[0001] Commonly, metal clips or clamps that engage embedded supports are used for securing
steel railroad rails to concrete railroad ties, and non-conducting insulators are
used to insulate the clips or clamps from the railroad rails. Metal clips or clamps
of a type exemplified in
Leeves U.S. Patent No. 4,757,945 issued to Pandrol Limited of London, England, and metal clips or clamps of a type
exemplified in
Young U.S. Patent No. 5,110,046 issued to McKay Australia Limited of Maid-stone, Australia, are used widely in North
America.
[0002] Commonly, when such clips are used, elastomeric pads are disposed between the lower
flanges of the railroad rails and the railroad ties for cushioning the railroad rails
and for insulating the rails electrically from the ties and from other underlying
structures. Although ethylene vinyl acetate (EVA) rubber and other pads have been
used widely for many years, polyurethane pads offering superior performance have become
available commerciallyfrom ITW Irathane (a unit of Illinois Tool Works Inc.) of Hibbing,
Minnesota, under its IRATHANE trademark.
[0003] Deterioration of the elastomeric pads and erosion of the concrete ties can occur
if water infiltrates and freezes between the pads and the ties or if sand, which is
used commonly to increase traction on grades, or debris infiltrates therebetween.
Such deterioration and erosion problems can be quite severe, particularly under high
loadings, in regions where weather conditions vary widely from summer to winter, at
sharp curves, and at steep grades. Such deterioration and erosion problems can result
in so-called "tie seat abrasion", which if severe can result in a railroad tie being
judged unsafe for further service in a railroad track and having to be replaced.
[0004] Prior efforts to address such deterioration and erosion problems are disclosed in
Buekett U.S. Patent No. 4,925,094. As disclosed therein, a stainless steel or other non-corrodible metal or plastic
plate is cast into an upper surface of a concrete tie. A rubber or plastic pad is
interposed between the lower flange of a railroad rail and the plate that has been
cast into the tie. It appears that the pad merely rests upon the plate and is free
to move relative to the cast-in-place plate.
[0005] Other efforts to address such deterioration and erosion problems are disclosed in
Young U.S. Patent No. 5,110,046. As disclosed therein, either an abrasion-resistant plate of an unspecified material
is bonded to the upper surface of a concrete tie by an adhesive layer, epoxy resin
adhesives being preferred, or a high density polyethylene (HDPE) closed cell foam
is interposed between the abrasion-resistant plate and the upper surface of the concrete
tie. In either instance, a rubber, polyurethane, or other elastomeric pad is interposed
between the lower flange of a railroad rail and the upper surface of the concrete
tie. It appears that the elastomeric pad merely rests upon the plate and is free to
move relative to the adhesively bonded or foam-separated plate.
[0006] As a matter of related interest,
Brown U.S. Patent No. 5,261,599 discloses an elastomeric pad having resilientlydeformable sealing portions, which
are intended to form a watertight seal between the pad and the upper surface of a
railroad tie, such as a concrete tie.
[0007] According to this invention a railroad tie is made from concrete and includes a pad
mounted on its upper surface, in use, to receive and engage the lower flange of a
railroad rail, is characterised in that the pad is a composite pad and comprises an
elastomeric pad and bonding means having an upper surface bonded to the lower surface
of the elastomeric pad so as to resist relative movement between them, the tie further
comprising an adhesive layer bonding the bonding means to its upper surface so as
to resist relative movement between them and so as to retard infiltration of sand,
water or debris between them.
[0008] The bonding means may be a plate like member bonded onto, and/or embedded into the
lower surface of the elastomeric pad. The plate like member is preferably made from
a galvanised powder-coated steel or a polymeric material such as polycarbonate.
[0009] The bonding means may comprise particles or fibres bonded onto the elastomeric material
and being partially embedded within its lower surface. In this case the particles
or fibres may be granules or fibres made from polycarbonate, acrylic or nylon. The
particles may instead be quartz, silica sand, silicon carbide, or aluminium oxide.
[0010] The bonding means may comprise a bonding layer which is at least as flexible as the
elastomeric pad contacting the lower surface of the bonding pad. In this case the
bonding layer may be an acrylic composition, or a polymerization product of a thermoplastic
elastomer in methyl methacrylate monomer.
[0011] The invention also embraces an elastomeric pad for use in such a railroad tie and
the track includes such ties.
[0012] The elastomeric pad can be made from any of several compositions depending upon the
very specific needs of the application, as determined by the environmental factors,
as well as the loadings and frequency of loadings of the specific rail line. The pad
can be thus made from a thermoplastic material, such as EVA, polyurethane, or other
elastomeric material available. If a bonding member is used, bonding can occur via
insert moulding, if the pad is injection moulded, via adhesive bonding, via thermally
laminating a suitable material for the bonding member, or via casting a liquid onto
the bonding member and polymerizing it in place.
[0013] Preferably, the elastomeric pad is a polyurethane pad, and the adhesive layer comprises
a methacrylate ester composition. If a bonding member is used, the bonding member
may be a galvanized, powder-coated, steel plate, or a rigid, polymeric film or sheet,
or an acrylic layer.
[0014] If an acrylic layer is used, the acrylic layer may be a product of polymerizing a
solution of methyl methacrylate copolymer in n-butyl acrylate monomer, or a product
of polymerizing a solution of a thermoplastic elastomer in methyl methacrylate monomer.
The solution may have an addition of cumene hydroperoxide to catalyze polymerization
or a sprayed coat of a dispersion of benzoyl peroxide in a plasticizer or in water
to catalyze polymerization. Alternatively, the acrylic layer may be a product of curing
or drying an acrylic emulsion, which may be water-based.
[0015] Particular embodiments of this invention will now be described with reference to
the accompanying drawings, in which:-
Figure 1 is a fragmentary, cross-sectional view of a railroad rail having a lower
flange, a railroad tie made from concrete, and a composite pad, together with associated
clips, supports, and insulators, in a first embodiment;
Figure 2 is a plan view of the first embodiment shown in Figure 1;
Figure 3 is a greatly enlarged, fragmentary sectional view taken along line 3--3 of
Figure 2, in a direction indicated by arrows;
Figure 4 is a plan view of an elastomeric pad, as used in an alternative embodiment
of this invention;
Figure 5 is a somewhat enlarged, fragmentary sectional view taken along line 5--5
of Figure 4, in a direction indicated by arrows;
Figure 6 is a fragmentary, cross-sectional view of a railroad rail having a lower
flange, a railroad tie made from concrete, and a composite pad, together with associated
clips, supports, and insulators, in another alternative embodiment of this invention;
Figure 7 is a sectional view analogous to Figure 3 but taken for the alternative embodiment
of Figure 6;
Figure 8 is a fragmentary, cross-sectional view of a railroad rail having a lower
flange, a railroad tie made from concrete, and a composite pad, together with associated
clips, supports, and insulators, in another alternative embodiment of this invention;
and,
Figure 9 is a sectional view analogous to Figure 3 but taken for the alternative embodiment
of Figure 8.
[0016] As shown in Figure 1 in a first embodiment of this invention, a composite pad 10
is mounted between a railroad rail 12 made from steel and a railroad tie 14 made from
concrete. As mounted between a lower flange 16 of the railroad rail 12 and an upper
surface 18 of the concrete tie 14, the elastomeric pad 10 cushions the railroad rail
12 and insulates the railroad rail 12 electrically from the concrete tie 14.
[0017] Two supports 20 are embedded in the concrete tie 14 and extend upwardly from the
upper surface 18. Two clamps 22 are provided, each engaging one of the supports 20
and pressing against one side of the lower flange 16 of the railroad rail 12, via
an insulator 24 bearing on the composite pad 10, so as to secure the railroad rail
12 to the concrete tie 14.
[0018] In the embodiment shown in Figures 1, 2 and 3, the composite pad 10 is configured
to coact with the supports 20, clamps 22, and insulators 24, which are outside the
scope of this invention. In the embodiment shown in Figures 4 and 5, the composite
pad 10 is configured to coact with known supports, clamps, and insulators (not shown)
having different configurations. In either embodiment, the composite pad 10 is intended
to be adhesively bonded to a railroad tie, such as the concrete tie 14.
[0019] In each embodiment of Figures 1 through 5, the composite pad 10 comprises a polyurethane
pad 30 and a bonding member 40, which is bonded directly to the elastomeric pad 30
and which is to be adhesively bonded to a railroad tie, such as the concrete tie 14.
Preferably, the polyurethane pad 30 is a similar to the polyurethane pads that have
become available commercially from ITW Irathane, supra, except that the polyurethane
pad 30 is cast onto the bonding member 40 so that the bonding member 40 is bonded
directly to the polyurethane pad 30. Preferably, the bonding member 40 is made from
steel, galvanized, and powder-coated. Alternatively, the bonding member 40 is made
from a polymeric material.
[0020] As in each embodiment of Figures 1 through 5, the bonding member 40 may be located
in a recess 42 in the polyurethane pad 30. The recess 42 is defined by a marginal
lip 44 surrounding an outer edge 46 of the bonding member 40.
[0021] Preferably, if the bonding member 40 is made from galvanized steel, the bonding member
40 is powder-coated with a coating composition 48 similar to one of the coating compositions
disclosed in
U.S. Patent No. 5,441,373. Preferably, the coating composition 48 comprises a polyester resin, as disclosed
therein. Alternatively, the coating composition 48 comprises an epoxy or acrylic resin,
as disclosed therein.
[0022] When the polyurethane pad 30 is cast onto the bonding member 40, the polyurethane
pad 30 bonds chemically to the composition 48 coating the galvanized steel of the
bonding member 40, whereby the lower surface 52 of the polyurethane pad 30 is bonded
directly to the upper surface 54 of the separating pad 40 so as to resist relative
movement between the bonding member 40 and the polyurethane pad 30. No separate adhesive
is needed, therefore, to bond the polyurethane pad 30 to the bonding member 40.
[0023] Moreover, an adhesive layer 50 is used to bond the bonding member 40 to the concrete
tie 14, at the lower surface 56 of the bonding member 40 and the upper surface 18
of the concrete tie 14, so as to resist relative movement between the bonding member
40 and the concrete tie 14 and so as to retard infiltration of sand, water, or debris
between the bonding member 40 and the concrete tie 14.
[0024] Preferably, the adhesive layer 50 in its uncured state is deposited on the upper
surface 18 of the concrete tie 14, whereupon the composite pad 10 is pressed onto
the adhesive layer 50 so as to spread the adhesive layer 50 until the adhesive layer
50 covers the lower surface 5 6 of the bonding member 40 and the marginal lip 44.
It is permissible for some of the adhesive layer 50 to be thus extruded beyond the
marginal lip 44. Thereupon, the adhesive layer 50 is allowed to cure, until the bonding
member 40 is bonded to the concrete tie 14.
[0025] Preferably, the adhesive layer 50 is comprised of a methacrylate ester composition,
namely the methacrylate ester composition disclosed in a co-pending European application
95306418.5 published as EP-A-
[0026] In the alternative embodiment of Figures 6 and 7, the elastomeric pad 30' is similar
to the elastomeric pad 30 noted above, except that the elastomeric pad 30' does not
have a recess like the recess 42. A particulate layer 40' is used, which comprises
particles 42' bonded directly to the polyurethane pad 30' and which enable the polyurethane
pad 30' to be adhesively bonded to the concrete tie 14. Preferably, the polyurethane
pad 30' is similar to the polyurethane pads that have become available commercially
from ITW Irathane, supra, and is cast in an orientation that is inverted from its
orientation in use (see Figure 7) except that the particles 42' of the particulate
layer 40' are distributed onto the polyurethane pad 30', after such pad 30' has cured
partially but before such pad 30' has cured completely, so that the particles 42'
of the particulate layer 40' are bonded directly and chemically to the polyurethane
pad 30', so that portions of the bonded particles 42' are embedded in the polyurethane
pad 30', and so that portions of the bonded particles 42' are exposed.
[0027] Moreover, an adhesive layer 50' is used to bond the bonded particles 42' to the concrete
tie 14, at the exposed portions of the bonded particles 42' and the upper surface
18 of the concrete tie 14, so as to resist relative movement between the polyurethane
pad 30' and the concrete tie 14 and so as to retard infiltration of sand, water, or
debris between the polyurethane pad 30' and the concrete tie 14.
[0028] Preferably, the adhesive layer 50' in its uncured state is deposited on the upper
surface 18 of the concrete tie 14, whereupon the composite pad 10' comprised of the
elastomeric pad 30' and the particulate layer 40' is pressed onto the adhesive layer
50' so as to spread the adhesive layer 50' until the adhesive layer 50' covers the
lower surface of the polyurethane pad 30' and the exposed portions of the bonded particles
42'. It is permissible for some of the adhesive layer 50' to be thus extruded beyond
the margins of the polyurethane pad 30. Thereupon, the adhesive layer 50' is allowed
to cure so that the adhesive layer 50' is bonded not only to the exposed portions
of the particles 42' bonded to the polyurethane pad 30' but also to the concrete tie
14, whereby the composite pad 10' comprised of the elastomeric pad 30' and the particulate
layer 40' and the concrete tie 14 are bonded to one another via the particulate layer
40' and the adhesive layer 50'.
[0029] Bonding between the adhesive layer 50' and the particles 42' of the particulate layer
40' is a combination of chemical bonding and mechanical bonding. Mechanical bonding
occurs because of interpenetration of the adhesive layer 50' and the particulate layer
40'. It is not necessary, therefore, to have a strong bond between the polyurethane
pad 30' and the adhesive layer 50'.
[0030] Polymeric particles, either granules or fibres, or inorganic particles are suitable,
so long as the adhesive composition selected for the adhesive layer 50' can be chemically
or mechanically bonded to such particles. Thus, polycarbonate, acrylic, or nylon granules
or polycarbonate, acrylic, or nylon fibres are suitable. Also, particles of quartz,
silica sand, silicon carbide, or aluminum oxide may be so employed. Other polymeric
or inorganic particles may prove to be also suitable.
[0031] As an example, polycarbonate pulverized to U.S. 20 Mesh may be distributed as granules
by being shaken through a sieve or by being sprayed through a powder sprayer. As another
example, granules of nylon 12 may be similarly distributed.
[0032] Preferably, the adhesive layer 50' is comprised of a methacrylate ester composition,
namely the methacrylate ester composition disclosed in the co-pending European application
noted above.
[0033] Although the methacrylate ester composition discussed in the immediately preceding
paragraph does not bond well to polyurethane, such as that used for the polyurethane
pad 30', such methacrylate ester composition bonds chemically and mechanically to
any of the polymeric particles discussed in the previously preceding paragraphs and
at least mechanically to any of the inorganic particles discussed in the previously
preceding paragraphs.
[0034] In the embodiment of Figures 8 and 9, the composite pad 10" is configured so as to
co-act with metal clips or clamps known for securing railroad rails to railroad ties
and comprises a polyurethane pad 30" and a bonding layer 40", which is bonded to the
polyurethane pad 30" so as to cover the lower surface of the polyurethane pad 30".
Preferably, the polyurethane pad 30" is a similar to the polyurethane pads that have
become available commercially from ITW Irathane, supra, and is cast in an orientation
that is inverted from its orientation in use (see Figure 9) except that a curable
composition to provide the bonding layer 40" when cured is applied to the upper surface
of the polyurethane pad 30", as cast, before the polyurethane pad 30" has been cured
completely, whereupon the curable composition to provide the bonding layer 40" and
the polyurethane pad 30" are cured together until cured completely.
[0035] Moreover, an adhesive layer 50" is used to bond the composite pad 10" to the concrete
tie 14, at the bonding layer 40" and at the upper surface 18 of the concrete tie 14,
so as to resist relative movement between the polyurethane pad 30" and the concrete
tie 14 and so as to retard infiltration of sand, water, or debris between the composite
pad 10" and the concrete tie 14.
[0036] Preferably, the adhesive layer 50" in its uncured state is deposited on the upper
surface 18 of the concrete tie 14, whereupon the composite pad 10" is pressed onto
the adhesive layer 50" so as to spread the adhesive layer 50 a until the adhesive
layer 50" covers the exposed surface of the bonding layer 40" bonded to the polyurethane
pad 30". It is permissible for some of the adhesive layer 50" to be thus extruded
beyond the margins of the composite pad 10". Thereupon, the adhesive layer 50" is
allowed to cure so that the adhesive layer 50" is bonded not only to the bonding layer
40" bonded to the polyurethane pad 30" but also to the concrete tie 14, whereby the
composite pad 10" and the concrete tie 14 are bonded to one another via the bonding
layer 40" and the adhesive layer 50".
[0037] According to one proposed embodiment, the bonding layer 40" comprises an acrylic
composition that is a product of polymerizing a 20% (by volume) solution of methyl
methacrylate copolymer in n-butyl acrylate monomer. The solution has an addition of
1% (by volume) cumene hydroperoxide to catalyze polymerization and is applied by air
spraying, which is preferred, or by coating, printing, or pouring. After the solution
is applied to the polyurethane pad 30" while the polyurethane pad 30" is partially
cured, the bonding layer 40" is cured (polymerized) by activation of the peroxide
during further curing of the polyurethane pad 30 (at 250° F) 120°C until the bonding
layer 40" and the polyurethane pad 30" are cured completely.
[0038] According to another proposed embodiment, the bonding layer 40" comprises an acrylic
composition that is a product of curing or drying a water-based acrylic emulsion,
which is cured by drying. Either of two water-based acrylic emulsions available commercially
from Johnson Wax of Racine, Wisconsin, under trade designations "Joncryl 74" and "Joncryl
SCX 2660" respectively are suitable.
[0039] Alternatively, the bonding layer 40" is a product of polymerizing a solution of a
thermoplastic elastomer in methyl methacrylate monomer. As an example, the bonding
layer may be a product of polymerizing a solution of 20% (by volume) of Kraton D1117
thermoplastic elastomer available commercially from Shell Chemical Co. of Houston,
Texas, either with an addition of 1 % (by volume) of cumene hydroperoxide to catalyze
polymerization, whereupon heat curing is employed, or with a sprayed coat of a dispersion
of benzoyl peroxide in a plasticizer or in water to catalyze polymerization, whereupon
either ambient curing or heat curing is employed. The dispersion may comprise AFR400
benzoyl peroxide available commercially from Elf Atochem North America, Inc. of Philadelphia,
Pennsylvania.
[0040] Preferably, the adhesive layer 50" is comprised of a methacrylate ester composition,
namely the methacrylate ester composition disclosed in the co-pending European application
noted above.
[0041] Although the methacrylate ester composition discussed in the immediately preceding
paragraph does not bond well to polyurethane, such as that used for the polyurethane
pad 30", such methacrylate ester composition bonds well to any of the acrylic compositions
specified above.
[0042] By this construction, any relative movement between the railroad rail 12 and the
concrete tie 14 that is caused by a train rolling over the rail 12 will be between
the bottom surface 58 of the rail flange 16 and the top surface 54 of the polyurethane
pad 30, 30', or 30", so as to retard infiltration of sand, water, or debris therebetween.
Thus, the deterioration and erosion problems discussed above are alleviated, even
under high loadings, in regions where weather conditions vary widely from summer to
winter, at sharp curves, and at steep grades.
1. A railroad tie (14) is made from concrete and includes a pad (10) mounted on its upper
surface, in use, to receive and engage the lower flange (16) of a railroad rail (12),
characterised in that the pad (10) is a composite pad and comprises an elastomeric pad (30) and bonding
means (40) having an upper surface bonded to the lower surface of the elastomeric
pad (30) so as to resist relative movement between them, the tie (14) further comprising
an adhesive layer (18) bonding the bonding means (40) to its upper surface so as to
resist relative movement between them and so as to retard infiltration of sand, water
or debris between them.
2. A railroad tie according to claim 1, wherein the bonding means is a plate like member
(40) bonded onto, and/or embedded into the lower surface of the elastomeric pad (30).
3. A railroad tie according to claim 1 or claim 2, wherein the plate like member (40)
is made from a galvanised powder-coated steel or a polymeric material such as polycarbonate.
4. A railroad tie according to claim 1, wherein the bonding means comprises particles
or fibres (40') bonded onto the elastomeric material (30) and being partially embedded
within its lower surface.
5. A railroad tie according to claim 4, wherein the particles orfibres (40') are granules
orfibres made from polycarbonate, acrylic or nylon.
6. A railroad tie according to claim 4, wherein the particules are particles of quartz,
silica sand, silicon carbide, or aluminium oxide.
7. A railroad tie according to claim 1, wherein the bonding means (40") comprises a bonding
layer (40") which is at least as flexible as the elastomeric pad (30) contacting the
lower surface of the bonding pad (30).
8. A railroad tie according to claim 7, wherein the bonding layer (40") is an acrylic
composition, or a polymerization product of a thermoplastic elastomer in methyl methacrylate
monomer.
9. A railroad tie according to claim 8, wherein the acrylic composition is a product
of polymerizing a solution of methyl methacrylate copolymer in n-butylacrylate monomer
or is the product of curing or drying a water based acrylic water-based emulsion.
10. A railroad tie according to any one of the preceding claims, in which the adhesive
is a methacrylate ester composition.
11. A railroad tie according to any one of the preceding claims, in which the elastomeric
pad (30) is a polyurethane pad.
12. A railroad track comprising a railroad rail (12) having a lower flange (16) and a
railroad tie (14) in accordance with any one of the preceding claims, the railroad
rail (12) being mounted on the railroad tie (14) with its lower flange (16) engaging
and resting on the elastomeric pad (30).
13. A composite pad (10) for use in a railroad tie (14) in accordance with any one of
the preceding claims, comprising an elastomeric pad (30) and bonding means (40) bonded
directly to the surface of the elastomeric pad (30) so as to resist relative movement
between the elastomeric pad (30) and the bonding means (40).