BACKGROUND
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to controlling a fuel cell.
Background Art
[0002] In a fuel cell, for example, polymer electrolyte fuel cell, chemical energy of a
substance is directly converted into electrical energy by electrochemical reaction
of reactive gases (fuel gas and oxidizing gas) respectively supplied to a pair of
electrodes (anode and cathode) placed across an electrolyte membrane.
[0003] In a fuel cell system having such a fuel cell, one known control method measures
the output voltage of each of cells included in the fuel cell and gives an instruction
to decrease the load when the minimum voltage among the measured output voltages is
less than 0 V, while giving an instruction to increase the load when the minimum voltage
is not less than a predetermined threshold value. The known control method is shown
in
JP 2006-179389A,
JP 2007-35516A and
JP 2008-300299A, for example.
SUMMARY
[0005] A short circuit area may be generated in each cell of the fuel cell due to penetration
of the base material (for example, carbon fiber) of gas diffusion layers provided
to diffuse the reactive gases, through the electrolyte membrane. In the presence of
a short circuit area in the cell of the fuel cell, continuing power generation at
negative voltage or keeping the fuel cell at no load may cause electric current to
flow through the short circuit area in the cell. The electric current flowing through
the short circuit area in the cell may increase the temperature of the short circuit
area to or above the decomposition temperature of the electrolyte membrane. This may
cause a pinhole in the electrolyte membrane in the periphery of the short circuit
area and causes performance degradation of the fuel cell.
[0006] The increasing temperature of the short circuit area in the cell by the electric
current flowing through the short circuit area in the cell and the decomposition temperature
of the electrolyte membrane differ depending on the resistance value of the short
circuit area and the specification of the fuel cell (for example, the thickness of
the electrolyte membrane). The above prior art method uniformly controls the voltage
of the fuel cell with threshold values set without considering the resistance value
of the short circuit area and the specification of the fuel cell. This does not effectively
prevent a pinhole from being made in the electrolyte membrane.
[0007] Consequently, in order to solve at least part of the foregoing, there is a need to
provide a fuel cell system and its control method that effectively prevent a pinhole
from being made in an electrolyte membrane of the fuel cell.
[0008] In order to achieve at least part of the foregoing, the present invention provides
various aspects and embodiments described below.
[0009] First aspect: According to a first aspect of the invention, there is provided a fuel
cell system as defined in claim 1.
[0010] The fuel cell system according to this aspect obtains the temperature index value
correlated to the temperature of the short circuit area in each cell and controls
the control parameter of the fuel cell affecting the temperature of the short circuit
area, such that the temperature index value is within the predetermined range set
to make the temperature of the short circuit area lower than the decomposition temperature
of the electrolyte membrane. This effectively prevents a pinhole from being made in
the electrolyte membrane of the fuel cell.
[0011] The fuel cell system according to this aspect obtains the resistance value of the
short circuit area and sets the predetermined range of the temperature index value
based on the obtained resistance value of the short circuit area. This enables the
allowable range of the temperature index value to be set with high accuracy, thus
effectively preventing a pinhole from being made in an electrolyte membrane of the
fuel cell and reducing deterioration of drivability.
[0012] The fuel cell system according to this aspect obtains the amount of drop of the voltage
value at low load due to the decreased resistance value of the short circuit area,
which may cause a pinhole in the electrolyte membrane, without measuring the open
circuit voltage, and determines whether the resistance value of the short circuit
area is to be reacquired. This effectively prevents a pinhole from being made in the
electrolyte membrane, while enabling the improved durability of the fuel cell and
the efficient control.
[0013] Second aspect: In the fuel cell system according to the first aspect,
the resistance value acquirer may reacquire the resistance value of the short circuit
area, based on a first voltage value at low load, which is the corrected voltage value
at low load in the first characteristic, and a current value in the second characteristic
corresponding to the first voltage value at low load.
[0014] The fuel cell system according to this aspect obtains the amount of drop of the open
circuit voltage due to the decreased resistance value of the short circuit area, which
may cause a pinhole in the electrolyte membrane, and determines whether the resistance
value of the short circuit area is to be reacquired. This effectively prevents a pinhole
from being made in the electrolyte membrane, while enabling efficient control.
[0015] Third aspect: In the fuel cell system according to the first or second aspect,
the temperature index value may be a voltage value of the fuel cell, and
the controller may set at least one different predetermined range of the temperature
index value for preventing performance degradation of the fuel cell and control the
control parameter of the fuel cell, such that the temperature index value is within
the different predetermined range and within the predetermined range set to make the
temperature of the short circuit area lower than the decomposition temperature of
the electrolyte membrane.
[0016] The fuel cell system according to this aspect enables the highly robust control of
the fuel cell, while effectively preventing a pinhole from being made in the electrolyte
membrane. This also efficiently avoids potential degradation or deterioration of the
fuel cell in a plurality of deterioration modes.
[0017] The present invention may be actualized by diversity of applications, for example,
a fuel cell, a fuel cell system and methods of controlling the fuel cell and the fuel
cell system. A method of controlling the fuel cell is set forth in claim 4.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0018]
Fig. 1 schematically illustrates the configuration of an electric vehicle 10, to which
a fuel cell system 20 according to a first example is applicable;
Fig. 2 is a flowchart showing a control flow of the fuel cell system 20 according
to the first example;
Fig. 3 illustrates one exemplary method of measuring the resistance of a short circuit
area SC in the cell 21;
Fig. 4 is a graph showing one example of measurement results of the electric current
against the cathode potential in the cell 21;
Fig. 5 illustrates one example of experimental results to set the decomposition temperature
Td of the electrolyte membrane ME;
Fig. 6 illustrates one example of temperature measurement results when the electrolyte
membrane ME is degraded to make a pinhole;
Figs. 7A and 7B illustrate supposed circuit of cell 21 in setting the threshold value;
Fig. 8 illustrates one example of the original threshold value V10 and the threshold
value V1 varying with the resistance of the short circuit area SC;
Fig. 9 illustrates one example of the original threshold value V20 and the threshold
value V2 varying with the resistance of the short circuit area SC;
Fig. 10 is a flowchart showing the flow of operation control of the fuel cell 22 according
to the first example;
Fig. 11 illustrates one example of experimental results for setting the required amount
of heat Q;
Fig. 12 is a flowchart showing the flow of reacquiring the resistance value of the
short circuit area SC according to a second example;
Fig. 13 illustrates one example of measurement results of the I-V characteristic of
the cell 21;
Fig. 14 illustrates one example of the calculated V-R characteristic of the cell A;
Figs. 15A and 15B illustrate the theoretical basis of the method of estimating the
resistance value of the short circuit area SC in the cell B;
Fig. 16 is a flowchart showing the flow of reacquisition of the resistance value of
the short circuit area SC (step S150 in Fig. 2) according to a first modification
of the second example;
Fig. 17 is a flowchart showing the flow of reacquisition of the resistance value of
the short circuit area SC according to a second modification of the second example;
Fig. 18 is a flowchart showing the flow of reacquisition of the resistance value of
the short circuit area SC (step S150 in Fig. 2) according to a third modification
of the second example;
Fig. 19 is a flowchart showing the flow of reacquiring the resistance value of the
short circuit area SC (step S150 in Fig. 2) according to a first embodiment;
Figs. 20A and 20B illustrate one example of measurement results of the I-V characteristic
of the cell 21;
Fig. 21 illustrates a method of estimating the current Is of the short circuit area
SC;
Fig. 22 is a flowchart showing the flow of reacquisition of the resistance value of
the short circuit area SC (step S150 in Fig. 2) according to a first modification
of the first embodiment;
Fig. 23 is a flowchart showing the flow of reacquisition of the resistance value of
the short circuit area SC (step S150 in Fig. 2) according to a second modification
of the first embodiment;
Fig. 24 is a flowchart showing the flow of reacquisition of the resistance value of
the short circuit area SC (step S150 in Fig. 2) according to a third modification
of the first embodiment;
Fig. 25 illustrates a method of estimating the current of the short circuit area SC
in the cell F;
Fig. 26 illustrates one example of voltage threshold values during control of the
fuel cell 22 according to a second embodiment;
Fig 27 illustrates one example of voltage threshold values during control of the fuel
cell 22 according to a second embodiment;
Fig. 28 illustrates one exemplary method of setting the threshold value Vt4; and
Fig. 29 is a flowchart showing the flow of operation control of the fuel cell 22 according
to the second embodiment.
DESCRIPTION OF THE EMBODIMENT
[0019] The invention is described in detail with reference to examples which are outside
the terms of the claims and embodiments of the invention.
A. First Example
A-1. Configuration of Fuel Cell System
[0020] Fig. 1 schematically illustrates the configuration of an electric vehicle 10, to
which a fuel cell system 20 according to a first example is applicable. The electric
vehicle 10 includes the fuel cell system 20, a secondary battery 30 and a drive motor
33 used to drive a vehicle driveshaft 39. The fuel cell system 20 includes a fuel
cell 22, a hydrogen tank 23 used to store hydrogen to be supplied to the fuel cell
22, and an air compressor 24 used to supply the compressed air to the fuel cell 22.
[0021] Hydrogen stored in the hydrogen tank 23 as the fuel gas is led to a hydrogen gas
supply path 60, is subjected to pressure reduction by a pressure reducing valve 61
provided in the hydrogen gas supply path 60 and subsequent pressure adjustment to
a preset pressure level by a pressure regulator 62, and is supplied to anodes in the
fuel cell 22. The anode off-gas from the anodes is led through an anode off-gas flow
path 63 and is recirculated to the hydrogen gas supply path 60 by means of a hydrogen
pump 65. Setting an on-off valve 66 provided in an exhaust gas discharge path 64 branched
off from the anode off-gas flow path 63 to ON position discharges outside part of
the anode off-gas.
[0022] The air taken in from outside as the oxidizing gas via an air flow meter 28 equipped
with a filter is compressed by the air compressor 24 and is supplied to cathodes in
the fuel cell 22 via an oxidizing gas supply path 67. The air may be humidified before
being supplied to the fuel cell 22. The cathode off-gas from the cathodes is led through
a cathode off-gas flow path 68 and is discharged outside.
[0023] The fuel cell 22 may be any of various types of fuel cells and is a polymer electrolyte
fuel cell according to the example. The fuel cell 22 has stacked structure including
a plurality of cells 21 stacked via separators (not shown). Each cell 21 is a unit
module of power generation in the fuel cell 22 and includes a membrane electrode assembly
(also referred to as MEA), wherein an anode and a cathode are respectively formed
on opposite surfaces of an electrolyte membrane (not shown). Each cell 21 also includes
gas diffusion layers placed across the MEA and provided to diffuse and supply the
hydrogen gas and the air as reactive gases to the MEA. The respective cells 21 of
the fuel cell 22 generate electric power through electrochemical reaction of the hydrogen
gas and oxygen contained in the air. According to this example, the respective cells
21 have identical structure and specification.
[0024] The fuel cell system 20 also has voltmeters 26 used to measure the voltages of the
respective cells 21 (cell voltages) in the fuel cell 22 and a controller 70 configured
to use signals representing the cell voltages output from the voltmeters 26 and other
signals and thereby control the fuel cell system 20 as described later. The controller
70 is constructed by a microcomputer including a CPU, a ROM and a RAM.
[0025] The fuel cell system 20 is connected with the drive motor 33 via an inverter 35,
and is connected with the secondary battery 30 via a DC-DC converter 32. The electric
power output from the fuel cell system 20 is supplied to the drive motor 33 and is
used to drive the vehicle driveshaft 39 by the drive motor 33. When the state of charge
in the secondary battery 30 decreases to or below a preset level, the secondary battery
30 is charged by the fuel cell system 20. The electric power of the secondary battery
30 is used to, for example, drive the drive motor 33 in the event of power shortage.
A-2. Controlling Fuel Cell System
[0026] Fig. 2 is a flowchart showing a control flow of the fuel cell system 20 according
to the first example. At the factory shipment of the fuel cell system 20, the resistance
of a short circuit area in each cell 21 of the fuel cell 22 is measured (step S110).
The resistance of the short circuit area in each cell 21 measured at the factory shipment
is referred to as initial short circuit resistance.
[0027] The resistance of the short circuit area in each cell 21 may be measured by, for
example, a known method described in
JP 2002-208424A. Fig. 3 illustrates one exemplary method of measuring the resistance of a short circuit
area SC in the cell 21. As shown in Fig. 3, the cell 21 includes an electrolyte membrane
ME, an anode AE and a cathode CE. The short circuit area SC may be generated in the
cell 21, for example, due to penetration of the base material (for example, carbon
fiber) of the gas diffusion layers provided to diffuse the reactive gases, through
the electrolyte membrane ME. Crossover or cross leakage CL, which means leakage of
the hydrogen gas from the anode AE to the cathode CE, may occur in the cell 21.
[0028] During measurement of the resistance of the short circuit area SC in each cell 21,
hydrogen gas is supplied to the anode AE, while nitrogen gas as inert gas is supplied
to the cathode CE. The hydrogen tank 23 and the hydrogen gas supply path 60 (Fig.
1) are used to supply the hydrogen gas to the anode AE. A nitrogen gas supply system
(not shown) provided in place of the oxidizing gas supply path 67 is used to supply
the nitrogen gas to the cathode CE. In this state, an external power source PS is
connected with the cell 21 and applies voltages to the cell 21, such that the cathode
CE has positive potential. The current value is then measured at each voltage value.
In the presence of the short circuit area SC, electric current flows through the short
circuit area SC during application of a voltage to the cell 21. In the presence of
the cross leakage CL in the cell 21, electric current also flows, due to the reaction
proceeding at the cathode CE to decompose the hydrogen gas reaching the cathode CE
by the cross leakage CL into proton and electron and the reaction proceeding at the
anode AE to combine proton moving from the cathode CE through the electrolyte membrane
ME to the anode AE with electron to generate hydrogen.
[0029] Fig. 4 is a graph showing one example of measurement results of the electric current
against the cathode potential in the cell 21. Each straight line in Fig. 4 connects
the measurement values of electric current at the respective values of cathode potential
with respect to Case 1 having relatively large resistance of the short circuit area
SC and Case 2 having relatively small resistance of the short circuit area SC. The
resistance of the short circuit area SC is calculated from the slope of this straight
line. Case 1 shows a slight increase in current value with an increase of the cathode
potential and accordingly has large resistance of the short circuit area SC. Case
2, on the other hand, shows a significant increase in current value with an increase
of the cathode potential and accordingly has small resistance of the short circuit
area SC. In the absence of the short circuit area SC in the cell 21, there is theoretically
no increase in current value with an increase of the cathode potential. The intercept
of each straight line on the graph of Fig. 4 represents the electric current due to
the cross leakage CL. This measuring method measures the cross leakage CL in addition
to the resistance of the short circuit area SC, thus promoting the process efficiency
during inspection before shipment.
[0030] Another suitable method different from the above method may be employed to measure
the resistance of the short circuit area SC in the cell 21. For example, one available
method may supply the same type of gas to both the anode AE and the cathode CE, apply
a voltage between the two electrodes and calculate the resistance of the short circuit
area SC based on the voltage value and the current value when the current value becomes
steady. Immediately after application of a voltage between the electrodes, the electric
current flows due to charging of carbon and the change of platinum oxide. The resistance
of the short circuit area SC is determinable with high accuracy using the voltage
value and the current value after such electric current is discharged and the current
value becomes steady. The same type of gas used in this method may be hydrogen gas,
the air or an inert gas, such as nitrogen gas. The voltage applied between the electrodes
is preferably in a range of 0.3 V to 0.5 V.
[0031] The determined resistance of the short circuit area SC in the cell 21 is stored in
the controller 70 (Fig. 1), which accordingly serves as the resistance acquirer.
[0032] The control flow subsequently sets a decomposition temperature Td of the electrolyte
membrane ME in the cell 21 and calculates the amount of heat required to increase
the temperature of the electrolyte membrane ME to the decomposition temperature Td
(required amount of heat Q) (step S120). Fig. 5 illustrates one example of experimental
results to set the decomposition temperature Td of the electrolyte membrane ME. Fig.
5 shows the variations in derivative of weight reduction against the temperature measured
by thermography with respect to the electrolyte membrane, the catalyst layer and the
MEA. According to the experimental results shown in Fig. 5, the decomposition temperature
Td of the electrolyte membrane ME is set to, for example, 300°C.
[0033] Fig. 6 illustrates one example of temperature measurement results when the electrolyte
membrane ME is degraded to make a pinhole. Fig. 6 shows changes of the surface temperature
of the MEA and the surface temperature of the separator with time under application
of heat to the cell 21. Since an instrument having the upper temperature limit of
about 1400°C was used for the experiment, the temperatures of and above 1400°C are
all shown as 1400°C in Fig. 6. In the experiment, the surface temperature of the MEA
rose by more than 1000°C within about 0.1 second when about 8 seconds had elapsed
since the start of the experiment. The required amount of heat Q can thus be calculated
without taking into account the heat loss to the environment. Additionally, it was
confirmed that the amount of heat to be calculated was the amount of heat per 0.1
second.
[0034] Table 1 shows one example of calculation result of the required amount of heat Q.
According to Table 1, the amount of heat required to increase the temperature in part
of the electrolyte membrane ME corresponding to the expected diameter of a potential
pinhole to the decomposition temperature Td (300°C) (required amount of heat Q) is
calculated by setting various conditions, i.e., the specification of the cell 21 including
the thickness of the electrolyte membrane ME, the diameter of the gas diffusion layer
base material and the specific gravities and the specific heats of the respective
materials, the expected diameter of a potential pinhole, and the initial temperature.
In the example of Table 1, NRE211 (25 µm in thickness) manufactured by DuPont and
25BC manufactured by SGL were respectively used for the electrolyte membrane and for
the gas diffusion layer. The expected diameter of a potential pinhole was set to 1,000
µm. In the example of Table 1, the required amount of heat Q was about 0.05 J.
[Table 1]
[0035] After calculating the required amount of heat Q, the control flow sets voltage threshold
values V1 and V2 used to prevent a pinhole from being made in the electrolyte membrane
ME during control of the fuel cell 22 (step S130 in Fig. 2). A pinhole may be made
in the electrolyte membrane ME both during power generation at negative voltage (i.e.,
power generation at the cell voltage below 0 V) and during normal power generation
(i.e., power generation at the cell voltage of or above 0 V).
[0036] In the presence of the short circuit area SC in the cell 21 of the fuel cell 22,
continuing the power generation at the negative voltage may increase the overvoltage
of the MEA due to oxidation of carbon at the anode and drying up of the electrolyte
membrane ME in the cell 21, which may cause electric current to flow through the short
circuit area SC and thereby raise the temperature of the short circuit area SC. When
the temperature of the short circuit area SC reaches or exceeds the decomposition
temperature Td of the electrolyte membrane ME, the electrolyte membrane ME in the
periphery of the short circuit area SC is degraded and disappears to make a pinhole
in the electrolyte membrane ME.
[0037] In the presence of the short circuit area SC in the cell 21 of the fuel cell 22,
the voltage applied to the short circuit area SC is maximized when an open circuit
voltage (hereinafter referred to as "OCV") is applied to the cell 21 at no load. When
the cell 21 is kept at no load under the condition of the small resistance of the
short circuit area SC, electric current may flow through the short circuit area SC.
This may increase the temperature of the short circuit area SC to or above the decomposition
temperature Td of the electrolyte membrane ME and make a pinhole in the electrolyte
membrane ME.
[0038] The voltage threshold value V1 set at step S130 is a reference value during power
generation at negative voltage, and the voltage threshold value V2 is a reference
value during normal power generation. According to this example, the voltage value
of the fuel cell 22 is an index value correlated to the temperature of the short circuit
area SC in the cell 21 and serves as a control parameter of the fuel cell 22 affecting
the temperature of the short circuit area SC.
[0039] The process of setting the threshold value V1 during power generation at negative
voltage where the cell voltage of the cell 21 is less than 0 V first assumes the MEA
of the cell 21 as a variable resistance as shown in Fig. 7A and calculates an original
threshold value V10 according to Equation (1) given below. In Equation (1), R represents
the measured resistance of the short circuit area SC, and Q represents the required
amount of heat Q described above. The original threshold value V10 shows the voltage
of the cell 21 when the temperature of the short circuit area SC in the cell 21 becomes
equal to the decomposition temperature Td of the electrolyte membrane ME. Controlling
the fuel cell 22 to increase the voltage of the cell 21 above the original threshold
value V10 causes the temperature of the short circuit area SC in the cell 21 to be
lower than the decomposition temperature Td of the electrolyte membrane ME.

[0040] The threshold value V1 is set to be greater than the original threshold value V10
by adding a safety factor to the original threshold value V10. Fig. 8 illustrates
one example of the original threshold value V10 and the threshold value V1 varying
with the resistance of the short circuit area SC. As shown in Fig. 8, the threshold
value V1 is set for each cell 21, based on the resistance of the short circuit area
SC in the cell 21. Cross marks in Fig. 8 show the experimental conditions when a pinhole
is made in the electrolyte membrane ME. The experimental results prove that controlling
the fuel cell 22 to make the cell voltage of the cell 21 not less than the threshold
value V1 prevents a pinhole from being made in the electrolyte membrane ME.
[0041] The process of setting the threshold value V2 during normal power generation where
the cell voltage of the cell 21 is not less than 0 V first assumes the MEA of the
cell 21 as a battery as shown in Fig. 7B and calculates an original threshold value
V20 according to Equation (2) given below. In Equation (2), R represents the measured
resistance of the short circuit area SC, and Q represents the required amount of heat
Q described above. The original threshold value V20 shows the voltage of the cell
21 when the temperature of the short circuit area SC in the cell 21 becomes equal
to the decomposition temperature Td of the electrolyte membrane ME. Controlling the
fuel cell 22 to decrease the voltage of the cell 21 below the original threshold value
V20 causes the temperature of the short circuit area SC in the cell 21 to be lower
than the decomposition temperature Td of the electrolyte membrane ME.

[0042] The threshold value V2 is set to be smaller than the original threshold value V20
by adding a safety factor to the original threshold value V20. Fig. 9 illustrates
one example of the original threshold value V20 and the threshold value V2 varying
with the resistance of the short circuit area SC. As shown in Fig. 9, the threshold
value V2 is set for each cell 21, based on the resistance of the short circuit area
SC in the cell 21. Controlling the fuel cell 22 to make the cell voltage of the cell
21 not greater than the threshold value V2 prevents a pinhole from being made in the
electrolyte membrane ME.
[0043] After setting the threshold values V1 and V2, the controller 70 performs operation
control of the fuel cell 22 (step S140 in Fig. 2). Fig. 10 is a flowchart showing
the flow of operation control of the fuel cell 22 according to the first example.
The controller 70 controls the respective constituents of the fuel cell system 20
for power generation by the fuel cell 22 (step S210) and obtains the voltage value
of each cell 21 measured by the voltmeter 26 at a predetermined timing (step S220).
The controller 70 accordingly serves as the index value acquirer to obtain a voltage
value as a temperature index value correlated to the temperature of the short circuit
area SC in the cell 21. The timing of voltage measurement may be every time a predetermined
period has elapsed or every time power has been generated for a predetermined period.
[0044] When the cell voltage of the cell 21 is less than 0V (step S230: No) but is not less
than the threshold value V1 set for each cell 21 (step S240: No), the controller 70
determines that there is no possibility of a pinhole made in the electrolyte membrane
ME (see Fig. 8) and continues power generation (step S210). When the cell voltage
of the cell 21 is less than 0V and is less than the threshold value V1 (step S240:
Yes), on the other hand, the controller 70 determines that there is a possibility
of a pinhole made in the electrolyte membrane ME and performs control to increase
the voltage of the fuel cell 22 (step S250). More specifically, the controller 70
performs control to decrease the load (electric current), increase the circulation
amount in the hydrogen gas circulation system, increase the air stoichiometric ratio
or increase the humidification amount. This increases the cell voltage of each cell
21 to or above the threshold value V1 and thereby prevents a pinhole from being made
in the electrolyte membrane ME.
[0045] When the cell voltage of the cell 21 is equal to or greater than 0 V (step S230:
Yes) but is not greater than the threshold value V2 set for each cell 21 (step S260:
No), the controller 70 determines that there is no possibility of a pinhole made in
the electrolyte membrane ME (see Fig. 9) and continues power generation (step S210).
When the cell voltage of the cell 21 is equal to or greater than 0 V and is greater
than the threshold value V2 (step S260: Yes), on the other hand, the controller 70
determines that there is a possibility of a pinhole made in the electrolyte membrane
ME and performs control to decrease the voltage of the fuel cell 22 (step S270). More
specifically, the controller 70 performs control to generate power and charge the
secondary battery 30 with the generated power or decrease the air stoichiometric ratio.
This decreases the cell voltage of each cell 21 to or below the threshold value V2
and thereby prevents a pinhole from being made in the electrolyte membrane ME.
[0046] In summary, when it is determined that there is a possibility of a pinhole made in
the electrolyte membrane ME in the decision based on the cell voltage of the cell
21 (steps S240 and S260 in Fig. 10), the fuel cell system 20 of the example performs
control to decrease the absolute value of the voltage of the fuel cell 22 (steps S250
and S270).
[0047] The control flow of this example reacquires the resistance value of the short circuit
area SC in each cell 21 at a predetermined timing after shipment of the fuel cell
system 20 (step S150 in Fig. 2) and updates the threshold values V1 and V2 (sets new
threshold values V1 and V2) based on the reacquired resistance value (step S130).
This enables control of the fuel cell 22 using the threshold values V1 and V2 adequately
set by taking into account the time change in resistance value of the short circuit
area SC in each cell 21, thus effectively preventing a pinhole from being made in
the electrolyte membrane.
[0048] For example, the timing of reacquiring the resistance value of the short circuit
area SC may be during regular check of the fuel cell system 20. On this occasion,
the same method as any of the methods of measuring the initial short circuit resistance
described above may be employed to measure the resistance value of the short circuit
area SC. In other examples, the timing of reacquiring the resistance value of the
short circuit area SC may be on shutdown immediately after the total operation time
of the fuel cell 22 exceeds a predetermined period of time or may be on shutdown immediately
after the total driving distance of the electric vehicle 10 exceeds a predetermined
distance. On such occasions, onboard measurement of the resistance value in the short
circuit area SC is preferable. In this case, the same method as any of the methods
of measuring the initial short circuit resistance described above may also be employed
to measure the resistance value of the short circuit area SC. The especially preferable
method adopted on these occasions supplies the same type of gas (either hydrogen gas
or the air) to both the anode AE and the cathode CE, applies a voltage between the
two electrodes and calculates the resistance of the short circuit area SC based on
the voltage value and the current value when the current value becomes steady, since
this method does not require an inert gas supply system provided in the fuel cell
system 20.
[0049] In the fuel cell system 20 of the example described above, the controller 70 obtains
the voltage value of each cell 21 and controls the voltage of the fuel cell 22 to
make the obtained voltage value within the predetermined range defined by the threshold
values V1 and V2 during operation control of the fuel cell 22. The voltage of each
cell 21 is correlated to the electric current flowing in the short circuit area SC
in the cell 21 and is thereby correlated to the temperature of the shot circuit area
SC. The voltage threshold values V1 and V2 are set to define such a voltage range
as to make the temperature of the short circuit area SC lower than the decomposition
temperature Td of the electrolyte membrane. The fuel cell system 20 of the example
thus effectively prevents a pinhole from being made in the electrolyte membrane of
the fuel cell 22.
[0050] In the fuel cell system 20 of the example, the voltage threshold values V1 and V2
are set based on the specification of the fuel cell 22 and the resistance value of
the short circuit area SC in each cell 21, such that the temperature of the short
circuit area SC is lower than the decomposition temperature Td of the electrolyte
membrane. The threshold values V1 and V2 can thus be set adequately according to the
specification of the fuel cell 22 and the degree of short circuit in each cell 21.
This effectively prevents a pinhole from being made in the electrolyte membrane of
the fuel cell 22. The fuel cell system 20 of the example also allows a change in voltage
value immediately before the respective threshold values V1 and V2 and thereby enables
a wider allowable range of the voltage of the fuel cell 22, compared with the system
of setting safety threshold values without taking into account the resistance value
of the short circuit area SC and the specification of the fuel cell 22. The fuel cell
system 20 of the example accordingly extends the range of continuous operation without
the output limit of the fuel cell 22. This enables establishment of the highly robust
system with preventing deterioration of drivability. Additionally, the fuel cell system
20 of the example sets the voltage threshold values V1 and V2 for each cell 21 based
on the resistance value of the short circuit area SC in the cell 21 and makes a comparison
between the measured voltage value and the threshold values V1 and V2 for each cell
21. This enables a wider allowable range of the voltage of the fuel cell 22, while
similarly preventing deterioration of drivability, compared with the system of uniformly
setting fixed threshold values for all the cells 21 and performing voltage control
with the fixed threshold values.
[0051] In the fuel cell system 20 of the example, the adequate threshold values V1 and V2
can be set by taking into account the time change in resistance value of the short
circuit area SC in each cell 21. This effectively prevents a pinhole from being made
in the electrolyte membrane, while preventing deterioration of drivability over a
long period of time.
[0052] According to the example described above, the control flow sets the decomposition
temperature Td of the electrolyte membrane ME and calculates the amount of heat required
to increase the temperature of the electrolyte membrane ME to the decomposition temperature
Td (required amount of heat Q) based on the specification of the cell 21, such as
the thickness of the electrolyte membrane ME. Alternatively the required amount of
heat Q may be set experimentally. Fig. 11 illustrates one example of experimental
results for setting the required amount of heat Q. Fig. 11 shows the correlation of
the heating value (per 0.1 second) on the occurrence of a pinhole to the resistance
of the short circuit area SC in the cell 21 with respect to a plurality of cells 21
of the same specification prepared under different conditions (e.g., method of making
the catalyst layers and the temperature and the pressure for heat transfer), when
a pinhole was made in the electrolyte membrane during power generation at negative
voltage. In the illustrated example of Fig. 11, the minimum heating value (Jmin) on
the occurrence of a pinhole was about 0.05 J, so that the required amount of heat
Q is set to this minimum heating value.
B. Second Example
B-1. Reacquisition of Resistance Value of Short Circuit Area
[0053] Fig. 12 is a flowchart showing the flow of reacquiring the resistance value of the
short circuit area SC (step S150 in Fig. 2) according to a second example. Like the
first example, the second example requires the resistance value of the short circuit
area SC in each cell 21 of the fuel cell 22 at a predetermined timing after shipment
of the fuel cell system 20. Unlike the first example, however, the second example
does not directly measure but estimates the resistance value of the short circuit
area SC in each cell 21 from the characteristics of the cell 21.
[0054] The controller 70 (Fig. 1) first determines whether there is any cell 21 having the
reduced OCV (open circuit voltage) from the initial value (step S310). The controller
70 stores the initial value of OCV for each cell 21, measures the voltage (OCV) of
each cell 21 at no load and compares the measured voltage with the initial value for
such determination. In general, the OCV is reduced by the decreased resistance value
of the short circuit area SC and by the cross leakage CL. When it is determined that
there is no cell 21 having the reduced OCV from the initial value, the controller
70 detects the absence of any cell 21 having the decreased resistance value of the
short circuit area SC and continues the operation without resetting the threshold
values V1 and V2 (step S130 in Fig. 2).
[0055] When it is determined at step S310 that there is any cell 21 having the reduced OCV
from the initial value, the controller 70 measures the I-V characteristic (relation
between current density and cell voltage) with respect to the cell 21 having the reduced
OCV (hereinafter also referred to as cell B) and the cell 21 having the unchanged
OCV from the initial value (hereinafter also referred to as cell A), and compares
the two I-V characteristics to estimate the amount of voltage drop due to the cross
leakage CL (step S320 in Fig. 12). The I-V characteristics used for estimation of
the amount of voltage drop may be newly measured or may be calculated from the current
value and the voltage value at each load recorded in advance during operation of the
fuel cell system 20.
[0056] Fig. 13 illustrates one example of measurement results of the I-V characteristic
of the cell 21. Fig. 13 shows the measurement results of the I-V characteristic of
the cell A having the unchanged OCV and the I-V characteristic of the cell B having
the reduced OCV. The controller 70 estimates a voltage difference between these two
I-V characteristics at a specified high load, as the amount of voltage drop due to
the cross leakage CL. Such estimation is allowed since the amount of voltage drop
due to the decreased resistance value of the short circuit area SC is negligibly smaller
than the amount of voltage drop due to the cross leakage CL at high load and the amount
of cross leakage CL is constant irrespective of the electric current. The specified
high load is preferably the state that the current density is not lower than 0.5 A/cm
2. In the illustrated example of Fig. 13, the voltage difference between the cell A
and the cell B at the current density of 1.0 A/cm
2 is estimated as the amount of voltage drop due to the cross leakage CL. The amount
of cell voltage drop can thus be divided into the amount of voltage drop due to the
cross leakage CL and the amount of voltage drop due to the decreased resistance value
of the short circuit area SC.
[0057] The controller 70 subsequently calculates the OCV of the cell B corrected with the
amount of voltage drop due to the cross leakage CL (step S330). Fig. 13 also shows
the I-V characteristic of the cell B corrected with the amount of voltage drop due
to the cross leakage CL (i.e., I-V characteristic of the cell B assumed to have no
voltage drop due to the cross leakage CL). The corrected OCV of the cell B (hereinafter
referred to as "corrected open circuit voltage Vc") is obtained by increasing the
uncorrected OCV of the cell B by the amount of voltage drop due to the cross leakage
CL. When the calculated corrected OCV of the cell B is equal to the OCV of the cell
A, it is thought that the reduction of the OCV is ascribed to only the cross leakage
CL. The control flow accordingly has no need to reacquire the resistance value of
the short circuit area SC in the cell B and continues power generation without executing
the subsequent steps in Fig. 12.
[0058] The controller 70 subsequently calculates the V-R characteristic (relation between
cell voltage and resistance) from the I-V characteristic of the cell A (step S340).
Fig. 14 illustrates one example of the calculated V-R characteristic of the cell A.
The controller 70 estimates the resistance value of the short circuit area SC in the
cell B, based on the corrected open circuit voltage Vc of the cell B and the V-R characteristic
of the cell A (step S350). More specifically, the controller 70 estimates that the
resistance value of the short circuit area SC in the cell B is equal to a resistance
value Rs at the corrected open circuit voltage Vc of the cell B in the V-R characteristic
of the cell A (Fig. 14).
[0059] Figs. 15A and 15B illustrate the theoretical basis of the method of estimating the
resistance value of the short circuit area SC in the cell B. The measurement of the
I-V characteristic of the cell A (see Fig. 13) measures the voltage value and the
current value with varying the resistance of the load as shown in Fig. 15A. The V-R
characteristic of the cell A is changeable from the I-V characteristic of the cell
A according to the relationship of V = I·R and is thus also based on the measurement
shown in Fig. 15A. The corrected open circuit voltage Vc of the cell B, on the other
hand, represents the voltage applied in the short circuit area SC at no load as shown
in Fig. 15B. The circuit shown in Fig. 15A is identical with the circuit shown in
Fig. 15B. The resistance value of the short circuit area SC in the cell B can thus
be estimated to be equal to the resistance value in the V-R characteristic of the
cell A corresponding to the corrected open circuit voltage Vc of the cell B.
[0060] When it is determined at step S310 in Fig. 12 that there are a plurality of cells
21 having the reduced OCV, the processing of steps S320 to S350 is repeated for each
of the plurality of cells 21 to estimate the resistance value of the short circuit
area SC in each of the cells 21.
[0061] When the resistance value of the short circuit area SC in the cell B is reacquired
by estimation, the second example also updates the threshold values V1 and V2 (sets
new threshold values V1 and V2) based on the reacquired or estimated resistance value
(step S130 in Fig. 2). This enables the threshold values V1 and V2 to be adequately
set by taking into account the time change in resistance value of the short circuit
area SC in the cell 21 and effectively prevents a pinhole from being made in the electrolyte
membrane.
[0062] According to the first example described above, the same method as any of the methods
of measuring the initial short circuit resistance may be employed to reacquire the
resistance value of the short circuit area SC in the cell 21 (step S150 in Fig. 2)
at the predetermined timing after shipment. One of the available methods measures
the voltage value and the current value by applying a voltage to the cell 21 with
supplying hydrogen gas to the anode AE and an inert gas to the cathode CE and calculates
the resistance of the short circuit area SC from the measurement values. The other
of the available methods measures the voltage value and the current value by applying
a voltage between the two electrodes with supplying the same type of gas (either hydrogen
gas or the air) to both the anode AE and the cathode CE and calculates the resistance
of the short circuit area SC from the measurement values. Employing the method using
the inert gas to reacquire the resistance value of the short circuit area SC, however,
requires the fuel cell system 20 to have an inert gas supply system (e.g., tank for
storing the inert gas) that is not needed for the operation itself of the fuel cell
system 20 and also requires an additional step of fully replacing the atmosphere of
the cathode CE with the inert gas. This undesirably complicates the system configuration
and the control procedure. Employing the method supplying hydrogen gas to the two
electrodes, i.e., both the anode AE and the cathode CE to reacquire the resistance
value of the short circuit area SC requires an additional step of fully replacing
the atmosphere of the cathode CE with hydrogen gas and an additional piping provided
to supply the hydrogen gas to the cathode CE. This also undesirably complicates the
system configuration and the control procedure. The same is true when the method supplying
the air to the two electrodes is employed. The second example, on the other hand,
estimate the amount of voltage drop due to the cross leakage CL based on the comparison
between the I-V characteristics of the cell B having the reduced OCV from the initial
value and the cell A having the unchanged OCV, and estimates the resistance value
of the short circuit area SC in the cell B based on the V-R characteristic calculated
from the I-V characteristic of the cell A and the open circuit voltage of the cell
B corrected with the amount of voltage drop due to the cross leakage CL. This does
not require using the inert gas or supplying the same type of gas to the two electrodes
to reacquire the resistance value of the short circuit area SC. The fuel cell system
20 of the second example thus effectively prevents a pinhole from being made in the
electrolyte membrane of the fuel cell 22, while reducing the complexity of the system
configuration and the control procedure.
[0063] According to the second example, the amount of cell voltage drop can be divided into
the amount of voltage drop due to the cross leakage CL and the amount of voltage drop
due to the decreased resistance value of the short circuit area SC. The occurrence
of a pinhole in the electrolyte membrane is ascribed not to the cross leakage CL but
to the decreased resistance value of the short circuit area SC. The second example
obtains the amount of drop of the open circuit voltage OCV due to the decreased resistance
value of the short circuit area SC, which may cause a pinhole in the electrolyte membrane,
and determines whether the resistance value of the short circuit area SC in the cell
B is to be reacquired. The second example sets the voltage threshold values V1 and
V2 by taking into account only the drop of cell voltage due to the decreased resistance
value of the short circuit area SC. This enables a wider allowable range of the voltage
of the fuel cell 22 and prevents deterioration of drivability.
B-2. Modifications of Second Example
[0064] Fig. 16 is a flowchart showing the flow of reacquisition of the resistance value
of the short circuit area SC (step S150 in Fig. 2) according to a first modification
of the second example. The first modification of the second example shown in Fig.
16 uses the recorded initial characteristic, instead of the characteristic of the
cell 21 having the unchanged OCV from the initial value (cell A) used in the second
example described above (Fig. 12). In the modification shown in Fig. 16, the I-V characteristic
of the cell 21 is recorded before shipment (initial I-V characteristic). The controller
70 calculates the V-R characteristic (initial V-R characteristic) from the recorded
initial I-V characteristic (step S302). The initial characteristic may be recorded
for each cell 21. Alternatively the initial characteristic may be recorded only for
one representative cell 21, since the respective cells 21 of the fuel cell 22 have
identical configuration and specification.
[0065] The control flow subsequently determines whether there is any cell 21 having the
reduced OCV from the initial value (step S310). When it is determined that there is
any cell 21 having the reduced OCV, the control flow measures the I-V characteristic
of the cell B having the reduced OCV, compares the measured I-V characteristic with
the initial I-V characteristic and estimates the amount of voltage drop due to the
cross leakage CL (step S322). The control flow subsequently calculates the OCV of
the cell B corrected with the amount of voltage drop due to the cross leakage CL (corrected
open circuit voltage Vc) (step S332) and estimates the resistance value of the short
circuit area SC in the cell B, based on the corrected open circuit voltage Vc of the
cell B and the initial V-R characteristic (step S352).
[0066] The modification shown in Fig. 16 can estimate the resistance value of the short
circuit area SC in the cell B by using the recorded initial characteristic, even when
there is no cell 21 having the unchanged OCV from the initial value. This effectively
prevents a pinhole from being made in the electrolyte membrane of the fuel cell 22,
while reducing the complexity of the system configuration and the control procedure.
[0067] Fig. 17 is a flowchart showing the flow of reacquisition of the resistance value
of the short circuit area SC (step S150 in Fig. 2) according to a second modification
of the second example. Like the modification shown in Fig. 16, the second modification
of the second example shown in Fig. 17 records the initial I-V characteristic of the
cell 21 and calculates the initial V-R characteristic from the recorded initial I-V
characteristic (step S302) and determines whether there is any cell 21 having the
reduced OCV from the initial value (step S310). When it is determined that there is
any cell 21 having the reduced OCV, the modified control flow subsequently determines
whether there is any cell 21 having the unchanged OCV from the initial value (step
S312). When it is determined that there is any cell 21 having the unchanged OCV from
the initial value, the modified control flow makes a comparison between the cell 21
having the unchanged OCV (cell A) and the cell 21 having the reduced OCV (cell B)
and estimates the resistance value of the short circuit area SC in the cell B (steps
S320 to S350), in the same manner as the second example shown in Fig. 12. When it
is determined that there is no cell 21 having the unchanged OCV from the initial value,
on the other hand, the modified control flow makes a comparison between the recorded
initial characteristic and the cell B having the reduced OCV and estimates the resistance
value of the short circuit area SC in the cell B (steps S322 to S352), in the same
manner as the first modification of the second example shown in Fig. 16.
[0068] During power generation in the fuel cell system 20, there may be a change in I-V
characteristic due to performance degradation by another cause (for example, degradation
of catalyst), in addition to the change in I-V characteristic due to the short circuit
in each cell 21 and due to the cross leakage CL. The change of the I-V characteristic
due to such performance degradation is assumed to be substantially uniform in the
respective cells 21 of the fuel cell 22. It is accordingly expected that the method
of estimating the resistance value of the short circuit area SC based on the comparison
between the cell A having the unchanged OCV from the initial value and the cell B
having the reduced OCV according to the second example shown in Fig. 12 is less susceptible
to error accompanied by the change of the I-V characteristic due to the performance
degradation and thereby has the higher accuracy of estimation, compared with the method
of estimating the resistance value of the short circuit area SC based on the comparison
between the initial characteristic and the cell B having the reduced OCV according
to the first modification of the second example shown in Fig. 16. The second modification
of the second example shown in Fig. 17 employs the estimation method of the higher
accuracy (i.e., the method of the second example) when there is any cell 21 having
the unchanged OCV from the initial value and the method of the second example is accordingly
allowed, while employing the method of the first modification of the second example
when there is no cell 21 having the unchanged OCV from the initial value and the method
of the second example is accordingly not allowed. The second modification of the second
example shown in Fig. 17 can thus deal with diverse situations and improve the estimation
accuracy of the resistance value of the short circuit area SC as much as possible.
[0069] In the second modification of the second example shown in Fig. 17, when it is determined
that there is no cell 21 having the unchanged OCV from the initial value, the control
flow may further be modified to stop the operations of the electric vehicle 10 and
the fuel cell system 20 and measure the resistance value of the short circuit area
SC by the same method as any of the methods of measuring the initial short circuit
resistance described above.
[0070] Fig. 18 is a flowchart showing the flow of reacquisition of the resistance value
of the short circuit area SC (step S150 in Fig. 2) according to a third modification
of the second example. The third modification of the second example shown in Fig.
18 differs from the second modification of the second example shown in Fig. 17 by
an additional step of estimating the I-V characteristic after performance degradation
based on the recorded initial characteristic and the power generation record (step
S314) when it is determined that there is no cell 21 having the unchanged OCV from
the initial value (step S312: No). The I-V characteristic after performance degradation
may be estimated by any of known methods described in, for example,
JP 2006-139935,
H. A. Gasteiger et al., J. Electrochem. Soc., Vol. 152, pages A2256-A2271 (2005),
R. M. Darling and J.P. Meyers, J. Electrochem. Soc., Vol. 150, pages A1523-A1527 (2003), and
W. Bi and T. F. Fuller, J. Power Sources, Vol. 178, pages 188-196 (2008). After estimating the I-V characteristic after performance degradation, the control
flow makes a comparison between the estimated I-V characteristic after performance
degradation and the I-V characteristic of the cell B having the reduced OCV and estimates
the resistance value of the short circuit area SC in the cell B (steps S322 to S352),
in the same manner as the second modification of the second example shown in Fig.
17.
[0071] Even when there is no cell 21 having the unchanged OCV from the initial value and
the high-accuracy method of the second example is accordingly not allowed, the third
modification of the second example shown in Fig. 18 estimates the I-V characteristic
after performance degradation based on the initial characteristic and the power generation
record, and estimates the resistance value of the short circuit area SC in the cell
B based on the estimated I-V characteristic after performance degradation. This improves
the estimation accuracy of the resistance value of the short circuit area SC.
C. First Embodiment
C-1. Reacquisition of Resistance Value of Short Circuit Area
[0072] Fig. 19 is a flowchart showing the flow of reacquiring the resistance value of the
short circuit area SC (step S150 in Fig. 2) according to a first embodiment. Like
the second example, the first embodiment estimates and thereby reacquires the resistance
value of the short circuit area SC based on the characteristic of each cell 21 of
the fuel cell 22 at a predetermined timing after shipment of the fuel cell system
20. The difference from the second example is that the first embodiment estimates
the resistance value of the short circuit area SC without measuring the OCV of each
cell 21.
[0073] The controller 70 (Fig. 1) determines whether there is any cell 21 having reduction
of cell voltage during power generation at a predetermined low load (i.e., minimum
current Ib) (hereinafter referred to as "voltage Vb at the minimum current") from
its initial value (step S410). The predetermined minimum current Ib may be any value
greater than 0 and is 0.1 A/cm
2 according to this embodiment. The controller 70 stores an initial value of the voltage
Vb at the minimum current of each cell 21, measures the voltage Vb at the minimum
current of each cell 21 and makes a comparison between the stored initial value and
the measured voltage Vb at the minimum current for this determination. In general,
like the reduction of the OCV, the reduction of the voltage Vb at the minimum current
is caused by both the reduced resistance value of the short circuit area SC and the
cross leakage CL. When it is determined that there is no cell 21 having the reduced
voltage Vb at the minimum current, the controller 70 detects the absence of any cell
21 having the decreased resistance value of the short circuit area SC and continues
operations without resetting the threshold values V1 and V2 (step S130 in Fig. 2).
[0074] When it is determined at step S410 that there is any cell 21 having the reduced voltage
Vb at the minimum current from the initial value, the controller 70 measures the I-V
characteristic of the cell 21 having the reduced voltage Vb at the minimum current
(hereinafter also referred to as cell F) and the I-V characteristic of the cell 21
having the unchanged voltage Vb at the minimum current (hereinafter also referred
to as cell E), makes a comparison between these two I-V characteristics and estimates
the amount of voltage drop due to the cross leakage CL (step S420). Figs. 20A and
20B illustrate one example of measurement results of the I-V characteristic of the
cell 21. Fig. 20A shows the measurement results of the I-V characteristic of the cell
E having the unchanged voltage Vb at the minimum current and the I-V characteristic
of the cell F having the reduced voltage Vb at the minimum current. Fig. 20B is the
close-up view of an X1 part of Fig. 20A. The amount of voltage drop due to the cross
leakage CL is estimated by the same method as that of the first example shown in Fig.
13. More specifically, the voltage difference at a specified high load (for example,
at the electric current of 1.0 A/cm
2) between the two I-V characteristics is estimated as the amount of voltage drop due
to the cross leakage CL.
[0075] The controller 70 subsequently calculates the I-V characteristic of the cell F corrected
with the amount of voltage drop due to the cross leakage CL (step S430). Figs. 20A
and 20B also show the I-V characteristic of the cell F corrected with the amount of
voltage drop due to the cross leakage CL (i.e., I-V characteristic of the cell F assumed
to have no voltage drop due to the cross leakage CL). The corrected I-V characteristic
of the cell F is obtained by entirely increasing the uncorrected I-V characteristic
of the cell F by the amount of voltage drop due to the cross leakage CL. When the
calculated corrected voltage Vb at the minimum current of the cell F is equal to the
voltage Vb at the minimum current of the cell A, it is thought that the reduction
of the voltage Vb at the minimum current is ascribed to only the cross leakage CL.
The control flow accordingly has no need to reacquire the resistance value of the
short circuit area SC in the cell F and continues power generation without executing
the subsequent steps in Fig. 19.
[0076] The controller 70 subsequently estimates the current Is flowing through the short
circuit area SC in the cell F, based on the I-V characteristic of the cell E and the
corrected I-V characteristic of the cell F (step S440). The minimum current Ib is
a preset value, and the corrected voltage Vb at the minimum current of the cell F
is calculable from the corrected I-V characteristic of the cell F. The controller
70 calculates the current Ik in the I-V characteristic of the cell E corresponding
to the corrected voltage Vb at the minimum current of the cell F and estimates the
difference between the current Ik and the minimum current Ib as the current Is flowing
through the short circuit area SC as shown in Fig. 20B.
[0077] Fig. 21 illustrates a method of estimating the current Is of the short circuit area
SC. Fig. 21 shows a circuit structure including a cell E without the short circuit
area SC, a cell F with the short circuit area SC and a load. When the I-V characteristic
of the cell F without the short circuit area SC is assumed to be identical with the
I-V characteristic of the cell E, the cell F is required to generate electric power
to meet the current Is flowing through the short circuit area SC inside the cell F
in addition to the current Ib flowing through the load. It is accordingly expected
that the voltage Vb at the minimum current of the cell F is less than the voltage
Vb at the minimum current of the cell E. The inherent I-V characteristic of the cell
F is identical with the I-V characteristic of the cell E, so that the cell F is expected
to make the electric current in the I-V characteristic of the cell E corresponding
to the voltage Vb at the minimum current. The current Is of the short circuit area
SC is accordingly estimable to be equal to the difference by subtracting the minimum
current Ib from the current Ik in the I-V characteristic of the cell E corresponding
to the voltage Vb at the minimum current of the cell F as shown in Fig. 20B.
[0078] The controller 70 then calculates the resistance value of the short circuit area
SC from the corrected voltage Vb at the minimum current of the cell F and the estimated
current Is of the short circuit area SC (step S450). When it is determined at step
S410 in Fig. 19 that there are a plurality of cells 21 having the reduced voltage
Vb at the minimum current, the processing of steps S420 to S450 is repeated for each
of the plurality of cells 21 to estimate the resistance value of the short circuit
area SC in each of the cells 21.
[0079] When the resistance value of the short circuit area SC in the cell F is reacquired
by estimation, the first embodiment also updates the threshold values V1 and V2 (sets
new threshold values V1 and V2) based on the reacquired or estimated resistance value
(step S130 in Fig. 2). This enables the threshold values V1 and V2 to be adequately
set by taking into account the time change in resistance value of the short circuit
area SC in the cell 21 and effectively prevents a pinhole from being made in the electrolyte
membrane.
[0080] The second example described above measures the OCV of each cell 21 for estimating
the resistance of the short circuit area SC. For the improved durability of the fuel
cell 22, however, it is preferable to avoid application of the OCV and drive the fuel
cell 22 at no load. The first embodiment does not require measurement of the OCV of
each cell 21 for estimating the resistance value of the short circuit area SC. This
effectively prevents a pinhole from being made in the electrolyte membrane of the
fuel cell 22, while improving the durability of the fuel cell 22.
C-2. Modifications of First Embodiment
[0081] Fig. 22 is a flowchart showing the flow of reacquisition of the resistance value
of the short circuit area SC (step S150 in Fig. 2) according to a first modification
of the first embodiment. The first modification of the first embodiment shown in Fig.
22 records the I-V characteristic of the cell 21 before shipment (initial I-V characteristic)
(step S402) and determines whether there is any cell 21 having the reduced voltage
Vb at the minimum current from the initial value (step S410). When it is determined
that there is any cell 21 having the reduced voltage Vb at the minimum current, the
control flow subsequently determines whether there is any cell 21 having the unchanged
voltage Vb at the minimum current from the initial value (step S412). When it is determined
that there is no cell 21 having the unchanged voltage Vb at the minimum current from
the initial value, the control flow makes a comparison between the cell F having the
reduced voltage Vb at the minimum current and the recorded initial I-V characteristic,
instead of the I-V characteristic of the cell 21 having the unchanged voltage Vb at
the minimum current (cell E) used in the first embodiment described above (Fig. 19),
and thereby estimates the resistance value of the short circuit area SC in the cell
F (steps S460 to S490). When it is determined that there is any cell 21 having the
unchanged voltage Vb at the minimum current from the initial value, on the other hand,
the control flow makes a comparison between the cell 21 having the unchanged voltage
Vb at the minimum current (cell E) and the cell 21 having the reduced voltage Vb at
the minimum current (cell F) and thereby estimates the resistance value of the short
circuit area SC in the cell F (steps S420 to S450), in the same manner as the first
embodiment shown in Fig. 19.
[0082] The modified control flow shown in Fig. 22 employs the estimation method of the higher
accuracy (i.e., the method of the first embodiment) when there is any cell 21 having
the unchanged voltage Vb at the minimum current from the initial value and the method
of the first embodiment is accordingly allowed. Even when there is no cell 21 having
the unchanged voltage Vb at the minimum current, this modified control flow uses the
initial I-V characteristic to estimate the resistance value of the short circuit area
SC in the cell F. This enables control of the fuel cell 22 to effectively prevent
a pinhole from being made in the electrolyte membrane of the fuel cell 22 and reduce
the complexity of the system configuration and the control procedure. This can also
deal with diverse situations and improve the estimation accuracy of the resistance
value of the short circuit area SC as much as possible.
[0083] Fig. 23 is a flowchart showing the flow of reacquisition of the resistance value
of the short circuit area SC (step S150 in Fig. 2) according to a second modification
of the first embodiment. The second modification of the first embodiment shown in
Fig. 23 differs from the first modification of the first embodiment shown in Fig.
22 by the processing flow when it is determined that there is no cell 21 having the
unchanged voltage Vb at the minimum current from the initial value (step S412: No).
The modified control flow shown in Fig. 23 estimates the I-V characteristic after
performance degradation, based on the recorded initial I-V characteristic and the
power generation record (step S414), when it is determined that there is no cell 21
having the unchanged voltage Vb at the minimum current from the initial value. The
I-V characteristic after power degradation may be estimated by any of the known methods
mentioned above. After estimating the I-V characteristic after performance degradation,
the modified control flow makes a comparison between the estimated I-V characteristic
after performance degradation and the I-V characteristic of the cell F having the
reduced voltage Vb at the minimum current and thereby estimates the resistance value
of the short circuit area SC in the cell F (steps S462 to S492), in a similar manner
to the first modification of the first embodiment shown in Fig. 22.
[0084] Even when there is no cell 21 having the unchanged voltage Vb at the minimum current
from the initial value and the high-accuracy method of the first embodiment is accordingly
not allowed, the second modification of the first embodiment shown in Fig. 23 estimates
the I-V characteristic after performance degradation based on the initial I-V characteristic
and the power generation record, and estimates the resistance value of the short circuit
area SC in the cell F based on the estimated I-V characteristic after performance
degradation. This improves the estimation accuracy of the resistance value of the
short circuit area SC.
[0085] Fig. 24 is a flowchart showing the flow of reacquisition of the resistance value
of the short circuit area SC (step S150 in Fig. 2) according to a third modification
of the first embodiment. The third modification of the first embodiment shown in Fig.
24 differs from the second modification of the first embodiment shown in Fig. 23 by
the processing flow when it is determined that there is no cell 21 having the unchanged
voltage Vb at the minimum current from the initial value (step S412: No). The modified
control flow shown in Fig. 24 measures the resistance value of the short circuit area
SC in the cell 21 (step S464) by the same method as any of the methods of measuring
the initial short circuit resistance described above, when it is determined that there
is no cell 21 having the unchanged voltage Vb at the minimum current from the initial
value. More specifically, the method supplies hydrogen gas to the anode AE and nitrogen
gas to the cathode CE, applies a predetermined voltage (0.2 to 0.5 V) and calculates
the resistance value of the short circuit area SC from the current values at the respective
voltage values.
[0086] The control flow subsequently sets the cell 21 having the minimum resistance value
of the short circuit area SC to a reference cell, makes a comparison between the I-V
characteristic of the reference cell and the I-V characteristic of the cell of interest
(cell F) as an object of estimation of the resistance value of the short circuit area
SC and estimates the amount of voltage drop due to the cross leakage CL (step S474).
The control flow then estimates the current Is flowing through the short circuit area
SC in the cell F, based on the I-V characteristic of the reference cell, the I-V characteristic
of the cell F corrected with the amount of voltage drop due to the cross leakage CL,
and the short circuit resistance of the reference cell (step S484). More specifically,
as shown in Fig. 25, the control flow estimates electric current Is1 flowing through
the short circuit area SC based on the resistance value of the short circuit area
SC of the reference cell and the voltage Vb at the minimum current by the same method
as that of the first embodiment shown in Fig. 20B, and estimates current Is2 flowing
through the short circuit area SC in the cell F based on the estimated current Is1.
The control flow subsequently calculates the resistance value of the short circuit
area SC from the corrected voltage Vb at the minimum current of the cell F and the
estimated current Is2 of the short circuit area SC (step S494).
[0087] Even when there is no cell 21 having the unchanged voltage Vb at the minimum current
from the initial value, the third modification of the first embodiment shown in Fig.
24 estimates the resistance value of the short circuit area SC in the cell F based
on the I-V characteristic of the reference cell, which is subjected to measurement
of the resistance value of the short circuit area SC. This improves the estimation
accuracy of the resistance value of the short circuit area SC.
D. Second Embodiment
[0088] Figs. 26 and 27 illustrate one example of voltage threshold values during control
of the fuel cell 22 according to a second embodiment. In the first and second examples
and the first embodiment, the voltage threshold values are set from the viewpoint
of preventing a pinhole from being made in the electrolyte membrane ME. The voltage
threshold values during control of the fuel cell 22 may be set from another viewpoint
of preventing performance degradation of the fuel cell 22. The second embodiment controls
the fuel cell 22 using a plurality of voltage threshold values set from a plurality
of different viewpoints.
[0089] Fig. 26 shows upper threshold limits of voltage during normal power generation (i.e.,
power generation at the cell voltage of or above 0 V). A threshold value Vt2 shown
in Fig. 26 represents an upper threshold limit of voltage set from the viewpoint of
preventing a pinhole from being made in the electrolyte membrane ME (see Fig. 9).
A threshold value Vt1 represents an upper threshold limit of voltage set from the
viewpoint of avoiding the OCV for the purpose of the improved durability of the fuel
cell 22. The control of the fuel cell 22 according to the second embodiment actually
uses the safety threshold value, i.e., the smaller threshold value, between the two
upper threshold limits set from the two different viewpoints. The illustrated example
of Fig. 26 uses the threshold value Vt2 when the resistance value of the short circuit
area SC in the cell 21 is not less than a value Ra, while using the threshold value
Vt1 when the resistance value is greater than the value Ra.
[0090] Fig. 27 shows lower threshold limits of voltage during power generation at negative
voltage (i.e., power generation at the cell voltage below 0 V) of the cell 21 having
a resistance value Rb of the short circuit area SC. A threshold value Vt4 shown in
Fig. 27 represents a lower threshold limit of voltage set from the viewpoint of preventing
a pinhole from being made in the electrolyte membrane ME. Fig. 28 illustrates one
exemplary method of setting the threshold value Vt4. As shown in Fig. 28, the threshold
value Vt4 corresponds to the resistance value Rb in the threshold value distribution
against the resistance value of the short circuit area SC (see Fig. 8) set from the
viewpoint of preventing a pinhole from being made in the electrolyte membrane ME.
A threshold value Vt3 represents a lower threshold limit of voltage at each cell temperature
set from the viewpoint of avoiding hydrogen deficiency as described in
JP 2008-277044. The control of the fuel cell 22 according to the second embodiment actually uses
the safety threshold value, i.e., the greater threshold value, between the two lower
threshold limits set from the two different viewpoints. The illustrated example of
Fig. 27 uses the threshold value Vt3 at the cell temperature of or above -20°C and
at the cell temperature of or below -30°C in combination with the current density
of or below Ia, while using the threshold value Vt4 at the cell temperature of or
below -30°C in combination with the current density above Ia.
[0091] Fig. 29 is a flowchart showing the flow of operation control of the fuel cell 22
(step S140 in Fig. 2) according to the second embodiment. Fig. 29 shows the flow of
operation control under the conditions that the resistance value of the short circuit
area SC in the cell 21 is equal to 1.0 megaohm·cm
2 and the cell temperature is equal to -30°C. The control flow starts power generation
by the fuel cell 22 (step S510) and measures the voltage of each cell 21 at a predetermined
timing (step S520). When the cell voltage of the cell 21 is equal to or greater than
0V (step S530: Yes), the control flow determines whether the cell voltage is greater
than the threshold value Vt1 (step S580) according to the map of Fig. 26. When the
cell voltage is not greater than the threshold value Vt1 (step S580: No), the control
flow continues power generation. When the cell voltage is greater than the threshold
value Vt1 (step S580: Yes), on the other hand, the control flow performs control to
decrease the cell voltage (step S590). This prevents a pinhole from being made in
the electrolyte membrane ME during normal power generation, while avoiding the OCV
and improving the durability of the fuel cell 22.
[0092] When the cell voltage of the cell 21 is less than 0 V (step S530: No), on the other
hand, the control flow subsequently determines whether the current density is less
than Ia (step S540) according to the map of Fig. 27. When the current density is less
than Ia, the control flow subsequently determines whether the cell voltage is less
than the threshold value Vt3 (step S550). When the current density is not less than
Ia, on the other hand, the control flow subsequently determines whether the cell voltage
is less than the threshold value Vt4 (step S560). When the cell voltage is not less
than the threshold value Vt3 (step S550: No) or when the cell voltage is not less
than the threshold value Vt4 (step S560: No), the control flow continues power generation.
When the cell voltage is less than the threshold value Vt3 (step S550: Yes) or when
the cell voltage is less than the threshold value Vt4 (step S560: Yes), on the other
hand, the control flow performs control to increase the cell voltage (step S570).
This prevents a pinhole from being made in the electrolyte membrane ME during power
generation at negative voltage, while avoiding hydrogen deficiency.
[0093] As described above, the second embodiment takes into account the voltage threshold
values set from the viewpoint of preventing a pinhole from being made in the electrolyte
membrane ME and the voltage threshold values set from different viewpoints and controls
the fuel cell 22 with the most safety threshold values. More specifically, the fuel
cell 22 is controlled, such that the voltage value of the cell 21 is within the range
defined by the voltage threshold values set from the viewpoint of preventing a pinhole
from being made in the electrolyte membrane ME and within the range defined by the
voltage threshold values set from the different viewpoints. The second embodiment
accordingly enables control of the fuel cell 22 with higher robustness, while effectively
preventing a pinhole from being made in the electrolyte membrane of the fuel cell
22. The second embodiment also efficiently avoids potential degradation or deterioration
of the fuel cell 22 in a plurality of deterioration modes.
F. Modifications
[0094] The invention is not limited to the above embodiments or modifications, but a multiplicity
of variations and modifications may be made to the embodiments. A possible modification
is described below.
[0095] The above embodiments describe the electric vehicle 10 having the fuel cell system
20. The invention is, however, not limited to the fuel cell system 20 for the electric
vehicle 10 but is also applicable to the fuel cell system 20 for other purposes. The
configurations of the electric vehicle 10 and the fuel cell system 20 described in
the above embodiments are only illustrative and may be modified, altered or changed
in various ways.