[0001] The subject of the present invention is use of the AFLP technique which is composed
of the stages: isolation of genomic DNA, digestion of the genomic DNA with one pair
of restriction endonucleases and digestion of another portion of the same DNA with
another pair of restriction endonucleases, annealing of synthetic heteroduplexes to
the free restriction ends, initial amplification of fragments obtained in such a manner
by way of primary PCR, selective amplification, separation of the PCR products in
a polyacrylamide gel, visual profile analysis for the method for the identification
of variability induced by the derivation method in
in vitro cultures
[0002] It is a well established phenomenon that, following plant regeneration from non-differentiated
tissue, the resulting population of clonal individuals is not phenotypically or genetically
homogeneous. Both somaclonal and gametoclonal events contribute to this tissue culture
induced variation. The term somaclonal variation was introduced by Larkin and Scowcroft
[Larkin and Scowcroft 1981] to describe variation arising during somatic cell culture,
while gametoclonal variation represents heritable variation arising during the culture
of cells of gametic origin. The genetic basis underlying somaclonal variation remains
controversial [Bouman and De Klerk 2001, Bregitzer, et al. 1998, Fourré, et al. 1997,
Hossain, et al. 2003, Linacero, et al. 2000, Munthali, et al. 1996] and both the mechanisms
by which it is induced, and the ways in which can be detected and exploited have been
widely discussed in the literature [Brar and Jain 1998, Remotti 1998]. Genetic (DNA
point mutagenesis, microsatellite sequence amplification [Linacero, et al. 2000] and
transposon movement (Peshke and Phillips 1991] and epigenetic (localized changes in
DNA methylation state (Jaligot, et al. 2002, Jaligot, et al. 2000))) events provide
a molecular route to its induction. It is generally accepted that
in vitro systems that require prolonged passage through a callus or cell suspension phase
are the most vulnerable to mutation (Arene, et al. 1993, Freyssinet and Freyssinet
1988, Roseland, et al. 1991, Thomas, et al. 1982), and it has therefore been suggested
that the most effective means of minimizing the variation is to attempt to induce
somatic embryogenesis as rapidly as possible (Gray, et al. 1995). The definition of
the molecular changes underlying
de novo somaclonal variation and the quantification of its frequency have been hindered by
methodological difficulties (Gaj 2001), and this is reflected in the limited description
of this variation (mostly at the phenotypic level) in the literature (Guzy-Wróblewska
and Szarejko 2003). However, a lack of visually detectable changes cannot be taken
to infer a lack of variation at the molecular level (Gaj 2001).
[0003] DNA fingerprinting technology has the potential to detect DNA changes with growing
precision and efficiency. However, neither RFLP- nor RAPD-based approaches have been
particularly successful in recognizing somaclonal variants (Devaux, et al. 1993).
Munthali et al. (Munthali, et al. 1996) identified only three variants out of 5607
RAPD products among a set of regenerated beet plants, and a similarly low frequency
was observed in
Begonia (Bouman and De Klerk 2001). Somewhat better results have been achieved in studies
of protoplast-derived regenerants of
Lolium (Wang, et al. 1993), and from long-term wheat cell culture suspensions (Brown, et
al. 1993). The AFLP technique is potentially more appropriate as a detection platform,
since it both identifies a relatively large number of amplified fragments, and is
more experimentally robust than RAPD, as a result of its use of a more stringent PCR
regime. Despite this, relatively few reports of its use to detect variation in methylation
pattern or somaclonal variation have been published to date (Cervera, et al. 2002,
Portis, et al. 2003, Vendrame, et al. 1999). As an example, it was able to unequivocally
discriminate between embryogenic culture lines of
Carya illinoinensis and was able to group embryos originating from a given line (Vendrame, et al. 1999).
[0004] A feature of AFLP is the flexibility of choice for the two restriction enzymes needed
for the initial digestion of template DNA. Where one or both are sensitive to methylation,
the loss or gain of fragments in a profile can be due either to gain/loss of restriction
sites (sequence variants) or to differential methylation of particular recognition
sites, as pointed out by Donini et al. (Donini, et al. 1997). Isoschizomeric comparisons,
in which one treatment uses a methylation-sensitive, and the other a methylation-insensitive
enzyme have been explored in
Arabidopsis (Cervera, et al. 2002). This method, termed methylation sensitive amplified polymorphism
(MSAP), is particularly suited to the analysis of the molecular basis of somaclonal
variation. The present study describes the elaboration and application of an analytical
method, which enables the detection of tissue culture-induced variation in barley
(Hordeum vulgare L.) both at the nucleotide sequence and at the DNA methylation level. Our aim was further
to compare the frequency and patterns of variation between two different sources of
explants (immature embryos and microspores) and to evaluate the potential of the approach
to quantify the contributions of methylation and sequence alteration to overall variation.
We propose a method flexible enough to study different parts of the genome, and tailored
to giving either a qualitative and quantitative description of tissue culture-induced
variation.
[0005] Patent description
US6300071 (published 2001-10-09) describes a method for detecting nucleic acid methylation using AFLP(TM). The invention
relates to a method for analyzing of determining the methylation pattern of a starting
DNA and/or for distinguishing between methylated and non-methylated sites in the starting
DNA, comprising at least(A) generating a first DNA fingerprint, containing bands corresponding
to both the methylated and non-methylated sites of interest; and/or(B) generating
a second DNA fingerprint, containing bands corresponding only to the methylated sites
of interest; and optionally comprising(C) generating a third DNA fingerprint, containing
bands corresponding only to the non-methylated sites of interest; and optionally further
comprising(D) analysing the fingerprint(s) thus obtained. The fingerprints are preferably
generated using AFLP, by means of a frequent cutter and a methylation sensitive rare
cutter. The invention further relates to specific methods for generating the above
first and second DNA fingerprint by means of AFLP, and kits for use with said methods.
[0006] Patent description
WO9953100 (published 1999-10-21) describes a method for finding genetic markers of somaclonal variation. The invention
provides a method for obtaining molecular markers for use as a diagnostic and quality
control tool to identify genomic polymorphisms that arise during the process of tissue
culture of in vitro propagated plants. By using a representational difference analysis
(RDA) adapted for plant genomes, a set of nucleic acid difference sequences between
normal and off-type plant genomes are obtained. The invention further provides a method
for isolating sets of variant sequences which are common to many naturally occurring
or tissue culture-generated off-types of the same cultivar or species, in addition
to variant sequences present in all off-types, regardless of the phenotypic mutation,
and/or in all off-types that exhibit the same mutation. Detection of somaclonal variation
by the method of the invention may present an opportunity to optimize tissue culture
conditions and to optimize plant multiplication rates without producing a significant
number of off-types.
[0007] Despite the above mentioned research on methods of identifying induced variability
in
in vitro cultures applicable in such uses as obtaining genetically equivalent lines, and which
also facilitate the performance of broadly understood selection of plant material
derived via
in vitro cultures for cultivation purposes, as well as the possibility of producing a molecular
tool for the identification of epigenetic characteristics for cultivation purposes,
a need still exists to produce an effective solution for the quantitative and qualitative
evaluation of variance induced in
in vitro cultures and somaclonal variance.
[0008] The goal of the present invention is to provide tools which could be used into obtain
a method of quantitative and qualitative estimation of induced variability in
in vitro cultures as well as stably inherited changes in subsequent generative generations.
The goal of the present solution is to produce genetically stable lines, including
doubled haploids, to determine the level of their genetic-epigenetic variability,
to facilitate the selection of plant material derived via
in vitro culturing for cultivation purposes, as well as producing easily adaptable molecular
tools for the identification of their epigenetic characteristics for culturing purposes.
The goal is to obtain a method of quantitatively characterizing the variability induced
in
in vitro cultures as well as variation inherited subsequent generative generations, which
would facilitate the evaluation of individual types of variability (sequence and methylation
variability, divided into more specific subtypes) which would allow one to determine
which of the types (subtypes) of variability is dominant, whether sequence variability
is caused by mobile element migration, changes in micro-and macrosatellite regions,
within gene families, etc.
[0009] The realization of such a stated goal to provide solutions to the problems described
in the state of the art, in order to provide tools which could be used into obtain
a method of quantitative and qualitative estimation of induced variability in
in vitro cultures as well as variation inherited as a result of generative propagation, which
would facilitate the selection of plant materials derived
through in vitro culture for cultivation purposes, the application of said methodology to determine
what percentage of variability sequence or methylation variability (methylated and
non-methylated sites) was stably passed onto plant progeny, were achieved in the present
invention.
[0010] The topic of the subject invention is use of the AFLP technique which is composed
of the stages: isolation of genomic DNA, digestion of the genomic DNA with one pair
of restriction endonucleases and digestion of another portion of the same DNA with
another pair of restriction endonucleases, annealing of synthetic heteroduplexes to
the free restriction ends, initial amplification of fragments obtained in such a manner
by way of primary PCR, selective amplification, separation of the PCR products in
a polyacrylamide gel, visual profile analysis for the method for the identification
of variability induced by the derivation method in
in vitro cultures at the level of regenerant plants, as well as variation inherited as a result
of generative propagation consisting of the following stages:
- 1) estimation of the repeatability of the two AFLP technique variants: repeatability
control of AFLP based on the identity of several DNA samples of the same plant through
the use of AFLP and isoschizomers both sensitive and insensitive to methylation at
the restriction-site and/or adjacent areas as well as a representative number of pairs
of selective primers identical in all AFLP analyses;
- 2) estimation of the repeatability of the two AFLP technique variants: repeatability
control of AFLP based on the identity of several DNA samples of the same plant through
the use of AFLP and isoschizomers both sensitive and insensitive to methylation at
the restriction-site and/or adjacent areas as well as a representative number of pairs
of selective primers using a different set of selective AFLP primers than those used
in the other AFLP analyses;
- 3) identification of variability induced by the method of derivation of the regenerants
in relation to the donor plant is performed in two AFLP variants using isoschizomers
both sensitive and insensitive to methylation at the restriction-site and/or adjacent
areas as well as a representative number of pairs of selective primers identical in
all AFLP analyses;
- 4) the identification of the tissue culture induced variability among regenerants
in relation to the donor plant is performed in two AFLP technique variants utilising
isoschizomers both sensitive and insensitive to methylation at the restriction-site
and/or adjacent areas as well as a representative number of pairs of selective primers
identical in all AFLP analyses;
- 5) the identification of somaclonal variability among regenerant progeny in relation
to the donor plant is carried out using two AFLP technique variants utilising isoschizomers
both sensitive and insensitive to methylation at the restriction-site and/or adjacent
areas as well as a representative number of pairs of selective primers identical in
all AFLP analyses;
- 6) the molecular analysis of the experimental material using the AFLP technique taking
into account isoschizomers both sensitive and insensitive to methylation at the restriction-site
and/or adjacent areas as well as a representative number of pairs of selective primers
identical in all AFLP analyses is comprised of the following stages:
- a) analyses of AFLP patterns of donor plants with respect to genetic and epigenetic
variability induced during the generative propagation of an individual plant, a control
of generative propagation,
- b) analyses of AFLP patterns for the control of the reproducibility of both AFLP technique
variants,
- c) analysis of AFLP patterns for regenerants in comparison to donor plants or separate
régénérants in relation to appropriate donor plants;
- d) danalyses of AFLP patterns for donor plant, its regenerant and regenerant progeny,
or distinct regenerant progeny lines along with appropriate donor and its regenerant
plants;
- 7) identification of the 14 types of events recognized at the binary matrix level
for systems sensitive and insensitive to methylation, which are the result of a comparison
between the donor plant with regenerants and between donor plant with regenerant progeny
simultaneously in two AFLP systems, wherein the identification of event types is carried
out individually for each regenerant and as bulk for regenerant progenies and is represented
as 14 binary matrices which describe each of the events independently, subdivided
into methods of derivation; wherein the columns represent consecutive regenerants
or bulks and rows represent consecutive AFLP fragments;
- 8) assignment of certain event types to a given type of variability induced the method
of derivation in relation to each regenerant;
- 9) identification of the 14 types of events recognized at the binary matrix level
for systems sensitive and insensitive to methylation, which are the result of a comparison
between the donor plant with regenerant simultaneously in two AFLP systems;
- 10) identification of the 14 types of events recognized at the binary matrix level
for systems sensitive and insensitive to methylation, which are the result of a comparison
between the donor plant with regenerant progeny simultaneously in two AFLP systems,
where the identification of event types is performed through the summation of the
genotypes of a given summary progeny, and through the comparison of such a total AFLP
profile of regenerant progeny with the donor plant profile,
- 11) the bulk regenerant progeny genotype expressed via an AFLP profile for systems
sensitive and insensitive to methylation at the level of individual AFLP fragments
has a different value from that of the donor plant in a given AFLP system, so long
as a given fragment within it is polymorphic, or is totally different from this value
for the donor plant; in the opposite case the values for the donor plant and bulk
regenerant progeny for a given AFLP fragment in a given AFLP system are identical,
- 12) production of a quantitative matrix for regenerants, where the columns contain
data for consecutive regenerants grouped by the method of derivation, and the rows
contain the 14 types of events which may be assigned to each regenerant progeny;
- 13) production of a quantitative matrix for regenerant progeny, where the columns
contain bulk data for regenerant progeny grouped by the method of derivation, and
the rows contain the 14 types of events which may be assigned to each bulk regenerant
progeny;
- 14) production of a quantitative matrix for events in regenerants, where this is a
quantitative matrix for post-transposition regenerants, where the columns contain
14 events and the rows contain regenerants grouped by the method of derivation;
- 15) calculation of the total number of events based on the binary matrix for individual
methods of derivation of regenerants as well as for regenerants, where the total number
of events is calculated as a product of the number of AFLP fragments identified in
both AFLP systems for all pairs of selective primers multiplied by the number of regenerants
derived by a given method;
- 16) calculation of the total number of events based on the binary matrix for individual
methods of derivation of regenerants as well as for regenerant progenies in bulk,
where the total number of events corresponds to the number of DNA fragments identical
or different in both AFLP systems for all pairs of selective primers used in the analysis;
- 17) calculation of the error stemming from generative propagation is carried out based
on the binary matrix of donor plants and a single plant; determination of the number
of events different from those in a single plant belonging to the donor plants, and
the calculation of the total number of events for the donor plants;
- 18) calculation of the error stemming from the AFLP technique is carried out based
on the binary matrix for DNA samples obtained from the same plant and subjected to
the stages of the AFLP technique using isoschizomers sensitive and insensitive to
methylation at the restriction site or its immediate surroundings as well as a representative
number of selective starter pairs identical in all AFLP systems, where the total number
of events and the number of polymorphic events are calculated, and the latter number
is expressed as a percentage;
- 19) determination, based on binary matrices for regenerants and the donor plant, of
groups of events describing: (a) sequence variation connected with any changes in
DNA nucleotide sequences based on AFLP data from the system insensitive to methylation
and (b) epigenetic variability, the de novo variability of methylation patterns, and additionally mixed variation which is sequence
and methylation variability based on data for both AFLP systems;
- 20) determination, based on binary matrices for bulk regenerant progeny and the donor
plant, of event groups describing (a) sequence variation comiected with all DNA nucleotide
changes based on AFLP data from the system insensitive to methylation and (b) epigenetic
variability, the de novo variability of methylation patterns, and additionally mixed variation which is sequence
and methylation variability, and (c) inheritance of methylation patterns as related
to the presence and/or lack of methylation at the restriction site or its vicinity,
based on data for both AFLP systems;
- 21) identification of events particularly subject to the activity of factors inducing
variability in in vitro cultures;
- 22) sequence analysis of individual event types and/or broad sequence variability,
where variability is identified using AFLP technique variants using primers directed
against conservative sequences within mobile elements, repeating sequences or the
sequences of conservative gene families;
- 23) statistical analysis of the donor plant and its regenerants as well as regenerant
progeny, and possibly distinct regenerants and regenerant progenies along with appropriate
donor plants, as well as AFLP reproducibility control and generative propagation control:
a) statistical analysis of the results of AFLP using parametric analysis, Mantel's
test and/or Cronbach's alpha coefficient as well as molecular variance analysis using
the Fs,or Phis, coefficients;
b) determination of the error of the tissue culture induced and somaclonal variability
estimates, based on the Mantel test correlation coefficient;
c) determination of the quantitative parameters of variability induced by the method
of derivation of regenerants and somaclonal variability for regenerants, individual
regenerant progenies, talcing into account the method of derivation and giving their
statistical significance level;
d) statistic determination of differences between individual types of events induced
in in vitro cultures for regenerants, as well as bulk regenerant progeny, grouped by method of
derivation and supplemented by their statistical significance using quantitative matrices
of events;
e) statistical analysis of the comparison between variability induced by the method
of derivation as well as somaclonal variation, determined through the comparison of
the donor plant profile, and the bulk profile of regenerant progeny and their types:
sequence variability and/or broad sequence variability, de novo methylation, demethylation, mixed variability, inheritance of: methylation patterns,
non-methylated sites or conservative sites in regenerant progeny, grouped by method
of derivation as well as a comparison by method of derivation of regenerant progeny,
where quantitative matrices are used for events;
a) statistical comparisons of regenerants, and the bulk regenerant progenies for different
methods of derivation for a given regenerant progeny, where quantitative matrices
of the progeny are used;
b) statistical comparison of the results of the above mentioned points for individual
regenerants and bulk regenerant progenies amongst one another;
h) statistical or qualitative comparison of somaclonal variation between individual
plants being the generative progeny of regenerants;
i) collation of the existing results in the form of a compilation indicating quantitative
characteristics of variability induced by the method of derivation determined at the
regenerant level, as well as quantitative characteristics of inherited variability
determined at the level of regenerant progeny.
[0011] Preferentially the identification of the 14 types of events recognized at the level
of binary matrix is selected from among the events represented in Fig. 7.
[0012] Preferentially to derive donor plants, a single plant is used which is a doubled
haploid derived from an isolated microspore, wherein it is treated as a control of
the genetic and epigenetic variability of donor plants.
[0013] Preferentially genetic and epigenetic variability of generatively propagated material,
donor plants, is determined based on AFLP profiles obtained from restriction endonuclease
isoschizomers recognizing and digesting identical sequences, but differing in their
sensitivity to methylation at or about the restriction site, wherein one of the isoschizomers
is insensitive to methylation.
[0014] Preferentially in a system sensitive and insensitive to methylation no differences
are observed in the AFLP profiles of donor plants, then the level of variability induced
through generative propagation and identified with a given pair of selective primers
is insignificant.
[0015] Preferentially when there are differences in AFLP profiles for donor plants between
a system sensitive and a system insensitive to methylation, a percentage portion of
such an event is determined, along with the background level, generative propagation
error.
[0016] Preferentially when there are differences in AFLP profiles for experimental replicants
on the same DNA samples, the AFLP technique error is estimated in order to determine
experimental error.
[0017] Preferentially the integral portion of the research material is composed of donor
plants, along with a single plant, donor plant regenerants and separate regenerant
progenies.
[0018] Preferentially the donor plant along with regenerants and regenerant progeny compose
the core of research material for the study of variability induced by the method of
derivation or somaclonal variability, respectively.
[0019] Preferentially the molecular analysis is performed using the AFLP technique in two
variants, using isoschizomers differing in their sensitivity to methylation.
[0020] Preferentially one of the isoschizomers is completely insensitive to methylation.
[0021] Preferentially in the identification of segregated PCR products, and isotope marker
is used which is introduced to the 5' end of the primer complementary to the adaptor
annealed to the restriction site freed by the isoschizomers.
[0022] Preferentially other methods of visualising AFLP fragments are used, including fluorescence.
[0023] Preferentially the profiles of both AFLP variants for the donor plant along with
its regenerants and taking into account the method of derivation and AFLP reproducibility
control are performed on identical AFLP primer pairs.
[0024] Preferentially AFLP profile analysis and their conversion to binary matrices is based
on the fact that the AFLP profiles of both restrictase systems for all pairs of selective
primers are entered as a binary matrix into a spreadsheet, where the data set obtained
for one pair of selective AFLP primers is placed below the previous one such that
each column represents a total binary profile for a donor plant in one AFLP system,
and the subsequent columns contain analogous data for regenerants and controls, wherein
data for the second AFLP system is recorded in subsequent columns, wherein the bands
from one system are ordered like those from the previous system (in rows), and where
a given band does not appear a zero is entered in the appropriate row of the spreadsheet.
[0025] Preferentially AFLP profile analysis and their conversion to binary matrices is based
on the fact that the AFLP profiles of both restrictase systems for all pairs of selective
primers are entered as a binary matrix into a spreadsheet, where the data set obtained
for one pair of selective AFLP primers is placed below the previous one such that
each column represents a total binary profile for a donor plant in one AFLP system,
and the subsequent columns contain analogous data for regenerant progenies and controls,
wherein data for the second AFLP system is recorded in subsequent columns, wherein
the bands from one system are ordered like those from the previous system (in rows),
and where a given band does not appear a zero is entered in the appropriate row of
the spreadsheet.
[0026] Preferentially AFLP profile for regenerant progeny is represented in the form of
a bulk genotype per AFLP variant, sensitive and insensitive to methylation separately.
[0027] Preferentially the generative propagation control is carried out through the summation
of the number of signals (events) from a single plant, where the number of changes
is calculated as a percentage of the total number of events.
[0028] Preferentially the parametric analysis, Mantel's test correlation analysis and molecular
variability analysis are performed using binary matrices of AFLP systems sensitive
and insensitive to methylation for regenerants and/or regenerant progeny depending
on whether the variability induced in culture or inherited by regenerant progeny are
being analyzed.
[0029] Preferentially the factorial analysis is used as the graphical representation of
the AFLP results.
[0030] Preferentially the identification of the 14 types of events recognized at the level
of AFLP pattern and assigned to variability induced by the method of derivation is
performed on the basis of AFLP patterns, wherein the donor plant profile is used along
with regenerant profiles in both systems, and subsequently the profile of each regenerant
is compared to the donor plant profile in order to identify these events.
[0031] Preferentially the identification of the 14 types of events recognized at the level
of AFLP patterns and assigned to somaclonal variability is carried out on the basis
of AFLP patterns, where the donor plant profile is used along with profiles in both
AFLP systems, and the bulk profile of regenerant progeny is compared to the donor
plant profile in order to identify event types, wherein it is assumed that in case
of polymorphic AFLP fragments of the bulk regenerant progeny genotype, a value different
than that of the donor plant is entered or a different value if it is different from
that of the donor plant in all regenerant progenies for a given AFLP system.
[0032] Preferentially when the 14 event types comprise the basis for their segregation into
groups: sequence variability, methylation variability (methylation and demethylation),
mixed variability and inheritance of methylation patterns, wherein it is taken into
account that sequence variability is unequivocally confirmed in a system insensitive
to methylation.
[0033] Preferentially the analysis of the significance of individual variability types and
events within regenerants and regenerant progeny plants, as grouped by the method
of derivation, is performed based on qualitative matrices and quantitative matrices
of events describing all theoretically possible events, as well as regenerant plants
and regenerant progeny.
[0034] Preferentially the statistical analysis results for individual regenerants and bulk
regenerant progenies obtained through various means are compiled into a whole; quantitative
parameters are entered for variability induced by the method of derivation and of
somaclonal variability for individual regenerants and bulk regenerant progenies as
well as for separate regenerant progenies grouped by the method of derivation and
event types along with statistical parameters.
[0035] Preferentially those event types are identified, which are rare in culture or which
do not occur at all, as well as those which are particularly subject to the activity
of factors inducing variability at the level of regenerant and regenerant progeny,
as well as to determine their quantitative parameters.
[0036] Preferentially individual event types are studied at the molecular level through
the sequence analysis of AFLP fragments representing individual types of events, and
by the same token types of somaclonal variability.
[0037] Preferentially one or more bulk regenerant progeny is analyzed.
[0038] Preferentially the quantitative characteristics of an event are given for each individual
regenerant progeny: sequence variability, broad sequence variability, epigenetic variability
of methylation patterns
(de novo methylation, demethylation), stability of inherited methylated and non-methylated
sites (conservative), against changes induced in cultures as well as entering quantitative
differences in variability between different derivation methods of plant material.
[0039] Preferentially statistical analysis is performed of the significance of individual
event types among the regenerants, bulk regenerant progeny and individual regenerant
progenies as needed, grouped by the method of derivation of the research material.
Preferentially the somaclonal variability level of individual plants which are regenerant
progeny is determined independenly, using the principles used for somaclonal variability.
[0040] Preferentially the hypotheses relating to the sources of variability induced by the
method of derivation of regenerants and that inherited as a result of generative propagation
are tested.
[0041] Preferentially the detailed analysis is performed of the causes of sequence variability
after introducing minor AFLP procedural changes, based on the selective amplification
of research material using a tagged primer complementary to conservative sites of
transposable elements, or to macrosatellite sequences.
[0042] Preferentially the segregation of genetic and epigenetic markers are analyzed for
mapping populations derived through plant-plant crosses which are the progeny of regenerants
with a known genotype, based on AFLP profiles for both AFLP systems. Preferentially
the method is designed for deriving plants
in vitro with a lowered or enhanced level of somaclonal variability through the identification
of the causes of this variability.
[0043] Preferentially the genetic and epigenetic purity of arbitrary material derived through
in vitro culture is verified.
[0044] Preferentially when the method is used in the analysis of the inheritance of epigenetic
variability during sexual crossing.
[0045] Preferentially the method is a tool for the identification of epigenetic markers
linked with the utilitarian characteristics of the plant material.
[0046] Preferentially the method is used for the identification of differences in DNA methylation
patterns for various tissues of an individual plant.
[0047] The attached figures facilitate a better description of the nature of the present
invention.
Figure 1 represents general scheme for the evaluation of plant materials to study
tissue culture induced (level 7) and somaclonal variation (level 8) due to regeneration
method (level 6). Generative reproduction induced variation and purity of the initial
material along with the reproducibility of the AFLP approaches are verified at 5.
In the described example regenerants and donor plants.were analyzed (level 7) following
embryo- and androgenesis paths only.
Figure 2 represents arrangements of the theoretical donor and regenerant genotypes
and AFLP patterns putatively amplified by Acc65I/MseI and KpnIlMseI digests. The first and the third number reflect donor and the second and fourth
numbers regenerant profiles; the first two numbers depict Acc65I/MseI and the remaining KpnI/MseI digests. 1 and 0 state for presence and absence of a band on a profile.
Figure 3 represents Acc65IlMseI and KpnIlMseI metAFLP fingerprints of the regenerants (lines 1-19) and donor (D) plant, respectively;
lanes 1-7 - regenerants obtained via embryogenesis; lanes 8-19 - regenerants obtained
via androgenesis (see
Figure 1); different types of arrows indicate some of the events described as present/absent
"1-0" according to the Fig. 7; v.i. - band of variable intensity.
Figure 4 represents Clustering of the Acc56I/MseI and KpnIlMseI data. 'a-r' - states for Acc65I/MseI and 'k-r' for KpnIlMseI, numbers following 'a-r' or 'k-r' reflect the given regenerated plant. 'Aparent' and
'Kparent' state for donor plant.
Figure 5 represents factorial analysis of the fingerprint data generated by Acc65I/MseI and KpnI/MseI digests based on DNAs of the regenerated plants.
Figure 6 represents primer sequences for metAFLP.
Figure 7 represents variants detected by metAFLP. Acc65I/MseI and KpnI/MseI enzyme pairs were used for the digestion of templates; 1/0 - AFLP band is present/missing.
AFLP pattern column: the first two figures state for Acc65I/MseI and the reminder for KpnIlMseI digests; first and third positions reflect donor and second and fourth regenerant
profiles. Column "Event type" classifies the given pattern to the event type. Additionally,
the information is given whether the pattern is unequivocal. E, A and S state for
embryo-, androgenesis-derived regenerants and all regenerants taken together expressed
as absolute and normalized (%) values. Calculations of the tissue culture induced
variation are based on event types.
[0048] Example embodiments of the present invention defined above are presented below.
Plant material
[0049] A single double haploid barley plant, obtained via androgenesis from an isolated
microspore (Oleszczuk, et al. 2005) was self-fertilised. A set of its sixteen progeny
plants that did not differ in phenotypes was grown under controlled conditions (16h/8h
day/night regime, light intensity 27 µmolm
-2s
-1 and day/night temperatures of, respectively, 10°C and 12°C). The set was used to
test cryptic segregation due to sexual propagation at the molecular level. After reaching
proper developmental stage one progeny plant - donor one (Fig 1 general scheme) was
exploited as a source of immature embryos and anthers. Somatic embryogenesis was induced
from immature embryo-derived calli (Zimny and Lörz 1989) grown for three weeks on
semi-solid N6 medium (Chu 1978) containing 2mgl
-1 2.4-D. Somatic embryos were excised from callus, and transferred to a regeneration
medium containing 0.4µM kinetin in order to encourage their germination. Emerging
plantlets were transferred to Erlenmeyer flasks until they reached a height of 10-12cm,
after which they were potted, acclimatized for two weeks, and finally grown under
standard greenhouse conditions to maturity. To induce androgenesis, tillers of the
donor plant were harvested when the microspores were between the uninucleate and the
two-nucleate pollen stage. The cut ends of the tillers were held in water under low
light intensity for 7 days at 4°C. The spikes were then surface sterilized by dipping
first in 70% ethanol and then in 10% sodium hypochloride, after which they were rinsed
five times in sterile water. Anthers were excised, placed on semi-solid N6 medium
(Chu 1978) supplemented with 2mgl
-1 2,4-D and 0.5µM kinetin, and cultured in 6cm diameter Petri dishes in the dark at
26°C. Embryogenic calli were transferred to 190-2 regeneration medium (Pauk, et al.
1991). Developed androgenic embryos were transferred onto fresh 190-2 medium (Zhuang
and Xu 1983) supplemented with hormones according to Pauk (Pauk, et al. 1991) and
solidified with 5g/l Phytagel, and kept under a 16h/8h day / night regime. Plantlets
were rooted in glass tubes, and later potted, transferred to a growth chamber for
a short acclimatization period, and grown to maturity in a controlled environment
chamber. Before anthesis, spikes of each regenerant plant were bagged to ensure self-pollination.
The two sets of regenerants, obtained via somatic embryogenesis (Set: Regenerants
'E'), and via androgenesis (Set: Regenerants 'A' level 7, Figure 1), along with that
of the donor plant, provided the material to study tissue culture-induced variation.
DNA manipulation
[0050] Total genomic DNA was isolated from approximately 100mg of 7-day-old seedling leaf
using the DNeasy MiniPrep Kit (Qiagen). metAFLP oligonucleotides were obtained from
the Centre for Macromolecular Studies of the Polish Academy of Sciences (Lódź) (sequences
listed in Table 1). The AFLP procedure followed Vos, et al. (Vos, et al. 1995) with
minor modifications (Bednarek, et al. 2002), using the restriction enzyme pairs
Acc651I/
MseI and
KpnI
lMseI for the initial digestion of genomic DNA. About 500ng of genomic DNA was digested
with
Acc65I/
MseI and a similar quantity with
KpnI
lMseI at 37°C for 3h, stopping the reaction with an incubation of 15min incubation at
70°C. The relevant adaptors were ligated to the restriction digest in a final volume
of 25µl at 20°C for 12h and diluted 1:3 in TE buffer. Non-selective PCR was performed
using a standard amplification profile, in a total volume of 25µl using pre-selective
primers (Table 1), and this reaction was diluted 1:20 in TE. Labelled selective PCRs
were carried out in a final volume of 10µl in the presence of 5'-(
32P) labelled selective primers. Following PCR, samples were denatured by adding 6µl
of 80% formamide loading buffer in the presence of bromophenol blue and xylene cyanol
dyes. After a denaturation step (95°C for 10 minutes followed by quenching at 5°C),
6µl of reaction were loaded on a 7% 50cm x 0.4mm denaturing polyacrylamide gel. After
electrophoresis, X-ray films were exposed to gels overnight at -70°C.
Data scoring and analysis
[0051] XIStat-pro v.7.5.2 excel add-in software (www.x1stat.com, Addinsoft) was used to
perform clustering (UPGMA, Jaccard's coefficient) and factorial (Pearson correlation
coefficient without axes rotation) analyses. Estimates of similarity were based on
Jaccard's coefficient and clustering was performed by UPGMA (Saiotu and Nei 1986).
Analysis of molecular variance (AMOVA) and the Mantel test was carried out using GeneAlex5.1
excel add-in software (Peakall and Smouse 2001). The analytical treatment of the data
is explained in the context of the results themselves (see below, Table 2). Kruskal-Wallis
statistics (XIStat-pro v.7.5.2) were used to test whether the extent of tissue culture
induced variation differed significantly between the embryo- and androgenesis-derived
regenerants and among all regenerants.
Results
Testing the uniformity of the sexually-derived progeny
[0052] AFLP templates of the sixteen sexually derived plants were generated from both
Acc65I/
MseI and
KpnI/
MseI digests, and amplified with ten selective primer combinations (CpG-GGC/MCAA; CpG-GGC/MCAC;
CpG-GGC/MCAG; CpXpG-AGA/MCAC; CpXpG-AGA/MCCA; pXpG-AGC/MCAC; CpXpGAGC/MCGA; CpXpG-AGC/MCGC;
CpXpG-AGG/MCAA; CpXpG-AGT/MCGC) to produce a total of 764 fragments over both digests.
The profiles were invariant across all sixteen plants, except in the cases of selective
primer combination (CpG-GGC/MCAC) which delivered two variable
Acc65I/
MseI fragments, and CpXpG-AGT/MCGC, which produced one variable
KpnI
lMseI fragment. Thus the background rate of variation is of the order of 0.26% in
Acc651/
MseI and 0.13%
KpnIlMseI. When recalculated on the basis of the number of events (total number of polymorphic
signals that differed from the most representative 0 or 1 signals divided by the number
of plants and multiplied by number of the scored AFLPs), we conclude that the sexual
mode of reproduction generates polymorphism at a frequency of 0.03 to 0.04%.
Testing embryo and androgenesis-derived regenerants
[0053] In all, 19 independent viable plants were regenerated from tissue culture. These
consisted of seven in set E and twelve in set A. All plants were fully self-fertile
and resembled their mother plant in phenotype. Uniform and reproducible fingerprints
were generated from the templates of the parental donor and its regenerants using
seven selective primer pairs (CpXpGAGG/CAG; CpG-GCA/MCGC; CpXpG-AGC/MCCA; CpXpG-AGG/MCAC;
CpGGGC/MCAA; CpXpG-TGC/MCCG; CpXpG-AGA/MCAA) (Figure 3). A total, 272 fragments were
identified across both the
Acc65I/
MseI and
KpnI
lMseI AFLP profiles. In each of the sets of profiles, 229 fragments were invariant within
the test DNA set (all regenerants and the donor plant). In all, 206 fragments were
monomorphic across all samples.
Acc65I and
KpnI each identified 43 polymorphic fragments, of which 23 were specific to, but monomorphic
within one of the isoschizomer combinations. Among these, eight
Acc65I/
MseI and seven
KpnI
lMseI fragments varied only with respect to band intensity.
Statistical analysis
[0054] Cluster analysis demonstrated that the DNAs of the regenerated plants digested with
Acc65I/
MseI formed clusters that were distinct and independent from those digested with
KpnI
lMseI
. No individual subclusters for sets 'E' or 'A' were evident (Figure 4). A factorial
analysis (convergence 0.001 after 25 iterations) showed that variables F1 and F2 explain
98% of the variation identified between the
Acc65I/
MseI and
KpnI
lMseI sets. The respective proportions for F1-F3 and F2-F3 were 67% and 33%. Once again
two clusters were formed, with the
KpnI
lMseI group being more compact than the
Acc65I/
MseI one (Figure 5). AMOVA showed that 69% of the variation resulted from differences
between the two digests, but nonetheless the data sets remain highly correlated, as
indicated by the Mantel test (R
2>0.9991, p=0.001).
Explanation of metAFLP patterns
[0055] The experimental system was designed to detect a number of distinct events that may
have occurred during tissue culture. The isoschizomers recognize the same cleavage
sequence, but differ in their sensitivity to methylation at the recognition site:
Acc65I digests non-methylated, but not methylated sequences, whereas
KpnI is insensitive to recognition site methylation. The various changes detectable by
this metAFLP approach are summarized in Table 2, in which regenerant profiles are
compared to those of the donor. Most (seven) of the patterns could have been generated
by a single event, although for some variants more than one explanation is possible.
For example, the '0011' pattern describes a fragment that is methylated in both the
donor and the regenerant template, so that it is present in the
KpnI/
MseI
, but absent in the
Acc56I
lMseI digest, and is not a tissue culture-induced event; while the '0101' pattern is delivered
where a tissue culture-induced event introduces a non-methylated recognition site
not present in the parental template. In contrast, the '1000' pattern could have been
generated either from the de-methylation of a single methylated site or the de-methylation
of the external site (if two adjacent sites are considered). Some of the patterns
could not be assigned to a single event ('0010' or '0001') and these are referred
to as 'mixed variation'. All possible donor - regenerant pairs are given in figure
2 and permissible classification of the AFLP pattern to the appropriate event type.
Tissue culture-induced variation
[0056] Among the regenerants, 11 out of the 14 possible patterns described in Table 2 were
observed at least once. Two mixed (0100 and 1001) and a single sequence variation
(0010) patterns were not detected. Across all the regenerants, 94.7% of the restriction
fragments were conserved with respect to methylation status, 95.1 and 94.4% were conserved
for the embryo- and anther-derived plants. Of these invariant sequences, non-methylated
recognition sites were much commoner than methylated ones. Our estimation of tissue
culture-induced event frequency was based on the following reasoning: first, the total
number of events (5168) was taken as the number of analyzed
Acc65I/
MseIand
KpnI
lMseI fragments (272) times the number (19) of regenerants. The equivalent numbers for
the E and A regenerants were, respectively, 7x272 (1904) and 12x272 (3264). Distinct
tissue culture-induced events were identified by scoring for the presence/absence
of fragments in the two digests, across the donor and the regenerant DNAs, as detailed
in Table 2 (If the band was missing in one of the digests and present in the second
in at least case then it was scored as zero and one, respectively, resulting in two
0-1 matrices of the same dimension). The total number of changes was equal to the
whole number events less that of the methylation inheritance (0011 and 1100 patterns).
This value equals the number of events comprising total tissue culture-induced variation.
The frequency of changes in
KpnI
lMseI digest was calculated as the total number of differences among donor and regenerant
profiles and gives an estimate of sequence variation. Then, the frequency of tissue
culture-induced site methylation is the difference between that for total tissue culture-induced
variation and that identified in the
KpnI
lMseI digests. These are converted to percentages by using the appropriate total number
of fragments surveyed (5168, 1904 and 3264 for total, E and A). For example, the total
number of changes identified based on both digests is 275 (5.3%), the number of sequence
changes 101 (2.0%), and the number of methylation variants 174 (3.4%). This last estimate
comprises percentages of total tissue culture induced variation (TTCV) less than percentages
of sequence variation (SV) calculated based on
KpnI
lMseI digest. Calculation of the TTCV is the sum of 11 events (Table 2) normalized by
the number of events and expressed in percentages. Conserved sites (those that did
not change methylation status) were defined in percentage terms as all scored sites
less TTCV varied sites (94.7% across all regenerants). Inherited methylation sites
were scored as all the sites that did not change methylation status (remaining either
methylated or non-methylated). These represent 12.7% of fragments. The frequency of
de-methylation is of the same level in somatic and in gametic cells (0.4%). In contrast,
de novo methylation occurred a bit less frequently in 'E' (1.1%) than in 'A' (1.4%). Our
estimate of the overall frequencies of methylation events over the two regenerant
types is, respectively, 3.0% and 3.6%. 'Mixed events' accounted for 1.5% and 2.0%,
respectively. Similarly, the frequencies of sequence variation were 1.9% and 2.1%.
Finally, the overall proportions of restriction fragments altered as a consequence
of the tissue culture treatment were 4.9% and 5.6% for, respectively, the E and A
regenerant.
[0057] All the regenerated plants displayed either sequence variation or/and changes in
methylation pattern, with a mean of about 14 alterations per plant. About 44% of the
changes affected the embryogenesis-derived plants. There was little difference in
the mean number of sequence changes and alterations in methylation patterns between
the embryo- and the anther-derived plants. The tissue culture-induced variation was,
however, unevenly distributed among the regenerants, varying from 10 to 16 events
in the former, and from 13 to 20 in the latter regenerant types. The Kruskal-Wallis
statistics, however, suggest that there is no significant effect of regeneration mode
on the extent of tissue culture-induced variation.
Hotspots of tissue culture induced variation
[0058] We observed eight fragments which appear to have behaved as hotspots of variation,
in the sense that all or nearly all of the regenerated plants were altered in sequence
or in methylation status in relation to the donor. Thus for example, the
Acc65I profile of all regenerants included a fragment that was absent in the donor, while
the same fragment was present in the
KpnI profiles of both donor and regenerant. The events were classified as mixed (0100
-100%; two 1000 - 100%;), de-methylation (0111 - 100%), de novo methylation (1011
- 95%) and sequence change and three sequence (0001-100%; 0001 - 95%; 1010 - 95%)
events.
[0059] An important finding is that nearly 95% of sites were faithfully transmitted to all
the regenerant plants independently of how they were regenerated (via embryo or androgenesis).
Interestingly, only ca. 12% of the sites remain stably methylated which is nearly
seven times less than non-methylated ones. This data is comparable with that of (Chakrabarty,
et al. 2003) who assessed the extent and pattern of cytosine methylation during somatic
embryogenesis in
Eleurenococcus senticosus, and showed that over 11% of sites were methylated in embryogenic callus tissue. Rather
higher estimates of the extent of methylation have been obtained in rice (16%), and
in embryo-derived oil palm (20%) by (Jaligot, et al. 2000).
[0060] The strategy we have developed has allowed us to both quantify and qualify the tissue
culture-induced variation in barley plants regenerated from embryos and microspores.
We show that this occurs at a frequency of two magnitudes higher than the background
rate associated with sexual reproduction, and have been able to partition the variation
into changes in methylation state and sequence, to estimate the proportion of sites
unaffected by variation, to distinguish between methylated and non-methylated sites,
and to predict the appearance of bands with varying intensity. We may also examine
changes that affected individual plants and specify the degree they may differ from
the donor one. Although not attempted here we believe that by using specially designed
selective primers it should be possible to differentiate among various types of methylation
and thereby obtain some insight into sequence-variation defining whether it is induced
by migration of mobile elements, by changes in microsatellite copy number or by mutations
within functional genomic regions belonging to different protein families. We believe
that our analytical approach is the first which can differentiate between the two
major classes of tissue-induced epigenetic (methylation) and genetic (sequence mutation)
variation, and provide a quantitative and qualitative description of their relative
contribution. This represents a means to access tissue-induced variation among regenerants
sharing a uniform phenotype. Moreover, after minor modifications the approach could
be used to study inheritance of the tissue culture induced variation among progenies
of the regenerants giving characteristics of somaclonal variation. It is possible
to anticipate the development of this approach for the dissection of epigenetic inheritance.
REFERENCES
[0061]
Aina R, Sgorbati S, Santagostino A, Labra M, Ghiani A, Citterio S. (2004) Specific
hypomethylation of DNA is induced by heavy metals in white clover and industrial hemp.
Physiol Plant 121:472-480.
Arene L, Pellegrino C, Gudin S. (1993) A comparison of the somaclonal variation level
of Rosa hybrida L. cv. Meirutral plants regenerated from callus or direct induction
from different vegetative and embryonic tissues. Euphitica 71:83-90.
Bednarek PT, Kubicka H, Zawada M. (2002) Morphology, cytology and BSA based testing
on limited segregation population AFLPs. Cell Mol Biol Let 7:635-648.
Bouman H, De Klerk G-J. (2001) Measurement of the extent of somaclonal variation in
begonia plants regenerated under various conditions. Comparison of three assays. Theor
Appl Genet 102:111-117.
Brar DS, Jain SM. (1998) Somaclonal variation: mechanism and applications in crop
improvement. In: Somaclonal variationa and Induced Mutations in Crop Improvement.
Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, Boston, London:16-37.
Bregitzer P, Halbert SE, Lemaux PG. (1998) Somaclonal variation in the progeny of
transgenic barley. Theor Appl Genet 96:421-425.
Breyne P, Rombaut D, Gysel A, Montagu M, Gerats T. (1999) AFLP analysis of genetic
diversity within and between Arabidopsis thaliana ecotypes. Mol Gen Genet 261:627-634.
Brown PTH, Lange FD, Kranz E, Lörz H. (1993) Analysis of single protoplasts and regenerated
plants by PCR and RAPD technology. Molecular General Gentics 237:311-317.
Cervera M. Ruiz-Garcia L, Martinez-Zapater J. (2002) Analysis of DNA methylation in
Arabidopsis thaliana based on methylation-sensitive AFLP markers. Molecular Genetics
and Genomics 268:DOI 10.1007/s00438-002-0772-4.
Chakrabarty D, Yu KW, Paek KY. (2003) Detection of DNA methylation changes during
somatic embryogenesis of Siberian ginseng (Eleuterococcus senticosus). Plant Science
165:61-68.
Chu C. (1978) The N6 medium and its applications to anther culture of cereal crops.
Proc. Symp. Plant Tissue Culture, Science Press Beijing:43-50.
Devaux P, Kilian A, Kleinhofs A. (1993) Anther culture and Hordeum bulbosum-derived
barley doubled haploids: mutations and methylation. Mol. Gen. Genet. 241:674-679.
Donini P, Elias ML, Bougourd SM, Koebner ROD. (1997) AFLP fingerprinting reveals pattern
differences between template DNA extracted from different plant organs. Genome 40:521-526.
Fourré J-L, Berger P, Niquet L, André P. (1997) Somatic embryogenesis and somaclonal
variation in Norway spruce: morphogenetic, cytogenetic and molecular approaches. Theor
Appl Genet 94:159-169.
Freyssinet M, Freyssinet G. (1988) Fertil plant regeneration from sunflower (Heliantus
annuus L.) immature embryos. Plant Sci. 56:177-181.
Gaj MD. (2001) Direct somatic embryogenesis as a rapid and efficient system for in
vitro regeneration of Arabidopsis thaliana. Plant Cell Tiss Org 64:39-46.
Gray DJ, Compton ME, Harrell RC, Contliffe DJ. (1995) Somatic embryogenesis and the
technology of synthetic seed. In: Biotechnology in Agriculture and Forestry. Somatic
Embryogenesis and synthetic seed I. Springer, Berlin 30:126-151.
Guzy-Wróblewska J, Szarejko I. (2003) Molecular and agronomic evaluation of wheat
double haploid lines obtained through maize pollination and anther methods. Plant
Breeding 122:305-313.
Habu Y, Kakutani, T. and Paszkowski, J. (2001) Epigenetic developmental mechanisms
in plants: Molecules and targets of plant epigenetic regulation. Curr. Opin. Genet.
Dev. 11:215-220.
Hossain MA, Konisho K, Minami M, Nemoto K. (2003) Somaclonal variation of regenerated
plants in chili pepper (Capsicum annuum L.). Euphytica 130:233-239.
Jacobsen SE, Sakai, H., Finnegan, E. J., Cao, X. and Meyerowitz, E. M. (2000) Ectopic
hypermethylation of flower-specific genes in Arabidopsis. Curr. Biol. 10:179-186.
Jaligot E, Beulé T, Rival A. (2002) Methylation-sensitive RFLPs: characterisation
of two oil palm markers showing somaclonal variation-associated polymorphism. Theor
Appl Genet 104:1263 - 1269.
Jaligot E, Rival A, Beulé T, Dussert S, Verdeil J-L. (2000) Somaclonal variation in
oil palm (Elaeis guineensis Jacq.): the DNA methylation hypothesis. Plant Cell Reports
19:684 - 690.
Kakutani T, Munakata, K., Richards, E. J. and Hirochika, H. (1999) Meiotically and
mitotically stable inheritance of DNA hypomethylation induced by ddm1 mutation of
Arabidopsis thaliana. Genetics 151:831-838.
Kudirka DT, Schaeffer GW, Beanzinger PS. (1989) Stability of ploidy in meristems of
plants regenerated from anther calli of wheat (Triticum aestivum L. em. Thell.). Genome
32:1068-1073.
Larkin PJ, Scowcroft WR. (1981) Somaclonal variation - a novel source of variability
from cell cultures for plant improvement. Theor Appl Genet 60:197-214.
Linacero R, Freitas AE, Vázquez AM. (2000) Hot spots of DNA instability revealed through
the study of somaclonal variation in rye. Theor Appl Genet 100:506-511.
Munthali MT, Newbury HJ, Ford-Lloyd BV. (1996) The detection of somaclonal variants
of beet using RAPD. Plant Cell Reports 15:474 - 478.
Oleszczuk S, Sowa S, Zimny J. (2005) Androgenic response to pre-culture stress in
the microspore cultures of barley. Protoplasma in press
Pauk J, Manninen O, Mattila I, Salo Y, Pulli S. (1991) Androgenesis in hexaploid spring
wheat F2 populations and their parents using a multiple-step regeneration system.
Plant Breeding 107:18-27.
Peakall R, Smouse PE. (2001) GenALEx V5: Genetic Analysis in Excel. Population genetic
software for teaching and research. Australian National University, Canberra. http://www.anu.edu.au/BoZo/GenAIEx/
Peraza-Echeverria S, Herrera-Valencia VA, James-Kay A. (2001) Detection of DNA methylation
changes in micropropagated banana plants using methylation-sensitive amplification
polymorphism (MSAP). Plant Science 161:359-367.
Peshke VM, Phillips RL. (1991) Activation of the maize transposable element Suppreassor-mutator
(Spm) in tissue culture. Theor Appl Genet 81:90-97.
Portis E, Acquadro A, Comino C, Lanteri S. (2003) Analysis of DNA methylation during
germination of pepper (Capsicum annuum L.) seeds using methylation-sensitive amplification
polymorphism (MSAP). Plant Science 166:169-178.
Remotti PC. (1998) Somaclonal variation and in vitro selection for crop improvement.
In: Somaclonal Variation and Induced Mutations in Crop Improvement. Eds. Jain, S.M.,
Brar, D.S., Ahloowalia, B.S.:169-201.
Reyna-López GE, Simpson J, Ruiz-Herrera J. (1997) Differences in DNA methylation patterns
are detectable during the dimorphic transition of fungi by amplification of restriction
polymorphisms. Mol Gen Genet 253:703-710.
Roseland CS, Espinasse A, Grosz TJ. (1991) Somaclonal variats of sunflower with modified
coumarin expressionunder stress. Euphitica 54
Saiotu N, Nei M. (1986) The number of nucleotides required to determine the branching
order of three species, with special reference to human - Chimpanzee-Gorilla divergence.
J. Mol. Evaluation 24:189-204.
Thomas E, Bright SWJ, Franklin J, Lancaster V, Miflin BJ. (1982) Variation amongst
protoplast-derived potato plants (Solanum tuberosum cv, "Maris Bar"). Theor Appl Genet
62:65-68.
Vendrame WA, Kochert G, Wetzstein HY. (1999) AFLP analysis of variation in pecan somatic
embryos. Plant Cell Reports 18:853-857.
Vos P, Hogers R, Bleeker M, Lee T, Hornes M, Frijters A, Pot J, Peleman J, Kuiper
M, Zauber M. (1995) AFLP: a new technique for DNA fingerprinting. Nucl Acids Res 23:4407-4414.
Wang ZY, Nagel J, Potrykus I, Spangenberg G. (1993) Plants from cell suspension-derived
protoplasts in Lolium species. Plant Sci 94:179-193.
Xiong LZ, Xu CG, Saghai Maroof MA, Zhang Q. (1999) Patterns of cytosine methylation
in an elite rice hybrid and its parental lines, detected by a methylation-sensitive
amplification polymorphism technique. Mol Gen Genet 261:439-446.
Zhuang JJ, Xu J. (1983) Increasing differentiation frequencies in wheat pollen calus.
In: Cell and Tissue Culture Techniques for Cereal Crop Improvement (Hu, H. and Vega,
M.R. Eds). Science Press Beijing 431
Zimny J, Lörz H. (1989) High frequency of somatic embryogenesis and plant regeneration
of rye (Secale cereale L.). Z. Pflanzenzüchtung 102:89 100.
1. Use of the AFLP technique which is composed of the stages: isolation of genomic DNA,
digestion of the genomic DNA with one pair of restriction endonucleases and digestion
of another portion of the same DNA with another pair of restriction endonucleases,
annealing of synthetic heteroduplexes to the free restriction ends, initial amplification
of fragments obtained in such a manner by way of primary PCR, selective amplification,
separation of the PCR products in a polyacrylamide gel, visual profile analysis for
the method for the identification of variability induced by the derivation method
in
in vitro cultures at the level of regenerant plants, as well as variation inherited as a result
of generative propagation consisting of the following stages:
1) estimation of the repeatability of the two AFLP technique variants: repeatability
control of A FLP based on the identity of several DNA samples of the same plant through
the use of AFLP and isoschizomers both sensitive and insensitive to methylation at
the restriction-site and/or adjacent areas as well as a representative number of pairs
of selective primers identical in all AFLP analyses;
2) estimation of the repeatability of the two AFLP technique variants: repeatability
control of AFLP based on the identity of several DNA samples of the same plant through
the use of AFLP and isoschizomers both sensitive and insensitive to methylation at
the restriction-site and/or adjacent areas as well as a representative number of pairs
of selective primers using a different set of selective AFLP primers than those used
in the other AFLP analyses;
3) identification of variability induced by the method of derivation of the regenerants
in relation to the donor plant is performed in two AFLP variants using isoschizomers
both sensitive and insensitive to methylation at the restriction-site and/or adjacent
areas as well as a representative number of pairs of selective primers identical in
all AFLP analyses;
4) the identification of the tissue culture induced variability among regenerants
in relation to the donor plant is performed in two AFLP technique variants utilising
isoschizomers both sensitive and insensitive to methylation at the restriction-site
and/or adjacent areas as well as a representative number of pairs of selective primers
identical in all AFLP analyses;
5) the identification of somaclonal variability among regenerant progeny in relation
to the donor plant is carried out using two AFLP technique variants utilising isoschizomers
both sensitive and insensitive to methylation at the restriction-site and/or adjacent
areas as well as a representative number of pairs of selective primers identical in
all AFLP analyses;
6) the molecular analysis of the experimental material using the AFLP technique taking
into account isoschizomers both sensitive and insensitive to methylation at the restriction-site
and/or adjacent areas as well as a representative number of pairs of selective primers
identical in all AFLP analyses is comprised of the following stages:
a) analyses of AFLP patterns of donor plants with respect to genetic and epigenetic
variability induced during the generative propagation of an individual plant, a control
of generative propagation,
b) analyses of AFLP patterns for the control of the reproducibility of both AFLP technique
variants,
c) analysis of AFLP patterns for regenerants in comparison to donor plants or separate
regenerants in relation to appropriate donor plants;
d) danalyses of AFLP patterns for donor plant, its regenerant and regenerant progeny,
or distinct regenerant progeny lines along with appropriate donor and its regenerant
plants;
7) identification of the 14 types of events recognized at the binary matrix level
for systems sensitive and insensitive to methylation, which are the result of a comparison
between the donor plant with regenerants and between donor plant with regenerant progeny
simultaneously in two AFLP systems, wherein the identification of event types is carried
out individually for each regenerant and as bulk for regenerant progenies and is represented
as 14 binary matrices which describe each of the events independently, subdivided
into methods of derivation; wherein the columns represent consecutive regenerants
or bulks and rows represent consecutive AFLP fragments;
8) assignment of certain event types to a given type of variability induced the method
of derivation in relation to each regenerant;
9) identification of the 14 types of events recognized at the binary matrix level
for systems sensitive and insensitive to methylation, which are the result of a comparison
between the donor plant with regenerant simultaneously in two AFLP systems;
10) identification of the 14 types of events recognized at the binary matrix level
for systems sensitive and insensitive to methylation, which are the result of a comparison
between the donor plant with regenerant progeny simultaneously in two AFLP systems,
where the identification of event types is performed through the summation of the
genotypes of a given summary progeny, and through the comparison of such a total AFLP
profile of regenerant progeny with the donor plant profile,
11) the bulk regenerant progeny genotype expressed via an AFLP profile for systems
sensitive and insensitive to methylation at the level of individual AFLP fragments
has a different value from that of the donor plant in a given AFLP system, so long
as a given fragment within it is polymorphic, or is totally different from this value
for the donor plant; in the opposite case the values for the donor plant and bulk
regenerant progeny for a given AFLP fragment in a given AFLP system are identical,
12) production of a quantitative matrix for regenerants, where the columns contain
data for consecutive regenerants grouped by the method of derivation, and the rows
contain the 14 types of events which may be assigned to each regenerant progeny;
13) production of a quantitative matrix for regenerant progeny, where the columns
contain bulk data for regenerant progeny grouped by the method of derivation, and
the rows contain the 14 types of events which may be assigned to each bulk regenerant
progeny;
14) production of a quantitative matrix for events in regenerants, where this is a
quantitative matrix for post-transposition regenerants, where the columns contain
14 events and the rows contain regenerants grouped by the method of derivation;
15) calculation of the total number of events based on the binary matrix for individual
methods of derivation of regenerants as well as for regenerants, where the total number
of events is calculated as a product of the number of AFLP fragments identified in
both AFLP systems for all pairs of selective primers multiplied by the number of regenerants
derived by a given method;
16) calculation of the total number of events based on the binary matrix for individual
methods of derivation of regenerants as well as for regenerant progenies in bulk,
where the total number of events corresponds to the number of DNA fragments identical
or different in both AFLP systems for all pairs of selective primers used in the analysis;
17) calculation of the error stemming from generative propagation is carried out based
on the binary matrix of donor plants and a single plant; determination of the number
of events different from those in a single plant belonging to the donor plants, and
the calculation of the total number of events for the donor plants;
18) calculation of the error stemming from the AFLP technique is carried out based
on the binary matrix for DNA samples obtained from the same plant and subjected to
the stages of the AFLP technique using isoschizomers sensitive and insensitive to
methylation at the restriction site or its immediate surroundings as well as a representative
number of selective starter pairs identical in all AFLP systems, where the total number
of events and the number of polymorphic events are calculated, and the latter number
is expressed as a percentage;
19) determination, based on binary matrices for regenerants and the donor plant, of
groups of events describing: (a) sequence variation connected with any changes in
DNA nucleotide sequences based on AFLP data from the system insensitive to methylation
and (b) epigenetic variability, the de novo variability of methylation patterns, and additionally mixed variation which is sequence
and methylation variability based on data for both AFLP systems;
20) determination, based on binary matrices for bulk regenerant progeny and the donor
plant, of event groups describing (a) sequence variation comiected with all DNA nucleotide
changes based on AFLP data from the system insensitive to methylation and (b) epigenetic
variability, the de novo variability of methylation patterns, and additionally mixed variation which is sequence
and methylation variability, and (c) inheritance of methylation patterns as related
to the presence and/or lack of methylation at the restriction site or its vicinity,
based on data for both AFLP systems;
21) identification of events particularly subject to the activity of factors inducing
variability in in vitro cultures;
22) sequence analysis of individual event types and/or broad sequence variability,
where variability is identified using AFLP technique variants using primers directed
against conservative sequences within mobile elements, repeating sequences or the
sequences of conservative gene families;
23) statistical analysis of the donor plant and its regenerants as well as regenerant
progeny, and possibly distinct regenerants and regenerant progenies along with appropriate
donor plants, as well as AFLP reproducibility control and generative propagation control:
a) statistical analysis of the results of AFLP using parametric analysis, Mantel's
test and/or Cronbach's alpha coefficient as well as molecular variance analysis using
the Fs, or Phis, coefficients;
b) determination of the error of the tissue culture induced and somaclonal variability
estimates, based on the Mantel test correlation coefficient;
c) determination of the quantitative parameters of variability induced by the method
of derivation of regenerants and somaclonal variability for regenerants, individual
regenerant progenies, talcing into account the method of derivation and giving their
statistical significance level;
d) statistic determination of differences between individual types of events induced
in in vitro cultures for regenerants, as well as bulk regenerant progeny, grouped by method of
derivation and supplemented by their statistical significance using quantitative matrices
of events;
e) statistical analysis of the comparison between variability induced by the method
of derivation as well as somaclonal variation, determined through the comparison of
the donor plant profile, and the bulk profile of regenerant progeny and their types:
sequence variability and/or broad sequence variability, de novo methylation, demethylation, mixed variability, inheritance of: methylation patterns,
non-methylated sites or conservative sites in regenerant progeny, grouped by method
of derivation as well as a comparison by method of derivation of regenerant progeny,
where quantitative matrices are used for events;
f) statistical comparisons of regenerants, and the bulk regenerant progenies for different
methods of derivation for a given regenerant progeny, where quantitative matrices
of the progeny are used;
g) statistical comparison of the results of the above mentioned points for individual
regenerants and bulk regenerant progenies amongst one another;
h) statistical or qualitative comparison of somaclonal variation between individual
plants being the generative progeny of regenerants;
i) collation of the existing results in the form of a compilation indicating quantitative
characteristics of variability induced by the method of derivation determined at the
regenerant level, as well as quantitative characteristics of inherited variability
determined at the level of regenerant progeny.
2. Use according to Claim I, wherein the identification of the 14 types of events recognized
at the level of binary matrix is selected from among the events represented in Fig.
7.
3. Use according to Claim 1, wherein to derive donor plants, a single plant is used which
is a doubled haploid derived from an isolated microspore, wherein it is treated as
a control of the genetic and epigenetic variability of donor plants.
4. Use according to Claim 1, wherein genetic and epigenetic variability of generatively
propagated material, donor plants, is determined based on AFLP profiles obtained from
restriction endonuclease isoschizomers recognizing and digesting identical sequences,
but differing in their sensitivity to methylation at or about the restriction site,
wherein one of the isoschizomers is insensitive to methylation.
5. Use according to Claim I, wherein in a system sensitive and insensitive to methylation
no differences are observed in the AFLP profiles of donor plants, then the level of
variability induced through generative propagation and identified with a given pair
of selective primers is insignificant.
6. Use according to Claim I, wherein when there are differences in AFLP profiles for
donor plants between a system sensitive and a system insensitive to methylation, a
percentage portion of such an event is determined, along with the background level,
generative propagation error.
7. Use according to Claim 1, wherein when there are differences in AFLP profiles for
experimental replicants on the same DNA samples, the AFLP technique error is estimated
in order to determine experimental error.
8. Use according to Claim 1, wherein the integral portion of the research material is
composed of donor plants, along with a single plant, donor plant regenerants and separate
regenerant progenies.
9. Use according to Claim I, wherein the donor plant along with regenerants and regenerant
progeny compose the core of research material for the study of variability induced
by the method of derivation or somaclonal variability, respectively.
10. Use according to Claim I, wherein the molecular analysis is performed using the AFLP
technique in two variants, using isoschizomers differing in their sensitivity to methylation.
11. Use according to Claim I, wherein one of the isoschizomers is completely insensitive
to methylation.
12. Use according to Claim 1, wherein in the identification of segregated PCR products,
and isotope marker is used which is introduced to the 5' end of the primer complementary
to the adaptor annealed to the restriction site freed by the isoschizomers.
13. Use according to Claim 1, wherein other methods of visualising AFLP fragments are
used, including fluorescence.
14. Use according to Claim 1, wherein the profiles of both AFLP variants for the donor
plant along with its regenerants and taking into account the method of derivation
and AFLP reproducibility control are performed on identical AFLP primer pairs.
15. Use according to Claim 1, wherein AFLP profile analysis and their conversion to binary
matrices is based on the fact that the AFLP profiles of both restrictase systems for
all pairs of selective primers are entered as a binary matrix into a spreadsheet,
where the data set obtained for one pair of selective AFLP primers is placed below
the previous one such that each column represents a total binary profile for a donor
plant in one AFLP system, and the subsequent columns contain analogous data for regenerants
and controls, wherein data for the second AFLP system is recorded in subsequent columns,
wherein the bands from one system are ordered like those from the previous system
(in rows), and where a given band does not appear a zero is entered in the appropriate
row of the spreadsheet.
16. Use according to Claim 1, wherein AFLP profile analysis and their conversion to binary
matrices is based on the fact that the AFLP profiles of both restrictase systems for
all pairs of selective primers are entered as a binary matrix into a spreadsheet,
where the data set obtained for one pair of selective AFLP primers is placed below
the previous one such that each column represents a total binary profile for a donor
plant in one AFLP system, and the subsequent columns contain analogous data for regenerant
progenies and controls, wherein data for the second AFLP system is recorded in subsequent
columns, wherein the bands from one system are ordered like those from the previous
system (in rows), and where a given band does not appear a zero is entered in the
appropriate row of the spreadsheet.
17. Use according to Claim 1, wherein the AFLP profile for regenerant progeny is represented
in the form of a bulk genotype per AFLP variant, sensitive and insensitive to methylation
separately.
18. Use according to Claim 1, wherein the generative propagation control is carried out
through the summation of the number of signals (events) from a single plant, where
the number of changes is calculated as a percentage of the total number of events.
19. Use according to Claim 1, wherein the parametric analysis, Mantel's test correlation
analysis and molecular variability analysis are performed using binary matrices of
AFLP systems sensitive and insensitive to methylation for regenerants and/or regenerant
progeny depending on whether the variability induced in culture or inherited by regenerant
progeny are being analyzed.
20. Use according to Claim 1, wherein the factorial analysis is used as the graphical
representation of the AFLP results.
21. Use according to Claim 1, wherein the identification of the 14 types of events recognized
at the level of AFLP pattern and assigned to variability induced by the method of
derivation is performed on the basis of AFLP patterns, wherein the donor plant profile
is used along with regenerant profiles in both systems, and subsequently the profile
of each regenerant is compared to the donor plant profile in order to identify these
events.
22. Use according to Claim 1, wherein the identification of the 14 types of events recognized
at the level of AFLP patterns and assigned to somaclonal variability is carried out
on the basis of AFLP patterns, where the donor plant profile is used along with profiles
in both AFLP systems, and the bulk profile of regenerant progeny is compared to the
donor plant profile in order to identify event types, wherein it is assumed that in
case of polymorphic AFLP fragments of the bulk regenerant progeny genotype, a value
different than that of the donor plant is entered or a different value if it is different
from that of the donor plant in all regenerant progenies for a given AFLP system.
23. Use according to Claim 1, wherein when the 14 event types comprise the basis for their
segregation into groups: sequence variability, methylation variability (methylation
and demethylation), mixed variability and inheritance of methylation patterns, wherein
it is taken into account that sequence variability is unequivocally confirmed in a
system insensitive to methylation.
24. Use according to Claim 1, wherein the analysis of the significance of individual variability
types and events within regenerants and regenerant progeny plants, as grouped by the
method of derivation, is performed based on qualitative matrices and quantitative
matrices of events describing all theoretically possible events, as well as regenerant
plants and regenerant progeny.
25. Use according to Claim I, wherein the statistical analysis results for individual
regenerants and bulk regenerant progenies obtained through various means are compiled
into a whole; quantitative parameters are entered for variability induced by the method
of derivation and of somaclonal variability for individual regenerants and bulk regenerant
progenies as well as for separate regenerant progenies grouped by the method of derivation
and event types along with statistical parameters.
26. Use according to Claim 1, wherein those event types are identified, which are rare
in culture or which do not occur at all, as well as those which are particularly subject
to the activity of factors inducing variability at the level of regenerant and regenerant
progeny, as well as to determine their quantitative parameters.
27. Use according to Claim I, wherein individual event types are studied at the molecular
level through the sequence analysis of AFLP fragments representing individual types
of events, and by the same token types of somaclonal variability.
28. Use according to Claim 1, wherein one or more bulk regenerant progeny is analyzed.
29. Use according to Claim I, wherein the quantitative characteristics of an event are
given for each individual regenerant progeny: sequence variability, broad sequence
variability, epigenetic variability of methylation patterns (de novo methylation, demethylation), stability of inherited methylated and non-methylated
sites (conservative), against changes induced in cultures as well as entering quantitative
differences in variability between different derivation methods of plant material.
30. Use according to Claim 1, wherein statistical analysis is performed of the significance
of individual event types among the regenerants, bulk regenerant progeny and individual
regenerant progenies as needed, grouped by the method of derivation of the research
material.
31. Use according to Claim I, wherein the somaclonal variability level of individual plants
which are regenerant progeny is determined independenly, using the principles used
for somaclonal variability.
32. Use according to Claim 1, wherein the hypotheses relating to the sources of variability
induced by the method of derivation of regenerants and that inherited as a result
of generative propagation are tested.
33. Use according to Claim 1, wherein the detailed analysis is performed of the causes
of sequence variability after introducing minor AFLP procedural changes, based on
the selective amplification of research material using a tagged primer complementary
to conservative sites of transposable elements, or to macrosatellite sequences.
34. Use according to Claim I, wherein the segregation of genetic and epigenetic markers
are analyzed for mapping populations derived through plant-plant crosses which are
the progeny of regenerants with a known genotype, based on AFLP profiles for both
AFLP systems.
35. Use according to Claim 1, wherein the method is designed for deriving plants in vitro with a lowered or enhanced level of somaclonal variability through the identification
of the causes of this variability.
36. Use according to Claim I, wherein the genetic and epigenetic purity of arbitrary material
derived through in vitro culture is verified.
37. Use according to Claim 1, wherein when the method is used in the analysis of the inheritance
of epigenetic variability during sexual crossing.
38. Use according to Claim 1, wherein the method is a tool for the identification of epigenetic
markers linked with the utilitarian characteristics of the plant material.
39. Use according to Claim 1, wherein the method is used for the identification of differences
in DNA methylation patterns for various tissues of an individual plant.
1. Verwendung von der AFLP Technik, die die Etappen umfasst: die Isolation von genomischer
DNA, Verdauen von genomischer DNA mit einem Paar von Restriktionsendonukleasen und
Verdauen einer anderen Portion von der selben genomischen DNA mit einem anderen Paar
von Restriktionsendonukleasen, Annealing von synthetischen Heteroduplexen zu den freien
Restriktionsenden, Anfangsamplifikation von den Fragmenten derart durch primäre PCR
erhaltene, selektive Amplifikation, Trennung der PCR-Produkte in einem Polyacrylamidgel,
visuelles Profil-Analyse für das Verfahren zur Identifizierung von Variabilität durch
die Ableitung Verfahren in
in vitro Kulturen auf der Ebene der Regeneranten-Pflanzen induziert, sowie Variation infolge
generatives Vermehrungsmaterial, bestehend aus den folgenden Schritten vererbt:
1) Schätzung der Wiederholbarkeit der beiden AFLP Technik Varianten: Wiederholbarkeit
Kontrolle von AFLP in Anlehnung an der Identität von mehreren DNA-Proben der gleichen
Pflanze durch die Verwendung von AFLP und Isoschizomere sowohl empfindlich und unempfindlich
gegen Methylierung an der Restriktionsstellen und/oder angrenzenden Bereichen sowie
einer repräsentativen Anzahl von Paaren von selektiven Primern identisch in allen
AFLP Analysen;
2) Schätzung der Wiederholbarkeit der beiden AFLP Technik Varianten: Wiederholbarkeit
Kontrolle von AFLP in Anlehnung an der Identität von mehreren DNA-Proben der gleichen
Pflanze durch die Verwendung von AFLP und Isoschizomere sowohl empfindlich und unempfindlich
gegen Methylierung an der Restriktionsstellen und/oder angrenzenden Bereichen sowie
einer repräsentativen Anzahl von Paaren von selektiven Primern mit Verwendung eines
anderen Satzes von selektiven AFLP-Primer als die in den anderen AFLP Analysen verwendeten;
3) Identifizierung der Variabilität durch das Verfahren der Ableitung der Regeneranten
in Bezug auf der Donorpflanze induziert, wird in zwei Varianten von AFLP mit Isoschizomere
sowohl empfindlich und unempfindlich gegen Methylierung an den Restriktionsstellen
und/oder angrenzenden Bereichen sowie eine repräsentative Anzahl von Paaren der selektiven
Primern identisch in allen AFLP Analysen durchgeführt;
4) die Identifizierung der Gewebekultur induziert Variabilität unter Regeneranten
in Bezug auf der Donorpflanze ist in zwei Varianten der AFLP-Technik unter Verwendung
der Isoschizomeren sowohl empfindlich und unempfindlich gegen Methylierung an der
Restriktionsstellen und/oder angrenzenden Bereichen sowie einer repräsentativen Anzahl
von Paaren selektive Primer identisch in allen AFLP Analysen durchgeführt;
5) die Identifizierung von der somaklonalen Variabilität unter Regeneranten Nachkommenschaft
in Bezug auf dem Donorpflanze in zwei Varianten AFLP-Technik unter Verwendung der
Isoschizomeren sowohl empfindlich und unempfindlich gegen Methylierung an der Restriktionsstellen
und/oder angrenzenden Bereichen sowie einer repräsentativen Anzahl von Paaren selektiv
Primer identisch in allen AFLP Analysen durchgeführt;
6) die molekulare Analyse der experimentellen Material mit der AFLP-Technik unter
Berücksichtigung der Isoschizomeren sowohl empfindlich und unempfindlich gegen Methylierung
an der Restriktionsstellen und/oder angrenzenden Bereichen sowie einer repräsentativen
Anzahl von Paaren von selektiven Primer identisch in allen AFLP Analysen setzt sich
zusammen aus den folgenden Schritten:
a) Analysen der AFLP-Mustern von der Donorpflanzen in Bezug auf genetische und epigenetische
Variabilität während der generativen Vermehrung eines einzelnen Pflanze induziert,
eine Kontrolle der generativen Vermehrung,
b) Analyse der AFLP-Mustern für die Steuerung der Reproduzierbarkeit der beiden AFLP-Technik
Varianten,
c) Analyse der AFLP-Mustern für den Regenenanten im Vergleich zur Donorpflanzen oder
getrennte Regeneranten in Bezug auf der geeigneten Donorpflanzen;
d) Analyse der AFLP-Mustern für die Donorpflanze, ihre Regenenant und Nachkommen von
Regeneranten oder unterschiedliche Nachkommen von Regenerierungslinien zusammen mit
den entsprechenden Donor und seiner Regenerierungspflanzen;
7) Identifizierung der 14 Arten von Ereignissen in der binären Matrix Ebene für Systeme
empfindlich und unempfindlich gegen Methylierung, die das Ergebnis eines Vergleichs
zwischen der Donorpflanze mit Regenenranten und zwischen der Donorpflanze mit Nachkommen
von Regeneranten gleichzeitig in zwei AFLP Systeme erkannt wird, wobei die Identifizierung
von Ereignistypen wird individuell für jeden Regenenranten und als Masse den Nachkommen
von Regeneranten durchgeführt und wird als 14 Binärmatrizen die jedes der Ereignisse
unabhängig beschreiben dargestellt, unterteilt in Methoden der Ableitung, wobei stellen
die Spalten die folgenden Regeneranten oder Massen und Zeilen die folgenden AFLP-Fragmente
dar;
8) Zuordnung bestimmter Ereignistypen zu einer bestimmten Art von Variabilität induziert
das Verfahren der Ableitung in Bezug auf jede Regenerant;
9) Identifizierung der 14 Arten von Ereignissen in der binären Matrix Ebene für Systeme
empfindlich und unempfindlich gegen Methylierung, die das Ergebnis eines Vergleichs
zwischen der Donorpflanze mit Regeneranten gleichzeitig in zwei Systemen AFLP erkannt
werden;
10) Identifizierung der 14 Arten von Ereignissen in der binären Matrix Ebene für Systeme
empfindlich und unempfindlich gegen Methylierung, die das Ergebnis eines Vergleichs
zwischen der Donorpflanze mit Regeneranten Nachkommen gleichzeitig in zwei AFLP Systemen
sind, wobei die Identifizierung von Ereignistypen durch die Summe der Genotypen einer
bestimmten Nachkommenzusammenfassung, und durch den Vergleich eines solchen gesamten
AFLP Profils von Regeneranten-Nachkommen mit dem Donorpflanzen-Profil durchgeführt
wird,
11) die Masse von Regeneranten-Nachkommen Genotyp über ein AFLP Profil von Systemen
empfindlich und unempfindlich gegen Methylierung auf der Ebene der einzelnen AFLP-Fragmente
exprimiert, hat einen anderen Wert als diese von der Donorpflanze in einer bestimmten
AFLP-System, solange innerhalb einer bestimmten Fragment ist polymorphen oder ist
völlig verschieden von diesem Wert für die Donorpflanze, im umgekehrten Fall sind
die Werte für die Donorpflanze und Massen-Regeneranten Nachkommen für eine gegebene
AFLP Fragment in einem gegebenen System AFLP identisch,
12) Herstellung einer Matrix für die quantitative Regeneranten, wobei die Spalten
enthalten die Daten für aufeinanderfolgende Regeneranten durch das Verfahren der Ableitung
gruppiert, und die Zeilen enthalten die 14 Arten von Ereignissen, die zu jedem Regeneranten-Nachkommen
zugewiesen werden kann;
13) Herstellung einer Matrix für die quantitative Regeneranten-Nachkommen, wobei die
Spalten enthalten der Datenblock Regeneranten-Nachkommen durch das Verfahren der Ableitung
gruppiert, und die Zeilen enthalten die 14 Arten von Ereignissen, die zu jedem Massen-Regeneranten-Nachkommen
zugewiesen werden kann;
14) Herstellung einer quantitativen Matrix für Ereignisse in Regeneranten, wo das
ist eine quantitative Matrix für post-Umsetzung Regeneranten, wo die Spalten enthalten
14 Veranstaltungen und die Zeilen enthalten Regeneranten nach der Methode der Ableitung
gruppiert;
15) Berechnung der Gesamtzahl der Ereignisse basierend auf der binären Matrix einzelner
Methoden zur Ableitung von Regeneranten als auch für Regeneranten, wobei die Gesamtzahl
der Ereignisse berechnet als ein Produkt der Anzahl von AFLP-Fragmente identifiziert
in beiden AFLP-Systeme für alle Paare der selektiven Primersequenzen durch die Anzahl
der Regeneranten von einem bestimmten Verfahren abgeleitet multipliziert;
16) Berechnung der Gesamtzahl der Ereignisse basierend auf der binären Matrix einzelner
Methoden zur Ableitung von Regeneranten als auch für Regeneranten-Nachkommen in der
Masse, wobei die Gesamtzahl der Ereignisse entspricht der Anzahl von DNA-Fragmenten
gleich oder verschieden in beiden AFLP für alle Paare von selektiven Primer in der
Analyse verwendet;
17) Berechnung der Fehler, die aus generatives Vermehrungsmaterial resultieren, wird
auf der Grundlage der binären Matrix Donorpflanzen und einer einzigen Pflanze durchgeführt;
die Bestimmung der Anzahl von Ereignissen, die sich von denen in einer einzigen Pflanze
von der den Donorpflanzen unterscheiden, und die Berechnung der Gesamtzahl der Ereignissen
für die Donorpflanzen;
18) Berechnung der Fehler, die aus der AFLP-Technik resultieren, wird auf der Grundlage
der binären Matrix für DNA-Proben erhaltenen aus der gleichen Pflanze und ausgesetzten
der Stufen der AFLP-Technik unter Verwendung der Isoschizomeren empfindlich und unempfindlich
gegen Methylierung an der Restriktionsstelle oder seiner unmittelbaren Umgebung als
auch eine repräsentative Anzahl von selektiven Starter Paaren identisch in allen AFLP
Systemen durchgeführt, wobei die Gesamtzahl der Ereignisse und der Anzahl der polymorphen
Ereignisse berechnet werden, und diese Zahl wird als Prozentsatz ausgedrückt;
19) Bestimmung, basierend auf Binärmatrizen für Regeneranten und Donorpflanze, von
Gruppen von Ereignissen, die beschreiben: (a) Sequenzvariation verbundene mit allen
Änderungen in der DNA-Nukleotid-Sequenzen basierende auf AFLP Daten aus dem System
unempfindlich gegenüber Methylierung und (b) die epigenetische Variabilität, die Variabilität
der de novo Methylierungsmuster, und zusätzlich gemischte Variabilität, die ist Sequenz und Methylierung
Variabilität basierend auf AFLP Daten für beide Systeme ist;
20) Bestimmung, basierend auf Binärmatrizen für Massen-Regenerante-Nachkommen und
dem Donorpflanze, der Gruppen von Ereignissen beschreiben (a) Sequenzvariation verbunden
mit allen DNA-Nukleotid-Änderungen basierend auf AFLP Daten aus dem unempfindlichen
gegenüber Methylierung System und (b) epigenetische Variabilität, die de novo Variabilität der Methylierungsmustern und zusätzlich gemischte Variation der Sequenz
und Methylierung Variabilität, und (c) Vererbung von Methylierungsmustern in Verbindung
mit der Anwesenheit und/oder Mangel von Methylierung an der Restriktionsstelle oder
deren Umgebung, basierend auf Daten für beide AFLP Systemen;
21) Identifizierung von Ereignissen, besonders der Aktivität der Faktoren induzierenden
Variabilität in in vitro Kulturen unterworfen;
22) Sequenzanalyse der einzelnen Ereignistypen und/oder der breite Sequenzvariabilität,
wo Variabilität wird mit AFLP-Technik Varianten unter Verwendung von Primern gegen
konservativen Sequenzen innerhalb beweglichen Elemente gerichtete, sich wiederholenden
Sequenzen oder Sequenzen, die konservative Genfamilien identifiziert;
23) statistische Analyse der Donorpflanze und ihre Regeneranten sowie Regeneranten-Nachkommen
und möglicherweise unterschiedliche Regeneranten und Regeneranten-Nachkommen zusammen
mit den entsprechenden Donorpflanzen sowie AFLP Reproduzierbarkeit Kontrolle und die
Kontrolle der generativen Vermehrung:
a) statistische Analyse der Ergebnisse der AFLP unter Verwendung der parametrischen
Analyse, Mantel-Test und/oder Cronbachs Alpha-Koeffizient sowie molekularen Varianz-Analyse
mit dem Fs oder Phis Koeffizienten;
b) Bestimmung des Fehlers der induzierte Gewebekultur und somaklonale Variabilität
Schätzungen, basierend auf der Mantel-Test Korrelationskoeffizient;
c) Bestimmung der quantitativen Parametern der Variabilität induziert durch das Verfahren
der Ableitung von Regeneranten und somaklonale Variabilität von Regeneranten, von
einzelnen Regeneranten-Nachkommen, unter Berücksichtigung der Methode der Ableitung
und gebend ihre statistische Signifikanz Ebene;
d) Statistik Bestimmung der Unterschiede zwischen den einzelnen Ereignistypen induziert
in in vitro-Kulturen für Regeneranten, sowie Massen-Regeneranten Nachkommen, durch die
Methode der Ableitung gruppierten und ergänzt durch ihre statistische Signifikanz
anhand quantitativer Matrizen von Ereignissen;
e) statistische Analyse des Vergleichs zwischen Variabilität induziert durch das Verfahren
der Ableitung sowie somaklonale Variation bestimmte durch das Vergleich des Profils
der Donorpflanze, und des Profils der Masse von Regeneranten-Nachkommen und deren
Typen: Sequenzvariabilität und/oder breite Sequenzvariabilität, de novo Methylierung, Demethylierung, gemischte Variabilität, Vererbung von: Methylierungsmuster,
nicht-methylierte Stellen oder Stellen in konservativen Regeneranten-Nachkommen, gruppiert
durch die Methode der Ableitung sowie einem Vergleich mit der Methode der Ableitung
der Regeneranten-Nachkommen, wo die quantitative Matrizen für Ereignissen genutzt
werden;
f) statistische Vergleiche von Regeneranten und die Masse von Regeneranten-Nachkommen
für verschiedene Methoden der Ableitung für einen bestimmten Regenerante-Nachkommen,
wobei quantitative Matrizen der Nachkommen verwendet werden;
g) statistisches Vergleich der Ergebnisse der oben genannten Punkte für einzelnen
Regeneranten und Massen-Regeneranten Nachkommen untereinander;
h) statistischer oder qualitativer Vergleich der somaklonalen Variation zwischen einzelnen
Pflanzen als generative Nachkommen von Regeneranten;
i) Zusammenführen der vorliegenden Ergebnisse in Form einer Zusammenstellung anzeigt
quantitativen Eigenschaften von der Variabilität durch das Verfahren der Ableitung
am Regeneranten Ebene sowie quantitative Eigenschaften von geerbter Variabilität auf
der Ebene von Regeneranten-Nachkommen bestimmt induziert.
2. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei die Identifizierung der 14 Ereignistypen auf der
Ebene der binären Matrix erkannt, wird aus den Ereignissen in der Fig. 7 dargestellt
ausgewählt.
3. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei zum Ableiten der Donorpflanzen wird eine einzelne
Pflanze verwendet, der doppelte Haploiden aus einer isolierten Mikrosporen abgeleitet,
wobei es als Kontrolle der genetischen und epigenetischen Variabilität der Donorpflanzen
behandelt ist.
4. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei genetische und epigenetische Variabilität von generativ
vermehrtem Material, Donorpflanzen, basierend auf AFLP Profile erhaltene von Restriktionsendonuklease
Isoschizomere, die identischen Sequenzen erkennen und verdauen, aber die sich in ihrer
Empfindlichkeit gegenüber Methylierung an oder über der Restriktionsstelle unterscheiden
bestimmt wird, wobei eine der Isoschizomere unempfindlich gegenüber Methylierung ist.
5. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei in einem empfindlichen und unempfindlichen gegen
Methylierung System keine Unterschiede in den AFLP Profile der Donorpflanzen beobachtet
sind, ist dann die Variabilität Niveau induziert durch generative Vermehrung und identifiziert
mit einem gegebenen Paar der selektiven Primer unerheblich.
6. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei, wenn es die Unterschiede in AFLP Profile für Donorpflanzen
zwischen einem empfindlichen und unempfindlichen gegen Methylierung System gibt, wird
eine prozentuale Anteil eines solchen Ereignisses bestimmt wird, zusammen mit dem
Hintergrundniveau, generativem Vermehrungsmaterial Fehler.
7. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei, wenn es die Unterschiede in AFLP Profile für experimentelle
Replikanten auf dem gleichen DNA-Proben gibt, die AFLP-Technik Fehler geschätzt wird,
um experimentelle Fehler zu bestimmen.
8. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei das Integral des Forschungsmaterial aus der Donorpflanzen,
zusammen mit einer einzigen Pflanze, Donorpflanze Regeneranten und separater Regeneranten-Nachkommen
besteht.
9. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei die Donorpflanze mit Regeneranten und Regeneranten-Nachkommen
bilden den Kern der Forschung Material für die Untersuchung der Variabilität durch
das Verfahren der Ableitung oder somaklonale Variabilität induzierte.
10. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei die molekulare Analyse unter Verwendung der AFLP-Technik
in zwei Varianten durchgeführt wird, unter Verwendung der Isoschizomeren, die sich
in ihrer Empfindlichkeit gegenüber Methylierung unterscheiden.
11. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei einer der Isoschizomere völlig unempfindlich gegen
Methylierung ist.
12. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei bei der Identifizierung von getrennten PCR-Produkten,
und Isotopen-Markierung verwendet wird, die an das 5'-Ende des Primers komplementär
zu dem Adapter der befreiten durch die Isoschizomere Restriktionsstelle geglüht eingeführt
ist
13. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei andere Methoden der Visualisierung AFLP-Fragmente
verwendet werden, einschließlich der Fluoreszenz.
14. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei die Profile der beiden AFLP Varianten für die Donorpflanze
zusammen mit der Regeneranten und unter Berücksichtigung des Verfahrens der Ableitung
und AFLP Reproduzierbarkeit Kontrolle mit gleichen AFLP-Primer-Paaren durchgeführt
werden.
15. Verwendung nach Anspruch I, bei AFLP-Profil-Analyse und ihre Umwandlung in binäre
Matrizen auf der Tatsache basiert, dass die AFLP Profile beider Restriktasesystemen
für alle Paare von selektiven Primer als binäre Matrix in eine Tabellenkalkulation,
wo die Daten erhaltenen für ein Paar von selektiven AFLP-Primern unter dem vorherigen
gesetzt werden, so dass jede Spalte insgesamt binären Profil von einer Donorpflanze
in einem ALFP-System darstellt, und die nachfolgenden Spalten analoge Daten für Regeneranten
und Kontrollen enthalten, wobei die Daten für den zweiten AFLP-System in den folgenden
Spalten dargestellt werden, wobei die Bänder von einem System sind wie die aus dem
bisherigen System (in Reihen) angeordnet, und wenn eine bestimmte Band nicht erscheint,
wird eine Null in die entsprechende Zeile der Tabelle eingetragen.
16. Verwendung nach Anspruch I, bei AFLP-Profil-Analyse und ihre Umwandlung in binäre
Matrizen auf der Tatsache basiert, dass die AFLP Profile beider Restriktasesystemen
für alle Paare von selektiven Primer als binäre Matrix in eine Tabellenkalkulation,
wo die Daten erhaltenen für ein Paar von selektiven AFLP-Primern unter dem vorherigen
gesetzt werden, so dass jede Spalte insgesamt binären Profil von einer Donorpflanze
in einem ALFP-System darstellt, und die nachfolgenden Spalten analoge Daten für Regeneranten-Nachkommen
und Kontrollen enthalten, wobei die Daten für den zweiten AFLP-System in den folgenden
Spalten dargestellt werden, wobei die Bänder von einem System sind wie die aus dem
bisherigen System (in Reihen) angeordnet, und wenn eine bestimmte Band nicht erscheint,
wird eine Null in die entsprechende Zeile der Tabelle eingetragen.
17. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei das AFLP-Profil von Regeneranten-Nachkommen wird
in Form einer Bulk Genotyp pro AFLP Variante empfindlich und unempfindlich gegen Methylierung
getrennt dargestellt.
18. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei die Kontrolle fur die generative Vermehrung wird
durch die Summe der Anzahl der Signale (Ereignisse) von einer einzigen Pflanze durchgeführt,
wenn die Anzahl der Änderungen in Prozent der Gesamtzahl der Ereignisse berechnet
wird.
19. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei die parametrische Analyse Mantel-Test Korrelationsanalyse
und molekulare Variabilität Analyse unter Verwendung von Binärmatrizen von AFLP Systemen
empfindlich und unempfindlich gegen Methylierung für Regeneranten und/oder Regeneranten-Nachkommen
durchgeführt sind, je nachdem, ob die Variabilität induziert in Kultur oder vererbt
von Regeneranten-Nachkommen untersucht wird.
20. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei die faktorielle Analyse als graphische Darstellung
der AFLP Wirkung verwendet ist.
21. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei die Identifizierung der 14 Ereignistypen auf der
Ebene der AFLP-Muster erkannt und der Variabilität zugeordnet, die durch das Verfahren
der Ableitung induziert ist, wird auf der Grundlage der AFLP-Mustern durchgeführt,
wobei die Donorpflanze Profil zusammen mit Regeneranten-Profile in beiden Systemen
verwendet wird, und anschließend das Profil jedes Regeneranten dem Donorpflanze Profil
verglichen werden, um diese Ereignisse zu identifizieren.
22. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei die Identifizierung der 14 Arten von Ereignissen
auf der Ebene der AFLP Mustern erkannt und der somaklonalen Variabilität zugeordnet,
wird auf der Grundlage der AFLPMustern durchgeführt, wobei der Donorpflanzeprofil
verwendet wird mit Profilen von beiden AFLP-Systemen und die Masse Profil Regeneranten-Nachkommen
mit dem Donorpflanze Profil verglichen, um diese Ereignistypen zu identifizieren,
wobei angenommen wird, dass im Falle einer polymorphen AFLP-Fragmente des Massen-Regeneranten
Nachkommen Genotyp, ein anderer Wert als der des Donorpflanze eingegeben wird oder
ein anderer Wert, wenn es sich von der der Donorpflanze in allen Regeneranten-Nachkommen
für eine gegebene AFLP-System ist.
23. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei, wenn die 14 Ereignistypen die Grundlage für ihre
Trennung in Gruppen umfassen: Sequenzvariabilität, Methylierung Variabilität (Methylierung
und Demethylierung), gemischte Variabilität und Vererbung von Methylierungsmuster,
wobei berücksichtigt wird, dass Sequenzvariabilität unmissverständlich in einem System
unempfindlich gegenüber Methylierung bestätigt ist.
24. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei die Analyse zum Stellenwert der individuellen Variabilität
und Ereignissen innerhalb der Regeneranten und Regeneranten-Nachkommenpflanzen, nach
dem Verfahren der Ableitung gruppiert sind, basierend auf qualitative und quantitative
Matrizen und quantitativen Matrizen von Ereignissen durchgeführt, die alle theoretisch
möglichen Ereignissen, sowie Regeneranten-Pflanzen und Regeneranten-Nachkommen beschreiben.
25. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei die Ergebnisse der statistischen Analyse für individuelle
Regeneranten und Massen-Regeneranten-Nachkommen durch verschiedene Mittel erreichte,
sind zu einem Ganzen zusammengefasst; eingegeben sind quantitative Parameter für die
Variabilität durch das Verfahren der Ableitung induziert und somaklonaler Variabilität
für individuelle Regeneranten und Massen-Regeneranten-Nachkommen sowie für getrennte
Regeneranten Nachkommen nach der Methode der Ableitung und Ereignistypen zusammen
mit statistischen Parameter gruppiert.
26. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei diese Ereignistypen identifiziert sind, die selten
in Kultur oder die überhaupt nicht auftreten, als auch solche, die besonders anfällig
für die Aktivität der Faktoren induzierenden Variabilität auf der Ebene der Regeneranten
und Regeneranten-Nachkommen sind, sowie ihre quantitative Parameter zu bestimmen.
27. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei einzelne Ereignistypen auf der molekularen Ebene
durch die Sequenzanalyse von AFLP-Fragmente untersucht werden, die einzelne Ereignistypen,
und aus dem gleichen Grund Arten von somaklonale Variabilität representieren.
28. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei ein oder mehrere Massen-Regeneranten-Nachkommen
analysiert werden.
29. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei die quantitativen Eigenschaften eines Ereignisses
für jeden einzelnen Regeneranten-Nachkommen angegeben sind: Sequenzvariabilität, breite
Sequenzvariabilität, epigenetische Variabilität der Methylierungsmuster (de novo Methylierung, Demethylierung), Stabilität der vererbten methylierter und nicht-methylierter
Stellen (konservativ), gegen Änderungen in Kulturen sowie die Eingabe der quantitativen
Unterschiede in Variabilität zwischen verschiedenen Methoden der Ableitung des Pflanzenmaterials
induzierten.
30. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei die statistische Analyse der Bedeutung der einzelnen
Ereignistypen unter den Regeneranten, Massen- Regeneranten-Nachkommen und individuelle
Regeneranten Nachkommen durchgeführt wird, wie es benötigt wird, gruppierten nach
der Methode der Ableitung der Forschung Material.
31. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei die somaklonaler Variabilität Ebene der einzelnen
Pflanzen, die Regeneranten-Nachkommen wird unabhängig bestimmt, unter Verwendung der
Prinzipien für somaklonale Variabilität verwendet.
32. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei die Hypothesen zu den Quellen der Variabilität durch
das Verfahren der Ableitung Regeneranten induziert und die vererbte als Ergebnis der
generatives Vermehrungsmaterial getestet.
33. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei die detaillierte Analyse der Ursachen von Sequenzvariabilität
nach Einführung kleinere AFLP Verfahrensänderungen durchgeführt wird, basierend auf
der selektiven Amplifikation des Forschungsmaterials unter Verwendung eines markierten
Primers, die komplementär zu konservativen Seiten von Transposons oder Macrosatellitesequenzen
sind.
34. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei die Trennung von genetischen und epigenetischen
Marker für Mappingpopulationen durch Pflanz-Pflanz Kreuze abgeleitet ist, welche die
Nachkommen von Regeneranten mit einem bekannten Genotyp abgeleitet werden, basierend
auf der AFLP Profile für beide AFLP Systemen.
35. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei das Verfahren zum Ableiten von Pflanzen in vitro mit einem abgesenkten oder gestiegenen Niveau der somaklonalen Variabilität durch
die Identifizierung der Ursachen dieser Variabilität entwickelt ist.
36. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei die genetische und epigenetische Reinheit von beliebigem
Material durch in vitro Kultur abgeleitete untersucht wird.
37. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei, wenn das Verfahren in der Analyse der Vererbung
von epigenetischen Variabilität während der sexuellen Kreuzung verwendet wird.
38. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei das Verfahren ein Werkzeug zur Identifizierung von
epigenetischen Markierungen verknüpft mit den nützliche Eigenschaften des pflanzlichen
Materials ist.
39. Verwendung nach Anspruch 1, wobei das Verfahren zur Identifizierung von Unterschieden
in der DNA-Methylierungsmuster zu verschiedenen Geweben einer einzelnen Pflanze verwendet
wird.
1. Utilisation de la technique AFLP qui se compose des étapes: l'isolement de l'ADN génomique,
la digestion de l'ADN génomique par une paire d'endonucléases de restriction et la
digestion d'une autre partie du même ADN par une autre paire d'endonucléases de restriction,
l'assemblage de heteroduplexes synthétiques aux extrémités de restriction libres,
l'amplification initiale des fragments obtenus de telle manière au moyen de la PCR
primaire, l'amplification sélective, la séparation des produits de PCR dans un gel
de polyacrylamide, l'analyse visuelle du profil pour le procédé pour l'identification
de la variabilité induite par le procédé de dérivation dans les
cultures in vitro au niveau des plantes régénérantes, ainsi que la variation héritée à la suite de
la propagation générative comprenant les étapes suivantes:
1) estimation de la répétabilité de ces deux variantes de la technique AFLP: contrôle
de la reproductibilité des AFLP sur la base de l'identité de plusieurs échantillons
d'ADN de la même plante par l'utilisation d'AFLP et des isoschizomères à la fois sensibles
et insensibles à la méthylation au niveau du site de restriction et/ou les zones adjacentes
ainsi qu'un nombre représentatif de paires d'amorces sélectives identiques dans toutes
les analyses AFLP;
2) estimation de la répétabilité de ces deux variantes de la technique AFLP: contrôle
de la reproductibilité des AFLP sur la base de l'identité de plusieurs échantillons
d'ADN de la même plante par l'utilisation d'AFLP et des isoschizomères à la fois sensibles
et insensibles à la méthylation au niveau du site de restriction et/ou les zones adjacentes
ainsi qu'un nombre représentatif de paires d'amorces sélectives en utilisant un ensemble
différent d'amorces AFLP sélectifs que ceux utilisés dans les autres analyses AFLP;
3) identification de la variabilité induite par le procédé de dérivation des régénérants
par rapport à la plante donneuse est réalisée en deux variantes AFLP en utilisant
des isoschizomères à la fois sensibles et insensibles à la méthylation au niveau du
site de restriction et/ou les zones adjacentes ainsi qu'un nombre représentatif de
paires d'amorces sélectives identiques dans toutes les analyses AFLP;
4) l'identification de la variabilité induite par la culture de tissus parmi les régénérants
par rapport à la plante donneuse est réalisée en deux variantes de la technique AFLP
en utilisant des isoschizomères à la fois sensibles et insensibles à la méthylation
au niveau du site de restriction et/ou les zones adjacentes ainsi qu'un nombre représentatif
de paires d'amorces sélectives identiques dans toutes les analyses AFLP;
5) l'identification de la variabilité somaclonale parmi la progéniture de régénérant
par rapport à la plante donneuse est réalisée en utilisant deux variantes de la technique
AFLP en utilisant des isoschizomères à la fois sensibles et insensibles à la méthylation
au niveau du site de restriction et/ou les zones adjacentes ainsi qu'un nombre représentatif
de paires d'amorces sélectives identiques dans toutes les analyses AFLP;
6) l'analyse moléculaire du matériel expérimental en utilisant la technique AFLP en
tenant compte des isoschizomères à la fois sensibles et insensibles à la méthylation
au site de restriction et/ou les zones adjacentes ainsi qu'un nombre représentatif
de paires d'amorces sélectives identiques dans toutes les analyses AFLP est constituée
des étapes suivantes:
a) analyses des modèles AFLP de plantes donneuses par rapport à la variabilité génétique
et épigénétique induite lors de la propagation générative d'une plante individuelle,
un contrôle de la propagation générative,
b) analyses des modèles AFLP pour le contrôle de la reproductibilité de ces deux variantes
de la technique AFLP,
c) analyse des modèles AFLP pour les régénérants par comparaison aux plantes donneuses
ou les régénérants distincts par rapport aux plantes donneuses appropriées;
d) analyses des modèles AFLP pour une plante donneuse, son régénérant et la progéniture
de régénérant, ou des lignes distinctes de progéniture de régénérant ainsi qu'une
donatrice appropriée et ses plantes régénérantes;
7) identification des 14 types d'événements reconnus au niveau de la matrice binaire
pour des systèmes sensibles et insensibles à la méthylation, qui sont le résultat
d'une comparaison entre la plante donneuse avec les régénérants et entre la plante
donneuse avec la progéniture de régénérant simultanément dans deux systèmes AFLP,
dans laquelle l'identification des types d'événement est réalisée individuellement
pour chaque régénérant et volumiquement pour les progénitures de régénérant et est
représentée comme 14 matrices binaires qui décrivent chacun de ces événements de façon
indépendante, subdivisées en procédés de dérivation; dans lesquelles les colonnes
représentent les régénérants consécutifs ou les volumes et les lignes représentent
les fragments AFLP consécutifs;
8) attribution de certains types d'événement à un type donné de la variabilité induite
par le procédé de dérivation par rapport à chacun régénérant;
9) identification des 14 types d'événements reconnus au niveau de la matrice binaire
pour des systèmes sensibles et insensibles à la méthylation, qui sont le résultat
d'une comparaison entre la plante donneuse avec le régénérant simultanément dans deux
systèmes AFLP;
10) identification des 14 types d'événements reconnus au niveau de la matrice binaire
pour des systèmes sensibles et insensibles à la méthylation, qui sont le résultat
d'une comparaison entre la plante donneuse avec la progéniture de régénérant simultanément
dans deux systèmes AFLP, où l'identification des types d'événement est réalisée par
la sommation des génotypes d'une progéniture sommaire donnée, et par la comparaison
d'un tel profil AFLP total de la progéniture de régénérant avec le profil de la plante
donneuse,
11) le génotype volumique de la progéniture de régénérant exprimé par l'intermédiaire
d'un profil AFLP pour des systèmes sensibles et insensibles à la méthylation au niveau
des fragments individuels d'AFLP a une valeur différente de celle de la plante donneuse
dans un système d'AFLP donné, pour autant qu'un fragment donné en son sein est polymorphe,
ou est totalement différent de cette valeur pour la plante donneuse; dans le cas contraire
les valeurs pour la plante donneuse et la progéniture volumique de régénérant pour
un fragment donné d'AFLP dans un système donné d'AFLP sont identiques,
12)production d'une matrice quantitative pour les régénérants, où les colonnes contiennent
des données pour les régénérants consécutifs regroupés par le procédé de dérivation,
et les lignes contiennent les 14 types d'événements qui peuvent être attribués à chaque
progéniture de régénérant;
13)production d'une matrice quantitative pour la progéniture de régénérant, où les
colonnes contiennent des données volumiques pour la progéniture de régénérant regroupée
par le procédé de dérivation, et les lignes contiennent les 14 types d'événements
qui peuvent être attribués à chaque progéniture volumique de régénérant;
14)production d'une matrice quantitative pour les événements dans les régénérants,
où il s'agit d'une matrice quantitative pour les régénérants après transposition,
où les colonnes contiennent 14 événements et les lignes contiennent les régénérants
regroupés par le procédé de dérivation;
15)calcul du nombre total d'événements sur la base de la matrice binaire pour des
procédés individuels de dérivation des régénérants ainsi que pour les régénérants,
où le nombre total d'événements est calculé comme un produit du nombre de fragments
d'AFLP identifiés dans les deux systèmes d'AFLP pour toutes les paires d'amorces sélectives
multiplié par le nombre de régénérants dérivé par un procédé donné;
16)calcul du nombre total d'événements sur la base de la matrice binaire pour des
procédés individuels de dérivation des régénérants ainsi que pour les progénitures
volumiques de régénérant, où le nombre total d'événements correspond au nombre de
fragments d'ADN, identiques ou différents, dans les deux systèmes d'AFLP pour toutes
les paires d'amorces sélectives utilisées dans l'analyse;
17)calcul de l'erreur résultant de la propagation générative est réalisé sur la base
de la matrice binaire de plantes donneuses et une plante individuelle; détermination
du nombre d'événements différents de ceux d'une plante individuelle appartenant aux
plantes donneuses, et le calcul du nombre total d'événements pour les plantes donneuses;
18)calcul de l'erreur résultant de la technique AFLP est réalisé sur la base de la
matrice binaire pour les échantillons d'ADN obtenus à partir de la même plante et
soumis aux étapes de la technique AFLP en utilisant des isoschizomères sensibles et
insensibles à la méthylation au site de restriction ou ses environs immédiats ainsi
qu'un nombre représentatif de paires d'amorces sélectives identiques dans tous les
systèmes AFLP, où le nombre total d'événements et le nombre d'événements polymorphes
sont calculés, et le second nombre est exprimé sous forme de pourcentage;
19)détermination, basée sur des matrices binaires pour les régénérants et la plante
donneuse, des groupes d'événements décrivant: (a) variation de séquence liée à toute
modification dans les séquences de nucléotides de l'ADN à partir des données AFLP
du système insensible à la méthylation et (b) variabilité épigénétique, la variabilité
de novo des modèles de méthylation, et en outre la variation mixte qui est la variabilité
de séquence et de méthylation basée sur des données pour les deux systèmes AFLP;
20) détermination, basée sur des matrices binaires pour la progéniture volumiques
de régénérant et la plante donneuse, de groupes d'événements décrivant (a) variation
de séquence liée à toute modification dans les nucléotides de l'ADN à partir des données
du système insensible à la méthylation et (b) variabilité épigénétique, la variabilité
de novo des modèles de méthylation, et en outre la variation mixte qui est la variabilité
de séquence et de méthylation, et (c) héritage de modèles de méthylation comme lié
à la présence et/ou l'absence de méthylation au niveau du site de restriction ou de
son voisinage, basé sur des données pour les deux systèmes AFLP;
21) identification d'événements particulièrement soumises à l'activité des facteurs
induisant la variabilité dans les cultures in vitro;
22) analyse de séquence de types d'événements individuels et/ou grande variabilité
de séquence, où la variabilité est identifié en utilisant des variantes de la technique
AFLP en utilisant des amorces dirigées contre des séquences conservatrices au sein
des éléments mobiles, séquences répétitives ou les séquences de familles de gènes
conservateurs;
23) analyse statistique de la plante donneuse et ses régénérants ainsi que la progéniture
de régénérant, et éventuellement les régénérants distincts et les progénitures de
régénérant ainsi que les plantes donneuses appropriées, aussi bien que le contrôle
de la reproductibilité AFLP et le contrôle de la propagation générative:
a) analyse statistique des résultats des AFLP en utilisant une analyse paramétrique,
le test de Mantel et/ou le coefficient alpha de Cronbach, ainsi que l'analyse de la
variance moléculaire en utilisant les coefficients Fs, ou Phis;
b) détermination de l'erreur de la culture de tissus induite et des estimations de
la variabilité somaclonale, sur la base du coefficient de corrélation du test de Mantel;
c) détermination des paramètres quantitatifs de la variabilité induite par le procédé
de dérivation des régénérants et la variabilité somaclonale pour les régénérants,
les progénitures individuelles de régénérant, en tenant compte du procédé de dérivation
et en donnant leur niveau de signification statistique;
d) détermination statistique des différences entre les types particuliers d'événements
induits dans les cultures in vitro pour les régénérants ainsi que la progéniture volumique de régénérant, regroupés
par le procédé de dérivation et complétés par leur signification statistique en utilisant
des matrices quantitatives des événements;
e) analyse statistique de la comparaison entre la variabilité induite par le procédé
de dérivation ainsi que la variation somaclonale, déterminée par la comparaison du
profil de la plante donneuse, et le profil volumique de la progéniture de régénérant
et de leurs types: variabilité des séquences et/ou grande variabilité de séquence,
méthylation de novo, déméthylation, variabilité mixte, héritage de: modèles de méthylation, sites non
méthylés ou sites conservateurs dans la progéniture de régénérant, regroupés par le
procédé de dérivation ainsi qu'une comparaison par le procédé de dérivation de la
progéniture de régénérant, où les matrices quantitatives sont utilisées pour des événements;
f) comparaisons statistiques des régénérants et les progénitures volumiques de régénérant
pour les différentes procédé de dérivation pour une progéniture donnée de régénérant,
où les matrices quantitatives de la progéniture sont utilisées;
g) comparaison statistique des résultats des points ci-dessus mentionnés pour régénérants
individuels et progénitures volumiques de régénérant entre eux;
h) comparaison statistique ou qualitative de la variation somaclonale entre les plantes
individuelles étant la progéniture générative de régénérants;
i) classement des résultats existants sous forme d'une compilation indiquant des caractéristiques
quantitatives de la variabilité induite par le procédé de dérivation déterminées au
niveau de régénérants, ainsi que des caractéristiques quantitatives de la variabilité
héritée déterminées au niveau de la progéniture de régénérant.
2. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle l'identification des 14 types
d'événements reconnus au niveau de la matrice binaire est choisie parmi les événements
représentés dans la Fig. 7.
3. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle pour dériver plantes donneuses,
une seule plante est utilisée qui est un haploïde doublé dérivé d'une microspore isolée,
dans laquelle elle est traitée comme un contrôle de la variabilité génétique et épigénétique
des plantes donneuses.
4. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle la variabilité génétique et épigénétique
du matériel propagé de façon générative, plantes donneuses, est déterminée sur la
base de profils AFLP obtenus à partir des isoschizomères d'endonucléase de restriction
reconnaissant et digérant des séquences identiques, mais différant dans leur sensibilité
à la méthylation à ou à environ du site de restriction, dans laquelle l'un des isoschizomères
est insensible à la méthylation.
5. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle dans un système sensible et insensible
à la méthylation aucune différence n'est observée dans les profils AFLP des plantes
donneuses, alors le niveau de variabilité induite par la propagation générative et
identifié par une paire donnée d'amorces sélectives est insignifiant.
6. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle quand il y a des différences dans
les profils AFLP pour plantes donneuses entre un système sensible et un système insensible
à la méthylation, une partie en pourcentage d'un tel événement est déterminée, ainsi
que le niveau de fond, erreur de propagation générative.
7. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle quand il y a des différences dans
les profils AFLP pour réplicants expérimentaux sur les mêmes échantillons d'ADN, l'erreur
de la technique AFLP est estimée afin de déterminer l'erreur expérimentale.
8. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle la partie intégrale du matériel
de recherche est composée des plantes donneuses, ainsi qu'une seule plante, des régénérants
de plantes donneuses et des progénitures distinctes de régénérant.
9. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle la plante donneuse ainsi que les
régénérants et la progéniture de régénérant composent le noyau du matériel de recherche
pour l'étude de la variabilité induite par le procédé de dérivation ou de la variabilité
somaclonale, respectivement.
10. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle l'analyse moléculaire est réalisée
en utilisant la technique AFLP en deux variantes, en utilisant les isoschizomères
se différenciant par leur sensibilité à la méthylation.
11. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle l'un des isoschizomères est totalement
insensible à la méthylation.
12. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle dans l'identification des produits
séparés de PCR, et traceur isotopique est utilisé, qui est introduit à l'extrémité
5 'de l'amorce complémentaire à l'adaptateur joint au site de restriction libéré par
les isoschizomères.
13. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle d'autres procédés de visualisation
des fragments AFLP sont utilisés, notamment la fluorescence.
14. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle les profils des deux variantes
AFLP pour la plante donneuse ainsi que ses régénérants et en tenant compte du procédé
de dérivation et le contrôle de la reproductibilité AFLP sont réalisés sur les paires
identiques d'amorces AFLP.
15. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle l'analyse des profils AFLP et
leur conversion en matrices binaires est basée sur le fait que les profils AFLP des
deux systèmes de restrictase pour toutes les paires d'amorces sélectives sont entrés
en tant que matrice binaire dans un tableur, où l'ensemble des données obtenues pour
une paire d'amorces sélectives AFLP est placé sous un ensemble précédent de telle
sorte que chaque colonne représente un profil binaire total pour une plante donneuse
dans un système AFLP, et les colonnes suivantes contiennent des données analogues
pour les régénérants et les contrôles, dans laquelle les données pour le deuxième
système AFLP sont enregistrées dans les colonnes suivantes, dans laquelle les bandes
d'un système sont ordonnées comme celles du système précédent (en lignes), et où une
bande donnée n'apparaît pas un zéro est entré dans la ligne correspondante du tableur.
16. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle l'analyse des profils AFLP et
leur conversion en matrices binaires est basée sur le fait que les profils AFLP des
deux systèmes de restrictase pour toutes les paires d'amorces sélectives sont entrés
en tant que matrice binaire dans un tableur, où l'ensemble des données obtenues pour
une paire d'amorces sélectives AFLP est placé sous un ensemble précédent de telle
sorte que chaque colonne représente un profil binaire total pour une plante donneuse
dans un système AFLP, et les colonnes suivantes contiennent des données analogues
pour les progénitures de régénérant et les contrôles, dans laquelle les données pour
le deuxième système AFLP sont enregistrées dans les colonnes suivantes, dans laquelle
les bandes d'un système sont ordonnées comme celles du système précédent (en lignes),
et où une bande donnée n'apparaît pas un zéro est entré dans la ligne correspondante
du tableur.
17. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle le profil AFLP pour la progéniture
de régénérant est représenté sous forme d'un génotype volumique par variante AFLP,
sensible et insensible à la méthylation séparément.
18. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle le contrôle de la propagation
générative est réalisé par la sommation du nombre de signaux (événements) d'une seule
plante, où le nombre de modifications est calculé comme un pourcentage du nombre total
d'événements.
19. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle l'analyse paramétrique, l'analyse
de corrélation de test de Mantel et l'analyse de la variabilité moléculaire sont réalisées
en utilisant des matrices binaires de systèmes AFLP sensibles et insensibles à la
méthylation pour les régénérants et/ou la progéniture de régénérant selon que la variabilité
induite dans la culture ou héritée par la progéniture de régénérant sont en cours
d'analyse.
20. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle l'analyse factorielle est utilisée
en tant que la représentation graphique des résultats de l'AFLP.
21. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle l'identification des 14 types
d'événements reconnus au niveau du modèle AFLP et attribués à la variabilité induite
par le procédé de dérivation est effectuée sur la base des modèles AFLP, dans laquelle
le profil de la plante donneuse est utilisé avec des profils des régénérants dans
les deux systèmes, et ensuite le profil de chaque régénérant est comparé au profil
de la plante donneuse afin d'identifier ces événements.
22. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle l'identification des 14 types
d'événements reconnus au niveau des modèles AFLP et attribués à la variabilité somaclonale
est effectuée sur la base des modèles AFLP, dans laquelle le profil de la plante donneuse
est utilisé avec des profils dans les deux systèmes AFLP, et le profil volumique de
la progéniture de régénérant est comparé au profil de la plante donneuse afin d'identifier
les types d'événements, dans laquelle on suppose que dans le cas de fragments polymorphes
d'AFLP du génotype volumique de la progéniture de régénérant, une valeur différente
de celle de la plante donneuse est entrée ou une autre valeur si elle est différente
de celle de la plante donneuse dans toutes les progénitures de régénérant pour un
système donnée d'AFLP.
23. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle lorsque les 14 types d'événements
comprennent la base pour leur ségrégation dans les groupes: variabilité de séquence,
variabilité de méthylation (méthylation et déméthylation), variabilité mixte et héritage
des modèles de méthylation, dans laquelle il est pris en compte le fait que la variabilité
de séquence est confirmée sans équivoque dans un système insensible à la méthylation.
24. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle l'analyse de la signification
des types individuels de variabilité et des événements au sein des régénérants et
des plantes de la progéniture de régénérant, comme regroupés par le procédé de dérivation,
est effectuée sur la base des matrices qualitatives et des matrices quantitatives
d'événements décrivant tous les événements théoriquement possibles, ainsi que les
plantes de régénérant et la progéniture de régénérant.
25. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle les résultats de l'analyse statistique
pour les régénérants individuels et les progénitures volumiques de régénérant obtenus
par divers moyens sont compilés dans un ensemble; paramètres quantitatifs sont entrés
pour la variabilité induite par le procédé de dérivation et de la variabilité somaclonale
pour les régénérants individuels et les progénitures volumiques de régénérant, ainsi
que pour les progénitures distinctes de régénérant regroupées par le procédé de dérivation
et les types d'événements avec paramètres statistiques.
26. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle ces types d'événements sont identifiés,
qui sont rares dans la culture ou qui ne se produisent pas du tout, ainsi que ceux
qui sont particulièrement exposés à l'activité des facteurs induisant la variabilité
au niveau du régénérant et la progéniture de régénérant, ainsi que pour déterminer
leur paramètres quantitatifs.
27. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle types individuels d'événements
sont étudiés au niveau moléculaire par l'analyse de séquence des fragments AFLP représentant
types individuels d'événements, et par les mêmes types de marqueurs de la variabilité
somaclonale.
28. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle on analyse une ou plus de progénitures
volumiques de régénérant.
29. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle les caractéristiques quantitatives
d'un événement sont données pour chaque progéniture individuelle de régénérant: variabilité
de séquence, grande variabilité de séquence, variabilité épigénétique des modèles
de méthylation (méthylation de novo, déméthylation), stabilité des sites hérités méthylés et non méthylés (conservateurs),
contre les modifications induites dans les cultures, ainsi que des différences quantitatives
entrant dans la variabilité entre les différents procédés de dérivation du matériel
de la plante.
30. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle on réalise l'analyse statistique
de l'importance des types individuels d'événements parmi les régénérants, la progéniture
volumique de régénérant et les progénitures individuels de régénérant si nécessaire,
regroupés par le procédé de dérivation du matériel de recherche.
31. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle le niveau de la variabilité somaclonale
des plantes individuelles qui sont la progéniture de régénérant est déterminé indépendamment,
en utilisant les principes utilisés pour la variabilité somaclonale.
32. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle les hypothèses relatives aux sources
de la variabilité induite par le procédé de dérivation des régénérants et celle héritée
à la suite de la propagation générative sont testées.
33. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle on réalise l'analyse détaillée
des causes de la variabilité de séquence après l'introduction de modifications procédurales
mineures d'AFLP, sur la base de l'amplification sélective du matériel de recherche
en utilisant une amorce marquée complémentaire aux sites conservateurs des éléments
transposables, ou aux séquences macrosatellites.
34. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle la ségrégation de marqueurs génétiques
et épigénétiques sont analysés pour mapper les populations dérivées de croisements
entre plantes qui sont la progéniture de régénérants avec un génotype connu, sur la
base des profils AFLP pour les deux systèmes AFLP.
35. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle le procédé est conçu pour dériver
des plantes in vitro avec un niveau de la variabilité somaclonale abaissé ou augmenté par l'identification
des causes de cette variabilité.
36. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle on vérifie la pureté génétique
et épigénétique du matériel arbitraire dérivé par la culture in vitro.
37. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle le procédé est utilisé dans l'analyse
de l'héritage de la variabilité épigénétique au cours de croisement sexuel.
38. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle le procédé est un outil pour l'identification
de marqueurs épigénétiques liés aux caractéristiques utilitaires du matériel de la
plante.
39. Utilisation selon la revendication 1, dans laquelle le procédé est utilisé pour l'identification
des différences dans les modèles de méthylation de l'ADN pour les différents tissus
d'une plante individuelle.