INTRODUCTION
[0001] Therapeutic chemical entities are often undesirably removed from an animal's circulatory
system by first-pass metabolism in the liver. If a chemical entity is taken up by
hepatocytes and excreted in bile via the bile canaliculi the chemical entity will
never reach its therapeutic target. Transport proteins endogenous to hepatocytes are
responsible for moving substrates across the sinusoidal membrane of the hepatocytes
and then into bile canaliculi. Bile canaliculi are structures within liver tissue
that receive excreted components from the hepatocytes and transport the bile to a
common bile duct for removal from the animal. Biliary excretion of substrates is thus
a complex process involving translocation across the sinusoidal membrane, movement
through the cytoplasm, and transport across the canalicular membrane.
[0002] Understanding that hepatobiliary excretion of parent drugs or their metabolites often
play a significant role in the overall clearance of a drug has forced the pharmaceutical
industry to explore better in-vitro tools for predicting this avenue of clearance.
For this reason an important determinate of the suitability of a chemical entity for
use as a pharmaceutical is both the degree to which it is subject to biliary excretion
and the effect it has on biliary excretion of other chemical entities.
[0003] The art has taught two general types of in vitro assays for biliary clearance of
a chemical entity. The first assay type is a two-culture assay format that utilizes
two parallel cultures of hepatocytes. (
BI, Yi-an, et al., "Use of cryopreserved human hepatocytes in sandwich culture to
measure hepatobiliary transport," Drug Metab Dispos., Vol. 34, No. 9, pp. 1658-65
(2006);
ANSEDE, John H., et al., "An In Vitro Assay to Assess Transporter-Based Cholestatic
Hepatotoxicity Using Sandwich-Cultured Rat Hepatocytes," Drug metabolism and Disposition,
Vol. 38, pp. 276-280 (2010).) In the first culture hepatocytes are exposed to normal culture media and form
and maintain canaliculi. In the second culture hepatocytes are exposed to culture
media designed to disrupt canaliculi, such as culture media that is calcium and magnesium
free. A chemical entity is then exposed to each culture and allowed to interact with
the hepatocytes for a culture period. Then the cultures are washed and the amount
of chemical entity associated with the cells in each culture is assessed. In the first
culture chemical entity associated with the cells may be localized in the cell cytoplasm
or present in canaliculi following biliary excretion. In the second culture there
are no intact canaliculi so any chemical entity associated with the cells must be
present in the cytoplasm. By suntracting the amount of chemical entity present in
the cytoplasm (second culture) from the amount of chemical entity present in the cytoplasm
and the canaliculi (first culture) it is possible to determine the amount of chemical
entity excreted in the bile of the first cell culture.
[0004] The two-culture assay format has several drawbacks. A first drawback is the simple
reality that creating a single biliary excretion data point using this assay format
requires two cultures of primary hepatocytes. Primary hepatocytes are difficult to
procure and therefore are very expensive. Thus, there is a need in the art for methods
of characterizing biliary excretion of chemical entities using fewer primary hepatocytes.
Clearly, a one culture method will achieve a 50% reduction in the number of primary
hepatocytes needed for the assay and is, therefore, very desirable. A second drawback
is that biliary accumulation of a chemical entity is necessarily calculated in a two-culture
assay format by measuring two values that are not biliary accumulation, namely total
cellular accumulation (cytoplasm and bile) and cytoplasmic accumulation, and then
calculating the difference between these values. A measurement made utilizing this
two-culture process will necessarily have more inherent variability than a single,
direct measurement of biliary accumulation. A direct measurement of biliary accumulation
is not possible in the two-culture assay format.
[0005] The art has also taught a single-culture in vitro assays for biliary clearance of
a chemical entity. (
U.S. Patent No. 7,604,934.) However, the previously taught assay is indirect. Specifically, it relies on exposing
a single culture to a marker compound (such as a radiolabeled compound) and comparing
biliary accumulation of the radioactive marker in the presence and absence of a test
chemical entity. Such assays assume that a drop in biliary accumulation of the marker
in the presence of the test chemical entity indicates that the test chemical entity
is excreted by a pathway similar to that used by the marker compound. This assay format
has several drawbacks including low accuracy.
[0006] For all of the above reasons and others there is a need in the art for new and efficient
methods of assessing the biliary excretion of chemical entities such as candidate
therapeutic agents. This invention provides new and nonobvious methods that meet these
and other needs.
SUMMARY
[0007] This invention provides new and improved in vitro methods of characterizing biliary
excretion of a chemical entity. In a first aspect, the methods comprise a) providing
cell culture comprising hepatocytes forming at least one bile canaliculus; b) contacting
the cell culture with a first chemical entity for a time sufficient to allow uptake
of the chemical entity by hepatocytes in the culture; c) disrupting the at least one
bile canaliculus without lysing the hepatocytes and detecting the amount (if any)
of the first chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released by the at least
one bile canaliculus; and d) lysing the hepatocytes and detecting the amount of the
first chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released by the hepatocytes. In
some embodiments at least one wash step is included between steps a) and b), between
steps b) and c), and/or between steps c) and d).
[0008] One feature of the disclosed methods is that biliary accumulation of a chemical entity
and cytoplasmic accumulation of the chemical entity are both measured using a single
hepatocyte culture, such as a single well of the tissue culture plate. Surprisingly,
and as discussed below and demonstrated in the examples, this assay format is highly
accurate and reproducible.
[0009] In some embodiments of the methods the cell culture is a hepatocyte-stromal cell
coculture comprising hepatocytes and stromal cells disposed on a surface of a solid
substrate.
[0010] In some embodiments of the methods the amount of the first chemical entity and/or
a metabolite thereof released by the at least one bile canaliculus in step c) is higher
than the amount of the first chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released
by the hepatocytes in step d).
[0011] In some embodiments of the methods the amount of the first chemical entity and/or
a metabolite thereof released by the at least one bile canaliculus in step c) is lower
than the amount of the first chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released
by the hepatocytes in step d).
[0012] In some embodiments of the methods the amount of the first chemical entity and/or
a metabolite thereof in steps c) and/or d) is detected using LC-MS/MS.
[0013] In some embodiments of the methods the first chemical entity does not comprise a
label.
[0014] In some embodiments of the methods the at least one bile canaliculus is disrupted
without lysing hepatocytes in the culture by incubating the culture in media comprising
latrunculin A (LatA) and/or not comprising calcium.
[0015] In some embodiments the methods further comprise determining the intrinsic biliary
clearance (CL
bile) and/or the biliary excretion index (BEI) for the first chemical entity in the cell
culture.
[0016] In some embodiments the methods further comprise determining the intrinsic biliary
clearance (CL
bile) and/or the biliary excretion index (BEI) for the first chemical entity in the cell
culture; and further comprise comparing the CL
bile and/or BEI of the first chemical entity to the CL
bile and/or BEI of a control chemical entity and characterizing the biliary excretion
of the first chemical entity based on the comparison.
[0017] In some embodiments of the methods the activity of at least one hepatocyte transport
protein is inhibited in the hepatocytes.
[0018] In some embodiments the methods further comprise contacting the cell culture with
a second chemical entity in step b).
[0019] In some embodiments the methods further comprise contacting the cell culture with
a second chemical entity in step b); and the methods, further comprise detecting the
amount of the second chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released by the at
least one bile canaliculus in step c).
[0020] In some embodiments the methods further comprise contacting the cell culture with
a second chemical entity in step b); and the methods, further comprise detecting the
amount of the second chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released by the at
least one bile canaliculus in step c); and the methods further comprise detecting
the amount of the second chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released by the
hepatocytes in step d).
[0021] In a second aspect, the methods comprise a) providing a first cell culture comprising
hepatocytes forming at least one bile canaliculus, wherein the activity of at least
one hepatocyte transport protein is inhibited in the hepatocytes of the first cell
culture; b) contacting the first cell culture with a first chemical entity; c) disrupting
the at least one bile canaliculus in the first cell culture without lysing the hepatocytes
in the first cell culture and detecting the amount (if any) of the first chemical
entity and/or a metabolite thereof released by the at least one bile canaliculus;
d) lysing the hepatocytes in the first cell culture and detecting the amount of the
first chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released by the hepatocytes; e)
providing a second cell culture comprising hepatocytes forming at least one bile canaliculus,
wherein the activity of the at least one hepatocyte transport protein is not inhibited
in the hepatocytes of the second cell culture; f) contacting the second cell culture
with the first chemical entity; g) disrupting the at least one bile canaliculus in
the second cell culture without lysing the hepatocytes in the second cell culture
and detecting the amount (if any) of the first chemical entity and/or a metabolite
thereof released by the at least one bile canaliculus; and h) lysing the hepatocytes
in the second cell culture and detecting the amount of the first chemical entity and/or
a metabolite thereof released by the hepatocytes. In some embodiments at least one
wash step is included between steps a) and b), between steps b) and c), and/or between
steps c) and d). In some embodiments at least one wash step is included between steps
e) and f), between steps f) and g), and/or between steps g) and h).
[0022] In some embodiments of the methods the first and second cell cultures are hepatocyte-stromal
cell cocultures comprising hepatocytes and stromal cells disposed on a surface of
a solid substrate.
[0023] In some embodiments the methods further comprise determining the CL
bile and/or BEI for the first chemical entity in the first cell culture and determining
the CL
bile and/or BEI for the first chemical entity in the second cell culture.
[0024] In some embodiments the methods further comprise determining the CL
bile and/or BEI for the first chemical entity in the first cell culture and determining
the CL
bile and/or BEI for the first chemical entity in the second cell culture; and the CL
bile and/or BEI for the first chemical entity is lower in the first cell culture than
in the second cell culture, indicating that biliary clearance of the first chemical
entity is mediated at least on part by the at least one hepatocyte transport protein.
[0025] In some embodiments the methods further comprise determining the CL
bile and/or BEI for the first chemical entity in the first cell culture and determining
the CL
bile and/or BEI for the first chemical entity in the second cell culture; and the CL
bile and/or BEI for the first chemical entity is not lower in the first cell culture than
in the second cell culture, indicating that biliary clearance of the first chemical
entity is not mediated at least on part by the at least one hepatocyte transport protein.
[0026] In some embodiments of the methods the amount of the first chemical entity and/or
a metabolite thereof in steps c) and/or d) and/or e) and/or h) is detected using LC-MS/MS.
[0027] In some embodiments of the methods the first chemical entity and/or a metabolite
thereof in steps b) and/or f) does not comprise a label.
[0028] In some embodiments of the methods the at least one bile canaliculus is disrupted
in the first and second cell cultures without lysing hepatocytes in the cell cultures
by incubating the cell cultures in media comprising latrunculin A (LatA) and/or not
comprising calcium.
[0029] In some embodiments the methods further comprise contacting the first and/or second
cell cultures with a second chemical entity in steps b) and/or f).
[0030] In some embodiments the methods further comprise contacting the first and/or second
cell cultures with a second chemical entity in steps b) and/or f); and further comprise
detecting the amount of the second chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released
by the at least one bile canaliculus in steps c) and/or g).
[0031] In some embodiments the methods further comprise contacting the first and/or second
cell cultures with a second chemical entity in steps b) and/or f); and further comprise
detecting the amount of the second chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released
by the at least one bile canaliculus in steps c) and/or g); and further comprise detecting
the amount of the second chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released by the
hepatocytes in steps d) and/or h).
[0032] In a third aspect, the methods comprise a) providing a cell culture comprising hepatocytes
forming at least one bile canaliculus; b) simultaneously contacting the cell culture
with a marker chemical entity and a test chemical entity, wherein the marker chemical
entity is a known substrate of at least one hepatocyte transport protein with a determined
CL
bile and/or BEI; c) disrupting the at least one bile canaliculus without lysing the hepatocytes
and detecting the amount of the marker chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof
released by the at least one bile canaliculus; and d) lysing the hepatocytes and detecting
the amount of the marker chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released by the
hepatocytes. In some embodiments at least one wash step is included between steps
a) and b), between steps b) and c), and/or between steps c) and d).
[0033] In some embodiments of the methods the cell culture is a hepatocyte-stromal cell
coculture comprising hepatocytes and stromal cells disposed on a surface of a solid
substrate.
[0034] In some embodiments the methods further comprise determining the CL
bile and/or BEI for the marker chemical entity in the hepatocyte-stromal cell coculture
in the presence of the test chemical entity.
[0035] In some embodiments the methods further comprise determining the CL
bile and/or BEI for the marker chemical entity in the hepatocyte-stromal cell coculture
in the presence of the test chemical entity; and the CL
bile and/or BEI for the marker chemical entity is lower in the presence of the test chemical
entity than in the absence of the test chemical entity, indicating that biliary clearance
of the test chemical entity is mediated at least in part by the at least one least
one hepatocyte transport protein.
[0036] In some embodiments the methods further comprise determining the CL
bile and/or BEI for the marker chemical entity in the hepatocyte-stromal cell coculture
in the presence of the test chemical entity; and the CL
bile and/or BEI for the marker chemical entity is not lower in the presence of the test
chemical entity than in the absence of the test chemical entity, indicating that biliary
clearance of the test chemical entity is not mediated at least in part by the at least
one least one hepatocyte transport protein.
[0037] In some embodiments of the methods the amount of the marker chemical entity and/or
metabolite thereof in steps c) and/or d) is detected using LC-MS/MS.
[0038] In some embodiments of the methods the at least one bile canaliculus is disrupted
in the cell culture without lysing hepatocytes in the cell culture by incubating the
cell culture in media comprising latrunculin A (LatA) and/or not comprising calcium.
[0039] In some embodiments of the methods the activity of at least one hepatocyte transport
protein is inhibited in the hepatocytes of the cell culture.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0040]
Figure 1 shows accumulation of taurocholate in the bile. The graph shows the concentration
of taurocholate obtained from the collection 4 sample which contains only substrate
secreted into the bile. The bars represent samples that were obtained by disrupting
the canaliculus with Ca- buffer or LatA buffer. All concentrations were determined
using LC-MS/MS.
Figure 2 shows accumulation of taurocholate in the cell. The graphs show the concentration
of taurocholate obtained from the collection 5 sample which contains only substrate
accumulated in the cell. The bars represent samples that were obtained after disrupting
the canaliculus with Ca- buffer or LatA buffer in collection 4. All concentrations
were determined using LC-MS/MS.
Figure 3 shows accumulation of taurocholate in the bile after inhibition with CSA. The graphs
show the concentration of taurocholate obtained from the collection 4 sample which
contains only substrate accumulated in the bile after incubation with transporter
inhibitor CSA. The bars represent samples that were obtained after disrupting the
canaliculus with Ca- buffer or LatA buffer or incubation with CSA and disruption with
Ca- buffer in collection 4. All concentrations were determined using LC-MS/MS.
Figure 4 shows biliary uptake of taurocholate by primary human hepatocytes grown in a hepatocyte-stromal
cell coculture. Accumulation in the bile and accumulation in the cell were measured
separately in a single well of a coculture plate. The measured values for bile accumulation
and cell accumulation are shown as separately shaded portions of the bar on the left
side of the graph and compared to the measured bile accumulation shown in the bar
on the right side of the graph. The measured values were used to calculate a BEI of
67% for taurocholate.
Figure 5 shows biliary uptake of estradiol-glucuronide by cultured human hepatocytes. Accumulation
in the bile and accumulation in the cell were measured separately in a single well
of a coculture plate. The measured values for bile accumulation and cell accumulation
are shown as separately shaded portions of the bar on the left side of the graph and
compared to the measured bile accumulation shown in the bar on the right side of the
graph. The measured values were used to calculate a BEI of 40% for estradiol-glucuronide.
Figure 6 shows biliary uptake of digoxin by cultured human hepatocytes. Accumulation in the
bile and accumulation in the cell were measured separately in a single well of a coculture
plate. The measured values for bile accumulation and cell accumulation are shown as
separately shaded portions of the bar on the left side of the graph and compared to
the measured bile accumulation shown in the bar on the right side of the graph. The
measured values were used to calculate a BEI of 41% for digoxin.
Figure 7 shows biliary uptake of rosuvastatin by cultured human hepatocytes. Accumulation
in the bile and accumulation in the cell were measured separately in a single well
of a coculture plate. The measured values for bile accumulation and cell accumulation
are shown as separately shaded portions of the bar on the left side of the graph and
compared to the measured bile accumulation shown in the bar on the right side of the
graph. The measured values were used to calculate a BEI of 52% for rosuvastatin.
Figure 8 shows biliary uptake of pravastatin by cultured human hepatocytes. Accumulation in
the bile and accumulation in the cell were measured separately in a single well of
a coculture plate. The measured values for bile accumulation and cell accumulation
are shown as separately shaded portions of the bar on the left side of the graph and
compared to the measured bile accumulation shown in the bar on the right side of the
graph. The measured values were used to calculate a BEI of 14% for pravastatin.
Figure 9 shows biliary uptake of taurocholate by cultured rat hepatocytes. Accumulation in
the bile and accumulation in the cell were measured separately in a single well of
a coculture plate. The measured values for bile accumulation and cell accumulation
are shown as separately shaded portions of the bar on the left side of the graph and
compared to the measured bile accumulation shown in the bar on the right side of the
graph. The measured values were used to calculate a BEI of 60% for taurocholate.
Figure 10 shows biliary uptake of rosuvastatin by cultured rat hepatocytes. Accumulation in
the bile and accumulation in the cell were measured separately in a single well of
a coculture plate. The measured values for bile accumulation and cell accumulation
are shown as separately shaded portions of the bar on the left side of the graph and
compared to the measured bile accumulation shown in the bar on the right side of the
graph. The measured values were used to calculate a BEI of 72% for rosuvastatin.
Figure 11 shows biliary uptake of estradiol-glucuronide by cultured rat hepatocytes. Accumulation
in the bile and accumulation in the cell were measured separately in a single well
of a coculture plate. The measured values for bile accumulation and cell accumulation
are shown as separately shaded portions of the bar on the left side of the graph and
compared to the measured bile accumulation shown in the bar on the right side of the
graph. The measured values were used to calculate a BEI of 45% for estradiol-glucuronide.
Figure 12 shows biliary uptake of digoxin by cultured rat hepatocytes. Accumulation in the
bile and accumulation in the cell were measured separately in a single well of a coculture
plate. The measured values for bile accumulation and cell accumulation are shown as
separately shaded portions of the bar on the left side of the graph and compared to
the measured bile accumulation shown in the bar on the right side of the graph. The
measured values were used to calculate a BEI of 67% for digoxin.
Figure 13 shows biliary uptake of pravastatin by cultured rat hepatocytes. Accumulation in
the bile and accumulation in the cell were measured separately in a single well of
a coculture plate. The measured values for bile accumulation and cell accumulation
are shown as separately shaded portions of the bar on the left side of the graph and
compared to the measured bile accumulation shown in the bar on the right side of the
graph. The measured values were used to calculate a BEI of 58% for pravastatin.
Figure 14 shows inhibition by cyclosporin A of BSEP-mediated transport of taurocholate. The
data indicate an IC50 value of 0.46 mM in this system.
Figure 15 shows shows inhibition by ritonavir of BCRP-mediated transport of rosuvastatin. The
data indicate an IC50 value of 0.50mM in this system.
Figure 16 shows inhibition by erythromycin-estolate of BSEP-mediated transport of taurocholate
and BCRP-mediated transport of rosuvastatin. BSEP was completely inhibited in this
experiment.
Figure 17 compares the results of three independent experiments measuring biliary uptake of
taurocholate by primary human hepatocytes grown in a hepatocyte-stromal cell coculture.
Accumulation in the bile and accumulation in the cell were measured separately in
a single well of a coculture plate. The measured values for bile accumulation and
cell accumulation are shown as separately shaded portions of a single bar. The error
bars represent a single standard deviation. Analysis of every pairwise combination
of the experiments indicated that the variation in the results is not statistically
significant.
Figure 18 compares the results of three independent experiments measuring biliary uptake of
pravastatin by primary human hepatocytes grown in a hepatocyte-stromal cell coculture.
Accumulation in the bile and accumulation in the cell were measured separately in
a single well of a coculture plate. The measured values for bile accumulation and
cell accumulation are shown as separately shaded portions of a single bar. The error
bars represent a single standard deviation. Analysis of every pairwise combination
of the experiments indicated that the variation in the results is not statistically
significant.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0041] The in vitro methods of this invention utilize cultured hepatocytes that have formed
at least one biliary canaliculus. A feature of the methods is that two different direct
measurements are obtained from a single culture of hepatocytes in the methods of the
invention. First, the amount of a chemical entity excreted into the biliary canaliculi
of the culture is measured directly. Then, the amount of the chemical entity that
is imported into the hepatocyte cytoplasm but not excreted into the biliary canaliculi
is measured directly. The features of direct measurement and use of a single culture
for both measurements distinguish the methods of the invention from prior art methods
and provide several advantages that will be apparent to a skilled artisan in view
of this disclosure.
A. Single Culture Biliary Excretion Assay
[0042] In certain embodiments the methods of this invention comprise a) providing a cell
culture comprising hepatocytes forming at least one bile canaliculus; b) contacting
the cell culture with a first chemical entity for a time sufficient to allow uptake
of the chemical entity by hepatocytes in the culture; c) disrupting the at least one
bile canaliculus without lysing the hepatocytes and detecting the amount (if any)
of the first chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released by the at least
one bile canaliculus; and d) lysing the hepatocytes and detecting the amount of the
first chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released by the hepatocytes. In
some embodiments of the methods at least one wash step is included between steps a)
and b), between steps b) and c), and/or between steps c) and d).
[0043] Typically step b) is performed by diluting a first chemical entity in culture media
and replacing the culture media used in step a) with the media comprising the diluted
first chemical entity. After a time sufficient to allow uptake the culture media of
step b) is removed from the culture. Because the hepatocytes are typically adhered
to a substrate this is typically accomplished using standard tissue culture aspiration
and pipetting techniques or equivalent to remove culture media and then add new media
Of course, a skilled artisan will appreciate that any suitable method may be used.
At this stage of the method the hepatocyte culture may be washed by one or more changes
of culture media that does not comprise the first chemical entity, such as by one
wash, by two washes, or by three washes.
[0044] In some embodiments, following step b) the cell culture comprising hepatocytes forming
at least one bile canaliculus is incubated in fresh media for a culture period and
the culture media is then collected. This culture media may be analyzed for accumulation
of first chemical entity in the culture media. First chemical entity that accumulates
under this culture conditions will have originated form basolateral transport processes
of the hepatocytes and thus inclusion of this step in embodiments of the methods allows
measurement of basolateral transport, biliary accumulation, and cytoplasmic accumulation
of a chemical entity in a single cell culture comprising hepatocytes forming at least
one bile canaliculus.
[0045] In step c) the at least one bile canaliculus is disrupted by any suitable technique
known in the art. An exemplary method is by exchanging the culture media with media
that is calcium free or that is calcium and magnesium free. Incubation in media that
is calcium free or that is calcium and magnesium free disrupts tight junctions and
causes the contents of bile canaliculi to be released into the culture media. Another
exemplary method is by exchanging the culture media for media comprising an effective
concentration of LatA, Incubation in media that comprising an effective concentration
of LatA disrupts tight junctions and causes the contents of bile canaliculi to be
released into the culture media. The detecting in step c) typically is by collecting
the media following disruption of canaliculi and characterization of first chemical
entity present in the collected media. The detection may be qualitative and/or quantitative.
In a preferred embodiment the detection methods comprise use of LC-MS/MS to detect
the first chemical entity. In some embodiments LC-MS/MS is used to measure the amount
of the first chemical entity present in the media following disruption of the at least
one bile canaliculus. In some embodiments the media comprising the material released
from the canaliculi is processed to remove undesirable components using steps that
may include, for example, at least one of filtration, chromatography, centrifugation,
and evaporation.
[0046] In step d) the remaining cells are lysed by any suitable technique known in the art.
An exemplary method is by exposure to deionized water. The detecting in step d) typically
is by collecting the media following lysing of the remaining cells and characterization
of first chemical entity present in the collected media. The detection may be qualitative
and/or quantitative. In a preferred embodiment the detection methods comprise use
of LC-MS/MS to detect the first chemical entity. In some embodiments LC-MS/MS is used
to measure the amount of the first chemical entity present in the media following
cell lysis. In some embodiments the media comprising the material released from the
lysed cells is processed to remove undesirable components using steps that may include,
for example, at least one of filtration, chromatography, centrifugation, and evaporation.
[0047] The cell culture comprising hepatocytes forming at least one bile canaliculus may
be any suitable hepatocyte culture. Typically the cell culture comprising hepatocytes
forming at least one bile canaliculus is a culture configuration that does not comprise
a liver slice. Exemplary cell cultures comprising hepatocytes forming at least one
bile canaliculus are described in Section D: "Cultures Comprising Hepatocytes Forming
a Bile Canaliculus" of this DETAILED DESCRIPTION section of the disclosure. Any Cultures
Comprising Hepatocytes Forming a Bile Canaliculus may be used in the methods of this
disclosure.
[0048] In some embodiments of the methods the cell culture is a hepatocyte-stromal cell
coculture comprising hepatocytes and stromal cells disposed on a surface of a solid
substrate.
[0049] In some embodiments of the methods the amount of the first chemical entity and/or
a metabolite thereof released by the at least one bile canaliculus in step c) is higher
than the amount of the first chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released
by the hepatocytes in step d).
[0050] In some embodiments of the methods the amount of the first chemical entity and/or
a metabolite thereof released by the at least one bile canaliculus in step c) is lower
than the amount of the first chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released
by the hepatocytes in step d).
[0051] In some embodiments of the methods the amount of the first chemical entity and/or
a metabolite thereof in steps c) and/or d) is detected using LC-MS/MS. In some embodiments
of the methods the amount of the first chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof
in steps c) and d) is detected using an equivalent LC-MS/MS technique.
[0052] In some embodiments of the methods the first chemical entity does not comprise a
label. As used herein a "label" is a moiety that emits a signal that may be detected
in an assay. Exemplary labels are fluorescent moieties and radioactive moieties.
[0053] In some embodiments the methods do not comprise detecting a signal from a label moiety
of a chemical entity.
[0054] In some embodiments of the methods the at least one bile canaliculus is disrupted
without lysing hepatocytes in the culture by incubating the culture in media comprising
latrunculin A (LatA) and/or not comprising calcium.
[0055] In some embodiments the methods further comprise determining the intrinsic biliary
clearance (CL
bile) and/or the biliary excretion index (BEI) for the first chemical entity in the cell
culture.
[0056] In some embodiments the methods further comprise determining the intrinsic biliary
clearance (CL
bile) and/or the biliary excretion index (BEI) for the first chemical entity in the cell
culture; and further comprise comparing the CL
bile and/or BEI of the first chemical entity to the CL
bile and/or BEI of a control chemical entity and characterizing the biliary excretion
of the first chemical entity based on the comparison.
[0057] In some embodiments of the methods the activity of at least one hepatocyte transport
protein is inhibited in the hepatocytes. In some embodiments the at least one hepatocyte
transport protein is selected from at least one sinusoidal membrane transport protein
and at least one bile membrane transport protein. In some embodiments the at least
one hepatocyte transport protein is selected from NTCP, OATP1A1, OATP1A2, OATP1A4,
OATPB2, OATP1B1, OATP1B3, OATP2B1, OAT2, OAT3, OAT4, OCT1, OCT3, OCTN1, OCTN2, BSEP,
MRP1, MRP2, MRP3, MRP4, MRP5, MRP6, MRP7, MRP8, MRP9, MDR1, MDR1A/B, MDR2, MDR3, BCRP,
ABCG5, ABCG8, and FIC-1.
[0058] In some embodiments the methods further comprise contacting the cell culture with
a second chemical entity in step b).
[0059] In some embodiments the methods further comprise contacting the cell culture with
a second chemical entity in step b); and the methods, further comprise detecting the
amount of the second chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released by the at
least one bile canaliculus in step c).
[0060] In some embodiments the methods further comprise contacting the cell culture with
a second chemical entity in step b); and the methods, further comprise detecting the
amount of the second chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released by the at
least one bile canaliculus in step c); and the methods further comprise detecting
the amount of the second chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released by the
hepatocytes in step d).
B. Single Culture Biliary Excretion Assay With Hepatocyte Transporter Inhibition
[0061] In certain embodiments the methods of this invention comprise comparing (1) biliary
excretion of a first chemical entity in cultured hepatocytes in which the activity
of at least one hepatocyte transport protein is inhibited in the hepatocytes with
(2) biliary excretion of the first chemical entity in cultured hepatocytes in which
the activity of at least one hepatocyte transport protein is not inhibited in the
hepatocytes, in order to characterize the effect of inhibition of the at least one
hepatocyte transport protein on biliary excretion of the first chemical entity. For
example, such methods may comprise a) providing a first cell culture comprising hepatocytes
forming at least one bile canaliculus, wherein the activity of at least one hepatocyte
transport protein is inhibited in the hepatocytes of the first cell culture; b) contacting
the first cell culture with a first chemical entity; c) disrupting the at least one
bile canaliculus in the first cell culture without lysing the hepatocytes in the first
cell culture and detecting the amount (if any) of the first chemical entity and/or
a metabolite thereof released by the at least one bile canaliculus; d) lysing the
hepatocytes in the first cell culture and detecting the amount of the first chemical
entity and/or a metabolite thereof released by the hepatocytes; e) providing a second
cell culture comprising hepatocytes forming at least one bile canaliculus, wherein
the activity of the at least one hepatocyte transport protein is not inhibited in
the hepatocytes of the second cell culture; f) contacting the second cell culture
with the first chemical entity; g) disrupting the at least one bile canaliculus in
the second cell culture without lysing the hepatocytes in the second cell culture
and detecting the amount (if any) of the first chemical entity and/or a metabolite
thereof released by the at least one bile canaliculus; and h) lysing the hepatocytes
in the second cell culture and detecting the amount of the first chemical entity and/or
a metabolite thereof released by the hepatocytes. In some embodiments at least one
wash step is included between steps a) and b), between steps b) and c), and/or between
steps c) and d). In some embodiments at least one wash step is included between steps
e) and f), between steps f) and g), and/or between steps g) and h).
[0062] Typically steps b) and f) are performed by diluting a first chemical entity in culture
media and replacing the culture media used in steps a) or e) with the media comprising
the diluted first chemical entity. After a time sufficient to allow uptake the culture
media of step b) or f) is removed from the culture. Because the hepatocytes are typically
adhered to a substrate this is typically accomplished using standard tissue culture
aspiration and pipetting techniques or equivalent to remove culture media and then
add new media Of course, a skilled artisan will appreciate that any suitable method
may be used. At this stage of the method the hepatocyte culture may be washed by one
or more changes of culture media that does not comprise the first chemical entity,
such as by one wash, by two washes, or by three washes.
[0063] In some embodiments, following steps b) and/or f) the cell culture comprising hepatocytes
forming at least one bile canaliculus is incubated in fresh media for a culture period
and the culture media is then collected. This culture media may be analyzed for accumulation
of first chemical entity in the culture media. First chemical entity that accumulates
under this culture conditions will have originated form basolateral transport processes
of the hepatocytes and thus inclusion of this step in embodiments of the methods allows
measurement of basolateral transport, biliary accumulation, and cytoplasmic accumulation
of a chemical entity in a single cell culture comprising hepatocytes forming at least
one bile canaliculus.
[0064] In steps c) and f) the at least one bile canaliculus is disrupted by any suitable
technique known in the art. An exemplary method is by exchanging the culture media
with media that is calcium free or that is calcium and magnesium free. Incubation
in media that is calcium free or that is calcium and magnesium free disrupts tight
junctions and causes the contents of bile canaliculi to be released into the culture
media. Another exemplary method is by exchanging the culture media for media comprising
an effective concentration of LatA, Incubation in media that comprising an effective
concentration of LatA disrupts tight junctions and causes the contents of bile canaliculi
to be released into the culture media. The detecting in steps c) and f) typically
is by collecting the media following disruption of canaliculi and characterization
of first chemical entity present in the collected media. The detection may be qualitative
and/or quantitative. In a preferred embodiment the detection methods comprise use
of LC-MS/MS to detect the first chemical entity. In some embodiments LC-MS/MS is used
to measure the amount of the first chemical entity present in the media following
disruption of the at least one bile canaliculus. In some embodiments the media comprising
the material released from the canaliculi is processed to remove undesirable components
using steps that may include, for example, at least one of filtration, chromatography,
and centrifugation.
[0065] In steps d) and h) the remaining cells are lysed by any suitable technique known
in the art. An exemplary method is by exposure to deionized water. The detecting in
steps d) and h) typically is by collecting the media following lysing of the remaining
cells and characterization of first chemical entity present in the collected media.
The detection may be qualitative and/or quantitative. In a preferred embodiment the
detection methods comprise use of LC-MS/MS to detect the first chemical entity. In
some embodiments LC-MS/MS is used to measure the amount of the first chemical entity
present in the media following cell lysis. In some embodiments the media comprising
the material released from the lysed cells is processed to remove undesirable components
using steps that may include, for example, at least one of filtration, chromatography,
and centrifugation.
[0066] The cell cultures comprising hepatocytes forming at least one bile canaliculus may
be any suitable hepatocyte culture. Typically the cell cultures comprising hepatocytes
forming at least one bile canaliculus are cultures in a configuration that does not
comprise a liver slice. Exemplary cell cultures comprising hepatocytes forming at
least one bile canaliculus are described in Section D: "Cultures Comprising Hepatocytes
Forming a Bile Canaliculus" of this DETAILED DESCRIPTION section of the disclosure.
Any Cultures Comprising Hepatocytes Forming a Bile Canaliculus may be used in the
methods of this disclosure.
[0067] In some embodiments of the methods the first and second cell cultures are hepatocyte-stromal
cell cocultures comprising hepatocytes and stromal cells disposed on a surface of
a solid substrate.
[0068] In some embodiments the methods further comprise determining the CL
bile and/or BEI for the first chemical entity in the first cell culture and determining
the CL
bile and/or BEI for the first chemical entity in the second cell culture.
[0069] In some embodiments the methods further comprise determining the CL
bile and/or BEI for the first chemical entity in the first cell culture and determining
the CL
bile and/or BEI for the first chemical entity in the second cell culture; and the CL
bile and/or BEI for the first chemical entity is lower in the first cell culture than
in the second cell culture, indicating that biliary clearance of the first chemical
entity is mediated at least on part by the at least one hepatocyte transport protein.
[0070] In some embodiments the methods further comprise determining the CL
bile and/or BEI for the first chemical entity in the first cell culture and determining
the CL
bile and/or BEI for the first chemical entity in the second cell culture; and the CL
bile and/or BEI for the first chemical entity is not lower in the first cell culture than
in the second cell culture, indicating that biliary clearance of the first chemical
entity is not mediated at least on part by the at least one hepatocyte transport protein.
[0071] In some embodiments of the methods the amount of the first chemical entity and/or
a metabolite thereof in steps c) and/or d) and/or e) and/or h) is detected using LC-MS/MS.
In some embodiments of the methods the amount of the first chemical entity and/or
a metabolite thereof in steps c) and d) and g) and h) is detected using an equivalent
LC-MS/MS technique.
[0072] In some embodiments of the methods the first chemical entity and/or a metabolite
thereof in steps b) and/or f) does not comprise a label. As used herein a "label"
is a moiety that emits a signal that may be detected in an assay. Exemplary labels
are fluorescent moieties and radioactive moieties.
[0073] In some embodiments the methods do not comprise detecting a signal from a label moiety
of a chemical entity.
[0074] In some embodiments of the methods the at least one bile canaliculus is disrupted
in the first and second cell cultures without lysing hepatocytes in the cell cultures
by incubating the cell cultures in media comprising latrunculin A (LatA) and/or not
comprising calcium.
[0075] In some embodiments the methods further comprise contacting the first and/or second
cell cultures with a second chemical entity in steps b) and/or f).
[0076] In some embodiments the methods further comprise contacting the first and/or second
cell cultures with a second chemical entity in steps b) and/or f); and further comprise
detecting the amount of the second chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released
by the at least one bile canaliculus in steps c) and/or g).
[0077] In some embodiments the methods further comprise contacting the first and/or second
cell cultures with a second chemical entity in steps b) and/or f); and further comprise
detecting the amount of the second chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released
by the at least one bile canaliculus in steps c) and/or g); and further comprise detecting
the amount of the second chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released by the
hepatocytes in steps d) and/or h.
[0078] In some embodiments of the methods the at least one hepatocyte transport protein
is selected from at least one sinusoidal membrane transport protein and at least one
bile membrane transport protein. In some embodiments the at least one hepatocyte transport
protein is selected from NTCP, OATP1A1, OATP1A2, OATP1A4, OATPB2, OATP1B1, OATP1B3,
OATP2B1, OAT2, OAT3, OAT4, OCT1, OCT3, OCTN1, OCTN2, BSEP, MRP1, MRP2, MRP3, MRP4,
MRP5, MRP6, MRP7, MRP8, MRP9, MDR1, MDR1A/B, MDR2, MDR3, BCRP, ABCG5, ABCG8, and FIC-1.
C. Single Culture Biliary Excretion Assay With Marker Chemical Entity
[0079] In certain embodiments the methods of this disclosure comprise simultaneously exposing
a cell culture comprising hepatocytes forming at least one bile canaliculus to a marker
chemical entity and a test chemical entity and characterizing biliary excretion of
the marker chemical entity in the presence of the test chemical entity in order to
characterize biliary excretion of the test chemical entity. In particular, these methods
allow detection of the use of a common transporter by the marker chemical entity and
the test chemical entity.
[0080] For example, such methods may comprise a) providing a cell culture comprising hepatocytes
forming at least one bile canaliculus; b) simultaneously contacting the cell culture
with a marker chemical entity and a test chemical entity, wherein the marker chemical
entity is a known substrate of at least one hepatocyte transport protein with a determined
CL
bile and/or BEI; c) disrupting the at least one bile canaliculus without lysing the hepatocytes
and detecting the amount of the marker chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof
released by the at least one bile canaliculus; and d) lysing the hepatocytes and detecting
the amount of the marker chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof released by the
hepatocytes. In some embodiments at least one wash step is included between steps
a) and b), between steps b) and c), and/or between steps c) and d).
[0081] Typically step b) is performed by diluting the marker chemical entity and test chemical
entity in culture media and replacing the culture media used in step a) with the media
comprising the diluted marker chemical entity and test chemical entity. After a time
sufficient to allow uptake the culture media of step b) is removed from the culture.
Because the hepatocytes are typically adhered to a substrate this is typically accomplished
using standard tissue culture aspiration and pipetting techniques or equivalent to
remove culture media and then add new media Of course, a skilled artisan will appreciate
that any suitable method may be used. At this stage of the method the hepatocyte culture
may be washed by one or more changes of culture media that does not comprise the marker
chemical entity and test chemical entity, such as by one wash, by two washes, or by
three washes. In some embodiments of the methods step b) is preceded by a step in
which the culture is contacted by the test chemical entity and not the marker chemical
entity to allow preloading of a transporter with the test chemical entity.
[0082] In step c) the at least one bile canaliculus is disrupted by any suitable technique
known in the art. An exemplary method is by exchanging the culture media with media
that is calcium free or that is calcium and magnesium free. Incubation in media that
is calcium free or that is calcium and magnesium free disrupts tight junctions and
causes the contents of bile canaliculi to be released into the culture media. Another
exemplary method is by exchanging the culture media for media comprising an effective
concentration of LatA, Incubation in media that comprising an effective concentration
of LatA disrupts tight junctions and causes the contents of bile canaliculi to be
released into the culture media. The detecting in step c) typically is by collecting
the media following disruption of canaliculi and characterization of marker chemical
entity present in the collected media. The detection may be qualitative and/or quantitative.
In a preferred embodiment the detection methods comprise use of LC-MS/MS to detect
the first chemical entity. In some embodiments LC-MS/MS is used to measure the amount
of the marker chemical entity present in the media following disruption of the at
least one bile canaliculus. In some embodiments the media comprising the material
released from the canaliculi is processed to remove undesirable components using steps
that may include, for example, at least one of filtration, chromatography, and centrifugation.
[0083] In step d) the remaining cells are lysed by any suitable technique known in the art.
An exemplary method is by exposure to deionized water. The detecting in step d) typically
is by collecting the media following lysing of the remaining cells and characterization
of marker chemical entity present in the collected media. The detection may be qualitative
and/or quantitative. In a preferred embodiment the detection methods comprise use
of LC-MS/MS to detect the marker chemical entity. In some embodiments LC-MS/MS is
used to measure the amount of the marker chemical entity present in the media following
cell lysis. In some embodiments the media comprising the material released from the
lysed cells is processed to remove undesirable components using steps that may include,
for example, at least one of filtration, chromatography, and centrifugation.
[0084] The cell culture comprising hepatocytes forming at least one bile canaliculus may
be any suitable hepatocyte culture. Typically the cell culture comprising hepatocytes
forming at least one bile canaliculus is a culture configuration that does not comprise
a liver slice. Exemplary cell cultures comprising hepatocytes forming at least one
bile canaliculus are described in Section D: "Cultures Comprising Hepatocytes Forming
a Bile Canaliculus" of this DETAILED DESCRIPTION section of the disclosure. Any Cultures
Comprising Hepatocytes Forming a Bile Canaliculus may be used in the methods of this
disclosure.
[0085] In some embodiments of the methods the cell culture is a hepatocyte-stromal cell
coculture comprising hepatocytes and stromal cells disposed on a surface of a solid
substrate.
[0086] In some embodiments the methods further comprise determining the CL
bile and/or BEI for the marker chemical entity in the hepatocyte-stromal cell coculture
in the presence of the test chemical entity.
[0087] In some embodiments the methods further comprise determining the CL
bile and/or BEI for the marker chemical entity in the hepatocyte-stromal cell coculture
in the presence of the test chemical entity; and the CL
bile and/or BEI for the marker chemical entity is lower in the presence of the test chemical
entity than in the absence of the test chemical entity, indicating that biliary clearance
of the test chemical entity is mediated at least in part by the at least one least
one hepatocyte transport protein.
[0088] In some embodiments the methods further comprise determining the CL
bile and/or BEI for the marker chemical entity in the hepatocyte-stromal cell coculture
in the presence of the test chemical entity; and the CL
bile and/or BEI for the marker chemical entity is not lower in the presence of the test
chemical entity than in the absence of the test chemical entity, indicating that biliary
clearance of the test chemical entity is not mediated at least in part by the at least
one least one hepatocyte transport protein.
[0089] In some embodiments of the methods the amount of the marker chemical entity and/or
metabolite thereof in steps c) and/or d) is detected using LC-MS/MS. In some embodiments
of the methods the amount of the marker chemical entity and/or a metabolite thereof
in steps c) and d) is detected using an equivalent LC-MS/MS technique.
[0090] In some embodiments of the methods the marker chemical entity does not comprise a
label. As used herein a "label" is a moiety that emits a signal that may be detected
in an assay. Exemplary labels are fluorescent moieties and radioactive moieties.
[0091] In some embodiments the methods do not comprise detecting a signal from a label moiety
of a chemical entity.
[0092] In some embodiments of the methods the at least one bile canaliculus is disrupted
in the cell culture without lysing hepatocytes in the cell culture by incubating the
cell culture in media comprising latrunculin A (LatA) and/or not comprising calcium.
[0093] In some embodiments of the methods the activity of at least one hepatocyte transport
protein is inhibited in the hepatocytes. In some embodiments the at least one hepatocyte
transport protein is selected from at least one sinusoidal membrane transport protein
and at least one bile membrane transport protein. In some embodiments the at least
one hepatocyte transport protein is selected from NTCP, OATP1A1, OATP1A2, OATP1A4,
OATPB2, OATP1B1, OATP1B3, OATP2B1, OAT2, OAT3, OAT4, OCT1, OCT3, OCTN1, OCTN2, BSEP,
MRP1, MRP2, MRP3, MRP4, MRP5, MRP6, MRP7, MRP8, MRP9, MDR1, MDR1A/B, MDR2, MDR3, BCRP,
ABCG5, ABCG8, and FIC-1.
D. Cultures Comprising Hepatocytes Forming a Bile Canaliculus
[0094] A bile canaliculus is a thin tube that collects bile secreted by hepatocytes. The
bile canaliculi merge and form bile ductules, which eventually become the common hepatic
duct. Hepatocytes are polyhedral in shape, with surfaces facing the sinusoids (called
sinusoidal faces) and surfaces which contact other hepatocytes (called lateral faces).
Bile canaliculi are formed by grooves on some of the lateral faces of adjacent hepatocytes.
Under appropriate conditions cultured hepatocytes have the ability to form canaliculi.
[0095] The methods of this disclosure utilize in vitro cell cultures comprising hepatocytes
that have formed at least one bile canaliculus. The hepatocytes may be any type of
hepatocyte including without limitation primary hepatocyte, hepatocyte cell lines,
and hepatocytes formed by differentiating stem cells (such as embryonic stem cells,
adult stem cells, or induced pluripotent stem cells) into hepatocytes. The hepatocytes
may be from any mammal. In some embodiments the hepatocytes are from a mammal selected
from a human, a non-human primate (such as a cynomolgus monkey), a farm animal (such
as pig, horse, cow, and sheep), a domestic mammal (such as dogs, cats, guinnea pig
and rabbit), and rodents (such as mice and rats). In some embodiments the hepatocyte-stromal
cell cocultures comprise hepatocytes from a plurality of mammalian species.
[0096] In a preferred embodiment the hepatocytes are primary hepatocytes. Primary hepatocytes
may need not be supplied in cryopreserved form. Cropreserved human hepatocytes may
be obtained from Life Technologies Corporation. Cropreserved non-human primate hepatocytes
may be obtained from Life Technologies Corporation. Cropreserved dog hepatocytes may
be obtained from IVT Bioreclemation. Cropreserved rat hepatocytes may be obtained
from Life Technologies Corporation.
[0097] In some embodiments the culture comprises hepatocytes present in a three dimensional
bioprinted configuration. In some embodiments the culture comprises hepatocytes present
in a spheroid configuration. In some embodiments the culture comprises hepatocytes
present in a gel sandwich configuration. In some embodiments the culture comprises
a capillary bed. In some embodiments the culture is made by a method that does not
comprise creating a liver slice. In some embodiments the culture does not comprise
a liver slice.
[0098] In some embodiments the culture is a hepatocyte-stromal cell coculture comprising
hepatocytes and at least one stromal cell type disposed on the surface of a solid
substrate. In some embodiments of the hepatocyte-stromal cell coculture the hepatocytes
and a single stromal cell type represent at least about 95%, at least about 96%, at
least about 97%, at least about 98%, at least about 99%, at least about 99.5%, at
least about 99.9%, or at least about 99.99% of the cells in the coculture.
[0099] Typically the hepatocytes and stromal cells are present in the coculture at a ratio
of from 1:10 to 10:1. In some embodiments the hepatocytes and stromal cells are present
in the coculture at a ratio of from 2:10 to 10:2. In some embodiments the hepatocytes
and stromal cells are present in the coculture at a ratio of from 2:10 to 4:10. In
some embodiments the hepatocytes and stromal cells are present in the coculture at
a ratio of from 4:10 to 6:10. In some embodiments the hepatocytes and stromal cells
are present in the coculture at a ratio of from 6:10 to 8:10. In some embodiments
the hepatocytes and stromal cells are present in the coculture at a ratio of from
8:10 to 1:1. In some embodiments the hepatocytes and stromal cells are present in
the coculture at a ratio of from 1:1 to 10:8. In some embodiments the hepatocytes
and stromal cells are present in the coculture at a ratio of from 10:8 to 10:6. In
some embodiments the hepatocytes and stromal cells are present in the coculture at
a ratio of from 10:6 to 10:4. In some embodiments the hepatocytes and stromal cells
are present in the coculture at a ratio of from 10:4 to 10:2. In some embodiments
the hepatocytes and stromal cells are present in the coculture at a ratio of about
10:1, 10:2, 10:3, 10:4, 10:5, :10:6, 10:7, 10:8, 10:9, 1:1, 9:10, 8:10, 7:10, 6:10,
5:10, 4:10, 3:10, 2:10, or 1:10.
[0100] In some embodiments the hepatocyte-stromal cell coculture comprises at least two
stromal cell types. In some embodiments the hepatocyte-stromal cell coculture comprises
two stromal cell types that each represent at least about 0.01%, at least about 0.1%,
at least about 0.5%, at least about 1%, at least about 2%, at least about 3%, at least
about 4%, at least about 5%, or at least about 10% of the cells in the coculture.
[0101] In some embodiments the stromal cell type is from the same type of mammal as the
hepatocytes. In some embodiments the stromal cell type is from a different type of
mammal than the hepatocytes.
[0102] In some embodiments the hepatocyte-stromal cell coculture comprises a third cell
type. In some embodiments the third cell type is a stromal cell. In some embodiments
the third cell type is not a stromal cell. In some embodiments the third cell type
is a parenchymal cell. In some embodiments the third cell type is not a non-parenchymal
cell. In some embodiments the third cell type is selected from Ito cells, endothelial
cells, biliary duct cells, immune-mediating cells, and stem cells. In some embodiments,
the immune-mediating cells are selected from macrophages, T cells, neutrophils, dendritic
cells, mast cells, eosinophils and basophils.
[0103] In some embodiments the third cell type is a Kupffer cell. In some embodiments the
Kupffer cells represent at least about 0.01%, at least about 0.1%, at least about
0.5%, at least about 1%, at least about 2%, at least about 3%, at least about 4%,
at least about 5%, or at least about 10% of the cells in the coculture.
[0104] In some embodiments the stromal cell type is an endothelial cell. In some embodiments
the stromal cell type is a fibroblast cell. In some embodiments the stromal cell is
a primary cell. In some embodiments the stromal cell is obtained from a cell line.
In some embodiments the stromal cell is a transformed cell. In some embodiments the
stromal cell is differentiated in vitro from a stem cell, such as an embryonic stem
cell, adult stem cell, or induced pluripotent stem cell. Numerous sources of stromal
cells such as fibroblasts are known in the art and may be utilized in the hepatocyte-stromal
cell cocultures. One example is the NIH 3T3-J2 cell line. (See for example
US 2013/0266939 A1.)
[0105] The art teaches that some aspects of hepatocyte function in culture are improved
by disposing hepatocytes and stromal cells onto a solid substrate such that the hepatocytes
are attached to the substrate in a first step in a cellular island configuration.
(See
US 2013/0266939 A1.) Specifically, such methods rely on formation of cellular islands of hepatocytes
on a substrate, the hepatocyte islands surrounded by a non-parenchymal cell type such
as a stromal cell type. The hepatocyte islands are formed by first placing an extracellular
matrix component or derivative onto a solid substrate in an island pattern and then
allowing the hepatocytes to adhere to the extracellular matrix component or derivative.
The non-parenchymal cell type is then added and allowed to "fill in" the portions
of the substrate that don't contain hepatocytes. A fundamental feature of such systems
is that the hepatocytes are not dispursed accross across the substrate surface.
[0106] In some embodiments the invention utilizes a hepatocyte-stromal cell coculture comprising
hepatocytes distributed in a cellular island configuration such as described in
US 2013/0266939 A1. However, in preferred embodiments the hepatocytes are substantially dispersed across
the surface of the solid substrate.
[0107] As used herein, "dispersed across the surface" in reference to an arrangement of
hepatocytes on a solid support in a hepatocyte-stromal cell coculture means that at
least one of the following criteria applies to the coculture: 1) at least about 20%,
at least about 30%, at least about 40%, or at least about 50% of the surface of the
solid substrate is covered by at least one hepatocyte; 2) at least about 2%, at least
about 5% or at least about 10% of the hepatocytes in the coculture are located on
top of a stromal cell that is in contact with the solid substrate; and 3) the hepatocytes
were not seeded onto the solid substrate by adding the hepatocytes to a solid substrate
comprising islands of at least one extracellular matrix component to create islands
of hepatocytes attached to the solid substrate. Note that a single hepatocyte may
be counted as meeting criteria 1 and criteria 2.
[0108] For use in the methods of the invention the coculture comprises at least one bile
canaliculus. In some embodiments the coculture comprises only a single bile canaliculus
while in other embodiments the coculture comprises a plurality of canaliculi.
[0109] In preferred embodiments the metabolic function of the hepatocyte-stromal cell coculture
is long enduring throughout a culture period. In some embodiments the culture period
is for at least one day, at least two days, at least three days, at least five days,
at least seven days, at least ten days, at least fourteen days, at least twenty-one
days, or at least twenty-eight days. In some embodiments the metabolic function of
the hepatocyte-stromal cell coculture is determined by measuring an activity selected
from gene expression, cell function, metabolic activity, morphology, and a combination
thereof, of the hepatocytes in the coculture. In some embodiments the metabolic function
of the hepatocyte-stromal cell coculture is determined by measuring the level of expression
and/or activity of at least one CYP450 enzyme. The level of expression and/or activity
of at least one CYP450 enzyme may be measured by measuring expression of the CYP450
enzyme mRNA, by measuring expression of the CYP450 enzyme protein, or by a functional
assay of CYP450 enzyme activity. In some embodiments, the metabolic activity is a
CYP450 enzyme activity. In some embodiments, the CYP450 enzyme is a CYP450 enzyme
selected from CYP1A2, CYP1B1, CYP2A6, CYP2B6, CYP2C, CYP2D6, CYP2E1, CYP2F1, CYP2J2,
CYP3A4, CYP4A, and CYP4B.
[0110] The metabolic function of the hepatocyte-stromal cell coculture is considered long
enduring if the metabolic function of the coculture endures longer in the hepatocyte-stromal
cell coculture than the metabolic function of a control hepatocyte monoculture. In
some embodiments the metabolic function of the coculture endures for at least seven
days. In some embodiments the metabolic function of the coculture endures for at least
fourteen days. In some embodiments the metabolic function of the coculture endures
for at least twenty-one days. In some embodiments the metabolic function of the coculture
endures for at least twenty-eight days.
[0111] In some embodiments the coculture is cultured in serum-free or essentially serum-free
media. In some embodiments the coculture is cultured in media containing serum. In
some embodiments the media comprises about 0.1% serum, about 0.2% serum, about 0.3%
serum, about 0.4% serum, about 0.5% serum, about 0.6% serum, about 0.7% serum, about
0.8% serum, about 0.9% serum, about 1% serum, about 2% serum, about 3% serum, about
4% serum, about 5% serum, about 6% serum, about 7% serum, about 8% serum, about 9%
serum, or about 10% serum. In some embodiments the media comprises at least about
0.1% serum, at least about 0.2% serum, at least about 0.3% serum, at least about 0.4%
serum, at least about 0.5% serum, at least about 0.6% serum, at least about 0.7% serum,
at least about 0.8% serum, at least about 0.9% serum, at least about 1% serum, at
least about 2% serum, at least about 3% serum, at least about 4% serum, at least about
5% serum, at least about 6% serum, at least about 7% serum, at least about 8% serum,
at least about 9% serum, or at least about 10% serum. In some embodiments the media
comprises less than or equal to about 0.1% serum, less than or equal to about 0.2%
serum, less than or equal to about 0.3% serum, less than or equal to about 0.4% serum,
less than or equal to about 0.5% serum, less than or equal to about 0.6% serum, less
than or equal to about 0.7% serum, less than or equal to about 0.8% serum, less than
or equal to about 0.9% serum, less than or equal to about 1% serum, less than or equal
to about 2% serum, less than or equal to about 3% serum, less than or equal to about
4% serum, less than or equal to about 5% serum, less than or equal to about 6% serum,
less than or equal to about 7% serum, less than or equal to about 8% serum, less than
or equal to about 9% serum, or less than or equal to about 10% serum.
E. Transporters
[0112] In some embodiments of the methods of the invention, at least one hepatocyte transporter
selected from a sinusoidal membrane transporter and a canalicular transporter is inhibited.
Numerous transporters are known in the art and a skilled artisan will appreciate that
any known or subsequently discovered transporter may be used with the methods of the
invention. Exemplary transporters include but are not limited to the sodium/bile acid
cotransporter also known as the Na+-taurocholate cotransporting polypeptide (NTCP)
or liver bile acid transporter (LBAT), a protein that in humans is encoded by the
SLC10A1 (solute carrier family 10 member 1) gene; an organic anion-transporting polypeptide,
for example one selected from OATP1A1, OATP1A2, OATP1A4, OATPB2, OATP1B1, OATP1B3,
and OATP2B1; an organic anion transporter, for example one selected from OAT2, OAT3,
OAT4; an organic cation transport protein, for example one selected from OCT1, OCT3,
OCTN1, and OCTN2; the bile salt export pump (BSEP) protein, also known as ATP-binding
cassette, sub-family B member 11 (ABCB11), encoded by the
ABCB11 gene in humans; a multidrug resistance-associated protein, for example one selected
from MRP1, MRP2, MRP3, MRP4, MRP5, MRP6, MRP7, MRP8, and MRP9; a P-glycoprotein, such
as one selected from MDR1, MDR1A/B, MDR2, and MDR3; the ATP-binding cassette sub-family
G member 2 (ABCG2), also known as BCRP, a protein that in humans is encoded by the
ABCG2 gene; an ABC protein selected from ABCG5 and ABCG8; and the probable phospholipid-transporting
ATPase IC (ATP8B1), also known as FIC-1, an enzyme that in humans is encoded by the
ATP8B1 gene.
[0113] Numerous inhibitors of these transporter proteins are known in the art and may be
used in the methods of the invention. Exemplary inhibitors of Pgp proteins include
but are not limited to ritonavir, cyclosporine, verapamil, erythromycin, ketocoanzole,
itraconazole, and quinidine. Exemplary inhibitors of BCRP include but are not limited
to elacridar, Imatinib, and fumitremorgin C. Exemplary inhibitors of Mate 1 include
but are not limited to cimetidine. Exemplary inhibitors of BSEP include but are not
limited to Atorvastatin, Cerivastatin, Clofazimine, and Glyburide. Exemplary inhibitors
of MRP2 include but are not limited to cyclosporine, probenecid, furosemide, and lamivudine.
EXAMPLES
Example 1: Hepatocyte-Stromal Cell Cocultures
[0114] Cryopreserved human hepatocytes were removed from liquid nitrogen and thawed. After
thawing, cells were resuspended in medium and cell number and cell viability was determined
using trypan blue exclusion. Stromal cells were passed in a CO
2 incubator until used for experimental plating. On plating day cells were detached
from the plate, washed, and re-suspended in medium. Cell number and viability were
determined using trypan blue exclusion.
[0115] Hepatocytes and stromal cells were seeded into collagen-coated 96-well plates at
a density of 30,000 hepatocytes per well. The stromal cells were growth arrested prior
to seeding. Cultures were maintained for 7 days before the start of any biliary excretion
assays. Before the experiments were started, the cells were stained with CDFDA on
day 7 to ensure canalicular formation.
Example 2: Excretion of Test Compound Into Bile Canaliculi in Hepatocyte-Stromal Cell
Cocultures
[0116] In this experiment the presence of bile canaliculi in hepatocyte-stromal cell cocoultures
prepared according to Example 1 was assessed. Cocultures were incubated with 5 uM
5-(and-6)-Carboxy-2', 7'-dichloro-fluoreceine diacetate (CDFDA) for 20 min. CDFDA
that is taken up by hepatocytes is hydrolyzed to fluorescent 5-(and-6)-Carboxy-2',
7'-dichloro-fluoreceine (CDA) by the hepatocyte and then secreted in this fluorescent
form into the canaliculus via the Mrp2 transporter. The cocultures comprised several
canaliculi that are readily apparent under the microscope (data not shown). Cyclosporin
A (CSA) is a known inhibitor of the Mrp2 transporter. In a subsequent experiment a
coculture was incubed with CDFDA in the presence of 50 uM CSA for 20 min. No fluorescent
canaliculi were visible following incubation with CDFDA in the presence of CSA (data
now shown). This result demonstrates that bile canaliculi are present in the cocultures
prepared according to Example 1 and demonstrates that transporter-dependent excretion
of chemical entities into the canaliculi can be assessed in this system.
Example 3: Disruption of Canaliculi
[0117] Assessing excretion of a chemical entity into the bile in the hepatocyte-stromal
cell coculture requires a method of distinguising between the chemical entity present
in canaliculi of the coculture and chemical entity that may be present in the cytoplasm
of cells in the coculture. Two methods of canalicular disruption were tested. In the
first method, the cultures were exposed to a calcium free (Ca-) free buffer. The lack
of calcium inhibits the ability of the cell to form tight junctions which allows bile
present in the canaliculi to escape. Cells were first washed two times in HBSS buffer
with Ca+. Cells were then incubated with 5 uM CDFDA in HBSS buffer without Ca- for
20 min. Cells were then washed two times in HBSS buffer without Ca-. Because accumulated
CDF escaped the canaliculi after exposure to Ca- buffer no CDF staining was apparent
(data not shown).
[0118] In the second method, the cultures were exposed to buffer containing latranculin
A (LatA). The LatA functions to disrupt microfilament organization, a key step in
tight junction formation, which allows bile present in the canaliculi to escape. Cells
were first washed twice in HBSS buffer with Ca+. Cells were then incubated with 5
uM CDFDA in HBSS buffer with Ca+ and 10 uM LatA for 20 min. Cells were then washed
two times in HBSS buffer with Ca+. Because accumulated CDA escaped the canaliculi
after exposure to LatA containing buffer no CDA staining was apparent (data not shown).
Example 4: Biliary Excretion Assays
[0119] The data reported in Examples 2 and 3 qualitatively demonstrates the ability of the
heaptocyte-stromal cell coculture system to form functional canaliculi, the ability
to disrupt the canaliculi, and the ability to inhibit the function of the Mrp2 and
BSEP transporter systems. This example demonstrates the capability of the system to
quantitatively measure hepatobiliary excretion of taurcholate. To assess hepatobiliary
transport in one coculture compartment 2uM of taurcholate was introduced to the cellular
media and allowed to incubate for 20 minutes. The media was then removed (collection
#1) and stored for analysis of remaining taurcholate. The cultures were washed twice
with buffer solution (collections #2 and #3) and each wash solution was stored for
analysis of remaining taurcholate. The cells were then exposed to either Ca- buffer
or LatA buffer for 30 minutes (collection #4) which functions to disrupt the canaliculi
present in the cultures but does not lyse cells in the coculture. This releases taurcholate
accumulated in the bile of the canaliculi. The cells were then exposed to deionized
water (collection #5) which functions to disrupt the cellular membrane and release
the compound accumulated in the cellular compartment. Because any taurcholate present
in the canaliculi was already collected in collection #4, collection #5 contains any
taurcholate present in the cell but not including any present in the canaliculi. The
concentration of taurcholate in collection #4 (Figure 1) and collection 5 (Figure
2) was determined using LC-MS/MS. The experiment was run in triplicate. The underlying
data shown in Figure 1 for Lat A was 117.6 nM, 115.4 nM and 158.6 nM. The underlying
data shown in Figure 1 for Ca- was 204 nM, 150.2 nM and 158 nM. The underlying data
shown in Figure 2, collection #5, for Lat A was 199 nM, 144.4 nM and 234 nM. The underlying
data shown in Figure 2, collection #5, for Ca- numbers was 141 nM, 95.4 nM and 120.8
nM.
[0120] Samples were centrifuged at 1000 x g for 10 min, and an aliquot (10 mL) of the supernatant
was analyzed by LC -MS/MS. The LC-MS/MS system comprised a Shimadzu LC-10ADvp pump
(Shimadzu, Columbia, MD), HTS PAL CTC autosampler (Leap Technologies, Carboro, NC),
and an API 4000 mass spectrometer with a Turbo Ion Spray probe (Applied Biosystems/MDS
SCIEX, Ontario, Canada). The separation of compounds was achieved using a reversed
phased stationary phase (Synergi Hydro, Phenomenex). The mobile phase was a gradient
with 0.1% formic acid with 0.15gm Ammonium acetate in water (A) and 0.1% formic acid
with 0.15gm Ammonium acetate in acetonitrile (B) with a flow rate of 0.5 mL/min. The
initial composition of the mobile phase was 2% of B for 0.3 min, followed by a linear
gradient to 100% of B over 1.3 min, and back to 2% of B in 0.2 min, and maintaining
2% B for another 0.2 min. Taurcholic acid was detected using multiple reaction monitoring
(MRM) in negative ion mode. The area ratio of the analytes to the internal standard
was calculated using the Analyst1 software v. 1.4.1 (Applied Biosystems). The concentrations
of taurcholate in the bile and in the cell were then used to calculate the intrinsic
biliary clearance (CLbile) [Equation 1] and a biliary excretion index (BEI) [Equation
2]for taurcholate in this system. The BEI for the method that used the Ca- buffer
to disrupt the canaliculi was 66.9% and the BEI for the method that used the LatA
buffer to disrupt the canaliculi was 40.4%. Others report similar ranges for BEI of
taurcholate ranging from 41-63%.
BI, Yi-an, et al., "Use of cryopreserved human hepatocytes in sandwich culture to
measure hepatobiliary transport," Drug Metab Dispos., Vol. 34, No. 9, pp. 1658-65
(2006).
Equations
[0121]

[0122] The effect of CSA on biliary clearance of taurcholate was then assessed using this
method. The same protocol was followed except that the cocultures were exposed to
the inhibitor CSA before addition of taurcholate into the cellular media. Prior to
the addition of 2uM of taurcholate, the cells were exposed to HBSS buffer with 50uM
Cyclosporine A for 20 min. Then the experiment continued as in Example 3. In this
experiment Ca- buffer was used to disrupt the canaliculi. As demonstrated by the data
shown in Figure 3, incubation with CSA dramatically reduced the concentration of taurcholate
accumulating in the bile.
Example 5: Uptake and Biliary Excretion in Human Hepatocyte Cocultures
[0123] Hepatocyte-stromal cell cocultures according to Example 1 were used to measure uptake
rates of five compounds: taurocholic acid (taurocholate) at 2uM, estradiol-glucuronide
at 2uM, digonxin at 2uM, rosuvastatin at 2uM, and pravastatin at 5uM. The single well
method of assessing biliary clearance of the invention was used.
[0124] A coculture was exposed to each tested compound in culture media at the indicated
concentration for 20 minutes. The media was then removed (collection #1) and stored
for analysis of remaining compound. The cultures were washed twice with buffer solution
(collections #2 and #3) and each wash solution was stored for analysis of remaining
taurcholate. The cells were then exposed to HEPES buffer containing latranculin at
a concentration of 5uM for 30 minutes, which functions to disrupt the canaliculi present
in the cultures but does not lyse cells in the coculture. This releases taurcholate
accumulated in the bile of the canaliculi. At the end of the incubation period the
culture media was collected (collection #4). The cells were then exposed to deionized
water which functions to disrupt the cellular membrane and release the compound accumulated
in the cellular compartment (collection #5). Because any compound present in the canaliculi
was already collected in collection #4, collection #5 contains any compound present
in the cell but not including any present in the canaliculi. The concentration of
compound in collection #4 and collection 5 was determined using LC-MS/MS as in Example
4.
[0125] The results of this analysis are presented in Figures 4-8. In teach figure the measured
amount of compound in bile and the measured amount of compound in the cytoplasm are
presented together as two parts of a single bar on the left side of the figure. The
measured value for the bile is also shown as a bar on the right side of the figure.
Comparing the height of the right bar (bile) to the hight of the composite left bar
(total of cytoplasm + bile) allows visulation of the portion of the compound that
accumulated in the bile. The results for taurocholic acid (taurocholate) are shown
in in Figure 4, the results for estradiol-glucuronide are shown in Figure 5, the results
for digonxin are showin in Figure 6, the results for rosuvastatin are shown in Figure
7, and the results for pravastatin are shown in Figure 8. Equation 2 was used to calculate
the BEI for each compound in this system. The data were used to calculate the Biliary
Clearance (Equiation 1) and BEI (Equation 2) for each tested compound. The data are
presented in Table 1.
[0126] The results obtained for taurocholic acid (taurocholate), estradiol-glucuronide,
digonxin, and rosuvastatin is in the range of published data that were generated using
a two culture method and reported by
Yi-an BI et al., "Use of Cryopreserved Human Hepatocytes in Sandwich Culture to Measure
Hepatobiliary Transport," Drug Metabolism and Disposition, Vol. 34, No. 9, pp. 1658-65
(2006), as shown in Table 1.
TABLE 1
| Taurocholic Acid |
| |
Example 6 Data |
Bi et al. (2006) |
| Uptake Rate (pmol/min/mg protein) |
38+/-5 |
11-17 |
| Biliary Clearance (ml/min/mg protein) |
23 +/- 3 |
6-10 |
| Biliary Excretion Index (%) |
66 +/- 9 |
41-72 |
| |
|
|
| Estradiol-Glucuronide |
| |
Example 6 Data |
Bi et al. (2006) |
| Uptake Rate (pmol/min/mg protein) |
2.0 +/- 0.1 |
2.2 |
| Biliary Clearance (ml/min/mg protein) |
0.3 +/- 0.1 |
1.8 |
| Biliary Excretion Index (%) |
40 +/- 3 |
37 |
| |
|
|
| Digoxin |
| |
Example 6 Data |
Bi et al. (2006) |
| Uptake Rate (pmol/min/mg protein) |
1.9 +/- 0.1 |
0.7-1.5 |
| Biliary Clearance (ml/min/mg protein) |
0.4 +/- 0.1 |
0.6-1.5 |
| Biliary Excretion Index (%) |
41 +/- 4 |
37-63 |
| Rosuvastatin |
| |
Example 6 Data |
Bi et al. (2006) |
| Uptake Rate (pmol/min/mg protein) |
11.4 +/- 1.3 |
15-26 |
| Biliary Clearance (ml/min/mg protein) |
6.0 +/- 0.7 |
4-12 |
| Biliary Excretion Index (%) |
52 +/- 7 |
43-58 |
| |
|
|
| Pravastatin |
|
|
| |
Example 6 Data |
Bi et al. (2006) |
| Uptake Rate (pmol/min/mg protein) |
0.6 +/- 0.1 |
n/a |
| Biliary Clearance (ml/min/mg protein) |
0.38 +/- 0.04 |
n/a |
| Biliary Excretion Index (%) |
14 +/- 1 |
n/a |
Example 6: Uptake and Biliary Excretion in Rat Hepatocyte Cocultures.
[0127] Hepatocyte-stromal cell cocultures according to Example 1 were prepared using primary
rat hepatocytes (Lifetech®) and used to measure uptake rates of five compounds: taurocholic
acid (taurocholate), estradiol-glucuronide, digonxin, rosuvastatin, and pravastatin.
The single well method of assessing biliary clearance of the invention was used.
[0128] A coculture was exposed to each tested compound in culture media at concentrations
of taurocholic acid (taurocholate) at 2uM, estradiol-glucuronide at 2uM, digoxin at
2uM, rosuvastatin at 2uM, and pravastatin at 5uM for 20 minutes. The media was then
removed (collection #1) and stored for analysis of remaining compound. The cultures
were washed twice with buffer solution (collections #2 and #3) and each wash solution
was stored for analysis of remaining taurocholate. The cells were then exposed to
HEPES buffer containing latrunculin at a concentration of 5uM for 30 minutes, which
functions to disrupt the canaliculi present in the cultures but does not lyse cells
in the coculture. This releases taurocholate accumulated in the bile of the canaliculi.
At the end of the incubation period the culture media was collected (collection #4).
The cells were then exposed to deionized water which functions to disrupt the cellular
membrane and release the compound accumulated in the cellular compartment (collection
#5). Because any compound present in the canaliculi was already collected in collection
#4, collection #5 contains any compound present in the cell but not including any
present in the canaliculi. The concentration of compound in collection #4 and collection
5 was determined using LC-MS/MS as in Example 4. The data is presented in Figure 9-13
using the same format as used in Figures 4-8.
[0129] The results for taurocholic acid (taurocholate) are shown in in Figure 9, the results
for rosuvastatin are shown in Figure 10, the results for estradiol-glucuronide are
shown in Figure 11, the results for digonxin are showin in Figure 12, and the results
for pravastatin are shown in Figure 13. Equation 2 was used to calculate the BEI for
each compound in this system. The measured BEI of taurocholic acid (taurocholate)
was 60% (Figure 9), the measured BEI of rosuvastatin was 72% (Figure 10), the measured
BEI of estradiol-glucuronide was 40% (Figure 11), the measured BEI of digonxin was
67% (Figure 12), and the measured BEI of pravastatin was 58% (Figure 13).
[0130] These data are summarized in Table 2. The values provided for
in vitro CL
bile were calculated by converting the intrinsic Cl
int, bile values to ml/min/kg based on 200 mg protein/g liver and 40 g liver/kg (See Seglen,
1976). Interestingly, for the compounds where in vivo data is available the results
of this example are within four fold for one compound and 2 fold in the other. This
is a good in vivo to in vitro correlation for the scaled numbers and demonstrates
the in vivo relevance of the methods.
TABLE 2
| Substrate |
Example 6 |
Example 6 |
Lundquist (2014) |
Fold Difference |
| Rat In Vitro PK |
Rat In Vitro PK |
Rat In Vivo PK |
| |
Intrinsic CL int, biliary (µl/min/mg protein) |
Predicted CL biliary (ml/min/kg) |
In Vivo CL biliary (ml/min/kg) |
|
| Digoxin |
0.31 ± 0.02 |
2.5 ± 0.12 |
0.8 ± 0.3 |
3.1 |
| Rosuvastatin |
3.5 ± 0.3 |
27.6 ± 2.1 |
48.0 ± 10.8 |
0.6 |
| Estradiol-Gluc |
2.7 ± 0.1 |
21.6 ± 0.4 |
n/a |
|
| Taurocholate |
8.4 ± 0.6 |
67.1 ± 4.8 |
n/a |
|
| Pravastatin |
0.29 ± 0.02 |
2.3 ± 0.14 |
n/a |
|
Example 7: Transporter Inhibition Assays
[0131] Direct inhibition of efflux transporters by xenobiotics or drugs leading to acquired
cholestasis and drug-induced liver injury (DILI) is a major obstacle in drug development.
Understanding the potential drug-drug interaction liabilities of a compound based
on in vitro testin is, therefore, desirable. In this experiment human primary hepatocyte
cocultures made according to Example 1 were used in the direct measurement one culture
assay format of the invention to characterize BSEP and BCRP inhibition. The probe
substrates used were 2 µM taurocholic acid (BSEP efflux transporter) and 2 µM rosuvastatin
(BCRP efflux transporter). Cyclosporin A is a known BSEP inhibitor and was used at
0-20 µM. Ritonavir is a known BCRP inhibitor and was used at 0-100 µM. Erythromycin
Estolate is a known broad spectrum inhibitor and was used at 50 µM. In order to asses
inhibition cultures were first preincubated in the indicated inhibitor for 20 min
and then incubated in the presence of the substrate and inhibitor for an additional
20 min. The cultures were then washed twice to remove excess substrate and inhibitor
and the procotol proceeded as in Example 5. The data for BSEP inhibition by cyclosporin
A are shown in Figure 14. Cyclosporin A inhibited BSEP mediated transport of taurocholate
with an IC
50 of 0.46 µM. The data for BCRP inhibition by ritonavir are shown in Figure 15. Ritonavir
inhibited BCRP mediated transport of ritonavir with an IC
50 of 0.50 µM. Inhibition by erythromycin estolate was performed in the same way except
that substrates taurocholate and ritonavir were added together. As shown in Figure
16, erythromycin estolate completely inhibited BSEP mediated transport of taurocholate
and significantly inhibited BCRP mediated transport of ritonavir. Taken together,
these data demonstrate the utility of the the direct measurement one culture assay
format of the invention for characterizing inhibition of efflux transporters by xenobiotics
or drugs. [EN: Please add any additional conclusions or clarifications.]
Example 8: Reproducibility
[0132] In contrast to prior art methods, the methods of this invention comprise direct measurement
of biliary excretion of a chemical entity in a one culture assay format. The accuracy
and reproducibility of this assay format was demonstrated by performing three independent
assays using human hepatocyte stromal cell coculture according to Example 1, for each
of taurocholate and pravastatin. The data for taurocholic acid are shown in Table
3 and Figure 17. The data for pravastatin are shown in Table 4 and Figure 18. A statistical
analysis presented in Table 5 indicates that there is no statistically-significant
variation (P<0.05) in the results of the replicate assay results for each compound.
TABLE 3: Taurocholic Acid
| |
Bile |
Cell |
| |
Mean |
SD |
Mean |
SD |
| Exp. 1 |
541.90 |
7.22 |
273.08 |
86.93 |
| Exp. 2 |
556.08 |
22.47 |
423.21 |
25.08 |
| Exp. 3 |
543.31 |
50.15 |
151.91 |
13.37 |
TABLE 4: Pravastatin
| |
Bile |
Cell |
| |
Mean |
SD |
Mean |
SD |
| Exp. 1 |
1.69 |
0.27 |
10.58 |
0.89 |
| Exp. 2 |
4.38 |
0.61 |
16.99 |
8.31 |
| Exp. 3 |
2.19 |
0.09 |
7.82 |
3.01 |
TABLE 5: Statistical Analysis
| Substrate |
Substrate Location |
P value |
Data Comparison |
Results |
| Taurocholic Acid |
Bile |
0.62 |
exp1 vs exp2 |
no significant difference |
| |
Bile |
0.98 |
exp1 vs exp3 |
no significant difference |
| |
Bile |
0.63 |
exp2 vs exp3 |
no significant difference |
| |
|
|
|
|
| Taurocholic Acid |
Cell |
0.31 |
exp1 vs exp2 |
no significant difference |
| |
Cell |
0.26 |
exp1 vs exp3 |
no significant difference |
| |
Cell |
0.06 |
exp2 vs exp3 |
no significant difference |
| |
|
|
|
|
| Pravastatin |
Bile |
0.06 |
exp1 vs exp2 |
no significant difference |
| |
Bile |
0.30 |
exp1 vs exp3 |
no significant difference |
| |
Bile |
0.14 |
exp2 vs exp3 |
no significant difference |
| |
|
|
|
|
| Pravastatin |
Cell |
0.50 |
exp1 vs exp2 |
no significant difference |
| |
Cell |
0.50 |
exp1 vs exp3 |
no significant difference |
| |
Cell |
0.25 |
exp2 vs exp3 |
no significant difference |