, and the dye salt electron acceptor layer deposited on the Cu-phthalocyanine
electron donor layer by spin-coating was also about 400 Angstroms thick. Table I lists
the photovoltaic output of the elements when tested under the simulated illumination
described in Example 1.

Examples 8 to 11
[0056] Dye salts having the formula:

wherein the
R30 and
R31 substituents are para and as identified in Table II below were tested as electron
acceptor compounds in photovoltaic elements as described in Example 1. Table II lists
the output of these elements.

Examples 12 to 19
[0057] Metal-free phthalocyanine and a number of metal-phthalocyanines were tested as electron
donor compounds in photovoltaic elements as described in Example 1. Phthalocyanine
layers of thickness ranging from 300 to 500 Angstroms were deposited on clean Nesatron
glass electrode. Then a 400 to 500 Angstrom thick electron acceptor layer consisted
of 4-[(2,6-diphenyl-4H-thiapyran-4-ylidene)methyl]-2,6-diphenylthiapyrylium perchlorate.
Table III lists the output of these elements.

Example 20
[0058] A 400 to 500 Angstrom thick Cu-phthalocyanine electron donor layer was deposited
on a clean Nesatron glass electrode by vapor deposition. Then a 400 to 500 Angstrom
thick layer containing a 1:1 by weight mixture of 4-[(2,6-diphenyl-4H-pyran-4-ylidene)methyl]-2,6-diphenylpyrylium
perchlorate and 4-[(2,6-diphenyl-4H-thiapyran-4-ylidene)methyl]-2,6-diphenylthiapyrylium
perchlorate, was spin-coated on top of the Cu-phthalocyanine layer to form an electron
acceptor layer. Indium was the other electrode. Under artificial illumination, as
described in Example 1, the element developed an open-circuit voltage of 0.43 volt,
a short-circuit current of 2 mA/cm , and a fill factor of 0.44, giving an efficiency
of 0.5 percent.
Example 21
[0059] Example 20 was repeated, except that a 1:1 mixture of 4-[(2,6-diphenyl-4H-thiapyran-4-yliaene)
methyl]-2,6-diphenylthiapyrylium perchlorate and 2,6-diphenyl-4-(4-dimethylaminophenyl)thiapvrylium
perchlorate was used to form the electron acceptor layer. The conversion efficiency
was found to be about 0.5 percent.
Example 22
[0060] An element of the configuration described in Example 1, having a silver electrode
instead of indium, developed an open-circuit voltage of 0.33 volt, a short-circuit
current of 1.8 mA/cm
2 and a fill factor of 0.4, giving a conversion efficiency of 0.36 percent. The element
was quite stable under prolonged illumination. After subjecting the element to a 90-hour
exposure to the 75 mW/cm
2 illumination described above, the element reached an efficiency of 0.23 to 0.25 percent,
with no evidence of further degradation.
Example 23
[0061] An element was fabricated as described in Example 1, but the dye salt used in step
(c) was the following:

[0062] The element had an open-circuit voltage of 0.5 V, a short-circuit current of 0.2
mA/cm
2, a fill factor of 0.28, and an efficiency of 0.05 percent.
Example 24
[0063] Example 1 was repeated, except that the dye salt used was the following:

[0064] The element had an open-circuit voltage of 0.5 V, a short-circuit current of 0.24
mA/cm , a fill factor of 0.34, and a conversion efficiency of 0.05 percent.
Examples 25 to 27
[0065] Elements were fabricated as descrioed in Example 1, except that dye salts of the
following structure were used:

[0066] Table IV lists the output of these elements for various substitutions at Q, X, and
R.

Example 28
[0067] A photovoltaic element was prepared and tested as described in Example 1, except
that the electron acceptor layer, at a thickness of 400 Angstroms, was:

[0068] This element was found to have an open-circuit voltage of about 0.52 V, a short-circuit
current of about 1 mA/cm
2, and a fill factor of 0.40, producing a conversion efficiency of about 0.27 percent.
Examples 29 - 36
[0069] A photovoltaic element was prepared and tested as described in Example 1, except
that the electron acceptor layer was a compound of the structure:

[0070] wherein R
14 and R
15 are as designated in Table V were used in place of the photoconductive dye salt of
Example 1, and a silver electrode was used in place of indium. Table V sets forth
the resulting element properties.

Examples 37 - 40
[0071] Photovoltaic elements were prepared and illuminated as described in Examples 29-36,
except for the electron acceptor. The identity of each electron acceptor compound
dyes and the results are given in Table VI.

Example 41
[0072] For this example, an element was prepared and tested, as described in Example 1,
except that in place of copper-phthalocyanine, ovalene was used, silver was used in
place of indium, and each of the electron donor and electron accepter layers was 500
Angstroms thick. The resulting element had a conversion efficiency of about 0.1 percent.
Example 42
[0073] An element was prepared and illuminated as described in Example 1, except that the
electron donor was diindeno[1,2,3-cd-1'2'3'-lm]perylene and the electron acceptor
was flavanthrone. The resulting element had an open-circuit voltage of 825 mV, a short-circuit
current of 0.8 mA/cm
2, a fill factor of 0.51, and a conversion efficiency of 0.46 percent.